成人烟雾病直接、间接及联合颅内外血运重建术:更新的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析检索至2021年12月,纳入143篇文章,比较成人烟雾病直接、间接及联合搭桥的临床与血管造影结局。汇总分析显示直接和联合搭桥在早期卒中、晚期卒中、晚期脑出血及良好结局方面优于间接搭桥,间接搭桥在早期脑出血方面更优。基于低质量证据,作者给出强推荐。
要点
- 直接和联合搭桥在晚期卒中、晚期出血及良好结局方面优于间接搭桥。
- 间接搭桥在早期脑出血方面优于联合和直接搭桥。
- 联合搭桥在良好结局方面优于间接搭桥(OR 2.06)。
核心结论
- 联合和直接搭桥对晚期卒中和出血的益处显著优于间接搭桥。
- 联合搭桥在良好结局方面优于间接搭桥。
- 基于低质量证据,作者给出强推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索至2021年12月,遵循PRISMA指南。
- 共纳入143篇文章,包括3827例直接搭桥、3826例间接搭桥和3801例联合搭桥。
- 平均随访时间3.59±2.93年。
- 使用纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表和牛津循证医学中心量表评估研究质量。
主要发现
- 直接搭桥对比间接搭桥:早期卒中OR 0.62(0.48-0.79),P<0.0001;晚期卒中OR 0.44(0.32-0.59),P<0.0001;晚期脑出血OR 0.56(0.42-0.74),P<0.0001;良好结局OR 3.1(2.5-3.8),P=0.0001。
- 联合搭桥对比间接搭桥:早期卒中OR 0.53(0.41-0.69),P<0.0001;晚期卒中OR 0.28(0.2-0.41),P<0.0001;晚期脑出血OR 0.41(0.3-0.56),P<0.0001;良好结局OR 3.1(2.8-4.3),P=0.0001。
- 早期脑出血:间接搭桥优于联合搭桥(OR 3.1 [1.7-5.6],P<0.0001)和直接搭桥(OR 4.12 [2.34-7.25],P<0.0001)。
- Meta分析显示直接搭桥对比间接搭桥:晚期卒中OR 0.37(0.23-0.60),P<0.001;晚期出血OR 0.49(0.31-0.77),P=0.002。
- Meta分析显示联合搭桥对比间接搭桥:晚期卒中OR 0.23(0.12-0.43),P<0.00001;晚期出血OR 0.30(0.18-0.49),P<0.00001;良好结局OR 2.06(1.18-3.58),P=0.01。
关键数值与推荐
- 基于GRADE系统,作者给出强推荐,但证据质量低。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出具体临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Moyamoya disease is a chronic, progressive cerebrovascular disease involving occlusion or stenosis of the terminal portion of the internal carotid artery. We conducted an updated systematic review and meta-analysis to investigate clinical and angiographic outcomes comparing direct, combined, and indirect bypass for the treatment of moyamoya disease in adults. METHODS: Two independent authors performed Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guided literature searches in December 2021 to identify articles reporting clinical/angiographic outcomes in adult moyamoya disease patients undergoing bypass. Primary end points used were ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes, clinical outcomes, and angiographic revascularization. Study quality was evaluated with Newcastle-Ottawa and the Oxford Center for Evidence-Based Medicine scales. RESULTS: Four thousand four hundred fifty seven articles were identified in the initial search; 143 articles were analyzed. There were 3827 direct, 3826 indirect, and 3801 combined bypasses. Average length of follow-up was 3.59±2.93 years. Pooled analysis significantly favored direct (odds ratio [OR], 0.62 [0.48-0.79]; P<0.0001; OR, 0.44 [0.32-0.59]; P<0.0001; OR, 0.56 [0.42-0.74]; P<0.0001; OR, 3.1 [2.5-3.8]; P=0.0001) and combined (OR, 0.53 [0.41-0.69]; P<0.0001; OR, 0.28 [0.2-0.41]; P<0.0001; OR, 0.41 [0.3-0.56]; P<0.0001; OR, 3.1 [2.8-4.3]; P=0.0001) over indirect bypass for early stroke, late stroke, late intracerebral hemorrhage, and favorable outcomes, respectively. Indirect bypass was favored over combined (OR, 3.1 [1.7-5.6]; P<0.0001) and direct (OR, 4.12 [2.34-7.25]; P<0.0001) for early intracerebral hemorrhage. The meta-analysis significantly favored direct (OR, 0.37 [0.23-0.60]; P<0.001; OR, 0.49 [0.31-0.77]; P=0.002) and combined (OR, 0.23 [0.12-0.43]; P<0.00001; OR, 0.30 [0.18-0.49]; P<0.00001) bypass over indirect bypass for late stroke and late hemorrhage, respectively. Combined bypass was favored over indirect bypass for favorable outcomes (OR, 2.06 [1.18-3.58]; P=0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Based on combined meta-analysis (43 articles) and pooled analysis (143 articles), the existing literature indicates that combined and direct bypasses have significant benefits for patients suffering from late stroke and hemorrhage versus indirect bypass. Combined bypass was favored over indirect bypass for favorable outcomes. This is a strong recommendation based on low-quality evidence when utilizing the Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation system. These findings have important implications for bypass strategy selection.
引用
- Nguyen VN, Motiwala M, Elarjani T, et al. Direct, Indirect, and Combined Extracranial-to-Intracranial Bypass for Adult Moyamoya Disease: An Updated Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Stroke. 2022. PMID: 36134563. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.122.039584
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。