文献速递脑血管病

三种侧支循环评分与临床结局关联的比较:HERMES 协作研究

Comparison of Three Scores of Collateral Status for Their Association With Clinical Outcome: The HERMES Collaboration.
PubMed 文献 · Stroke · 2022-10-17

该研究汇总 7 项随机对照试验的 1147 例大血管闭塞患者数据,比较三种 CTA 侧支评分与两种成像技术对 3 个月功能独立的预测能力。单时相 CTA 上区域侧支评分和区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分的预测准确性优于 Tan 侧支评分;多时相/动态 CTA 上各评分表现相似。所有侧支等级患者均从血管内取栓中获益,单时相 CTA 采集时间独立影响侧支评估。

要点

  • 单时相 CTA 上区域侧支评分(AUC 0.63)和区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分(AUC 0.62)预测 3 个月功能独立优于 Tan 侧支评分(AUC 0.60)。
  • 多时相/动态 CTA 上三种侧支评分预测功能结局表现相似(AUC 均为 0.61)。
  • 所有侧支等级患者均从血管内取栓中获益,未发现侧支状态对取栓疗效的修饰作用(P=0.41)。

核心结论

  • 在高度选择卒中患者数据集中,单时相 CTA 上使用区域侧支评分可能最准确预测功能结局,而时间分辨 CTA 上侧支评分类型不影响预测。
  • 所有侧支等级患者均从血管内取栓中获益。
  • 单时相 CTA 采集时间独立影响侧支评估。

研究设计与样本

  • HERMES 协作的患者水平数据汇总分析,纳入 7 项比较血管内取栓与标准内科治疗的随机对照试验中大血管闭塞患者。
  • 共纳入 1147 例,其中 948 例(82.7%)基线使用单时相 CTA,199 例(17.3%)使用多时相/动态 CTA。
  • 评估三种 CTA 侧支评分(Tan 侧支评分、区域侧支评分、区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分)和两种成像技术。
  • 主要结局为卒中后 3 个月功能独立(改良 Rankin 量表评分 0-2)。

主要发现

  • 三种侧支评分均显示侧支状态越好,3 个月功能结局越好。
  • 单时相 CTA 上,区域侧支评分 AUC 0.63,区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分 AUC 0.62,均优于 Tan 侧支评分 AUC 0.60(P<0.001 和 P=0.02)。
  • 多时相/动态 CTA 上,区域侧支评分 AUC 0.61、区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分 AUC 0.61 与 Tan 侧支评分 AUC 0.61 表现相似(P=0.93 和 P=0.91)。
  • 未发现侧支状态(区域侧支评分)对血管内取栓疗效的修饰作用(P=0.41)。
  • 单时相 CTA 采集时间独立影响侧支评估,较早采集的单时相 CTA 预测不良侧支比例更高,反之亦然。

关键数值与推荐

  • 单时相 CTA 上区域侧支评分 AUC 0.63,区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分 AUC 0.62,Tan 侧支评分 AUC 0.60(P<0.001 和 P=0.02)。
  • 多时相/动态 CTA 上区域侧支评分 AUC 0.61,区域 Alberta 卒中项目早期 CT 评分侧支评分 AUC 0.61,Tan 侧支评分 AUC 0.61(P=0.93 和 P=0.91)。
  • 侧支状态对取栓疗效修饰作用检验 P=0.41。

临床怎么用

  • 在单时相 CTA 上可考虑使用区域侧支评分预测功能结局,但原文未据此给出推荐。
  • 原文结论指出所有侧支等级患者均从血管内取栓中获益。
  • 单时相 CTA 采集时间影响侧支评估,解读时需注意采集时间。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Leptomeningeal collateral status on baseline computed tomographic angiography (CTA) is associated with clinical outcome after acute ischemic stroke treatment. However, assessment of collateral status is not uniform. To compare 3 different CTA collateral scores (CS) and imaging techniques about their association with clinical outcome. METHODS: Pooled analysis of patient-level data from the Highly Effective Reperfusion Using Multiple Endovascular Devices collaboration. Patients with large vessel occlusion from 7 randomized controlled trials that compared endovascular thrombectomy with standard medical care were included. Three different CS (Tan CS, regional CS [rCS], and regional Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score CS) and 2 imaging techniques (single-phase [sCTA] and multiphase/dynamic CTA) were evaluated. Functional independence (modified Rankin Scale score 0-2) at 3 months poststroke was the primary outcome. Furthermore, we assessed the effect of sCTA image acquisition time on collateral status assessment using an adjusted ordinal logistic regression model to obtain predicted values for the trichotomized rCS. RESULTS: Among 1147 pooled patients, 948 (82.7%) had sCTA and 199 (17.3%) multiphase/dynamic CTA as baseline angiography. With all 3 collateral scales, better CSs were associated with better 3-month functional outcome. With sCTA images, the rCS (area under the curve [AUC] 0.63) and regional Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score CS (AUC 0.62) better predicted functional outcome than the Tan CS (AUC 0.60, respectively; P<0.001 and P=0.02). With multiphase/dynamic CTA images, all collateral scales performed similarly in predicting functional outcome (rCS [AUC 0.61]; regional Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score CS [AUC 0.61] versus Tan CS [AUC 0.61], respectively; P=0.93 and P=0.91). Overall, no endovascular thrombectomy treatment effect modification by collateral status (rCS) was demonstrated (P=0.41). sCTA timing independently influenced CS assessment. On earlier timed sCTA, the predicted proportions of scans with poor collaterals was higher and vice versa. CONCLUSIONS: In this data set of highly selected patients with stroke, using a regional CS on sCTA likely allows for the most accurate prediction of functional outcome while on time-resolved CTA, the type of CS did not matter. Patients across all collateral grades benefit from endovascular thrombectomy. sCTA timing independently influenced CS assessment.

来源:Stroke,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gensicke H, Al-Ajlan F, Fladt J, et al. Comparison of Three Scores of Collateral Status for Their Association With Clinical Outcome: The HERMES Collaboration. Stroke. 2022. PMID: 36252099. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.122.039717

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。