即时通讯工具评估急性卒中脑影像的可靠性
这项前瞻性研究将81例急性卒中患者的104幅脑CT及CT血管成像图像经智能手机拍摄后通过WhatsApp发送,由2名神经科医生和2名神经放射科医生评估,以2名经验丰富的神经放射科医生使用完整放射设备评估为金标准。结果显示脑出血诊断的观察者间信度完美(κ=1),蛛网膜下腔出血信度略低,卒中模拟病诊断信度变异较大,大血管闭塞检测为中等至较高度信度。
要点
- 脑出血诊断的观察者间信度完美(所有4名评估者κ=1)。
- 大血管闭塞检测的信度为中等至较高度(κ=0.48至0.63)。
- 早期梗死征象和卒中模拟病的远程诊断信度较低。
核心结论
- 卒中神经科医生能够可靠地从通过智能手机拍摄并经即时通讯工具发送的CT图像中提取脑出血相关信息。
- 早期梗死征象和卒中模拟病的远程诊断信度较低。
- 研究制定了考虑数据保护的图像采集标准。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入81例急性卒中症状患者的104幅脑部图像(CT和CT血管成像)。
- 由2名神经科医生和2名神经放射科医生通过WhatsApp评估图像,以2名经验丰富的神经放射科医生使用完整放射设备评估为金标准。
- 统计分析包括计算Cohen κ值。
主要发现
- 脑出血诊断的观察者间信度完美(所有4名评估者κ=1)。
- 蛛网膜下腔出血的观察者间信度略低(评估者1、2、3的κ=1;评估者4的κ=0.88)。
- 卒中模拟病诊断的观察者间信度变异较大(κ在0.32至1之间)。
- Alberta卒中项目早期CT评分差异在评估者间总体相当,未超过3至4分,无明显离群值。
- 大血管闭塞检测的观察者间信度为中等至较高度(评估者1的κ=0.48,评估者2的κ=0.62,评估者3和4的κ=0.63)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The use of instant messenger applications among physicians has become common in acute stroke management, especially in developing countries. Photos or video sequences of brain computed tomography (CT) scans are being sent to receive real-time support in assessing radiological findings. We analyzed whether instant messaging-based evaluation is precise enough to extract relevant information from the images. METHODS: In this prospective study, anonymized videos and photos of CT and CT angiography scans of patients with symptoms of acute stroke were recorded from the diagnostic monitor using a smartphone. Two neurologists and 2 neuroradiologists performed evaluation of the images using WhatsApp. The gold standard was set by 2 experienced neuroradiologists who evaluated the CT images with their full radiological equipment. Statistical analysis included the calculation of Cohen kappa (κ). RESULTS: A total of 104 brain images (derived from 81 patients) were included. All 4 raters performed with a perfect (κ=1) interobserver reliability in diagnosing intracerebral hemorrhage. For subarachnoid hemorrhage, interobserver reliability was slightly lower (raters 1, 2, and 3, κ=1; rater 4, κ=0.88). For diagnosing stroke mimics, interobserver reliability showed considerable variations (κ between 0.32 and 1). Alberta Stroke Program Early CT Score differences overall were comparable between raters and did not exceed 3 to 4 points without noticeable outliers. All raters performed with a moderate-to-substantial interobserver reliability for detecting large vessel occlusions (κ=0.48 in rater 1, κ=0.62 in rater 2, and κ=0.63 in raters 3 and 4). CONCLUSIONS: Stroke neurologists can reliably extract information on intracerebral hemorrhage from CT images recorded via smartphone and sent through instant messaging tools. Remote diagnosis of early infarct signs and stroke mimics was less reliable. We developed a standard for the acquisition of images, taking data protection into account.
引用
- Kalra LP, Khatter H, Kulkarni A, et al. Reliability of Instant Messaging-Based Evaluation of Brain Imaging in Acute Stroke. Stroke. 2022. PMID: 35506382. doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.121.037274
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。