文献速递癫痫神经重症与神经感染

住院连续脑电图中的癫痫发作检测:人工判读与自动判读的比较

Seizure Detection in Continuous Inpatient EEG: A Comparison of Human vs Automated Review.
PubMed 文献 · Neurology · 2022-04-11

本研究在重症监护连续脑电图(EEG)中比较Persyst自动癫痫检测与人工判读的准确性。试点队列85份记录229次发作中,单次发作检测敏感度0.50、阳性预测值0.60;记录层面敏感度试点0.78、扩展0.91,阳性预测值试点0.40、扩展0.08,阴性预测值试点0.88、扩展0.97。局灶起源发作记录敏感度高于全面起源(0.93 vs 0.85,p=0.012)。

要点

  • 单次发作检测敏感度0.50、阳性预测值0.60,假阴性和假阳性均存在。
  • 记录层面敏感度试点0.78、扩展0.91,阴性预测值试点0.88、扩展0.97。
  • 局灶起源发作记录敏感度高于全面起源(0.93 vs 0.85,p=0.012)。

核心结论

  • 在重症监护连续EEG中,自动检测单次发作的假阴性和假阳性率使其作为临床发作报警的效用存疑。
  • 在整份EEG记录层面,无自动检测能准确预测无真性发作的记录。
  • Persyst自动癫痫检测的真正价值似乎在于低风险EEG的分诊。

研究设计与样本

  • 比较Persyst自动癫痫检测(版本12和13)与人工判读,先在85份EEG记录229次发作的试点队列中比较,后在7,924份EEG记录的扩展队列中比较。
  • 计算单次发作(试点队列)和整份记录(试点及扩展队列)的敏感度、特异度、阳性预测值和阴性预测值。
  • 评估与自动癫痫检测准确性相关的EEG特征。

主要发现

  • 试点队列中,自动检测单次发作的敏感度为0.50,阳性预测值为0.60。
  • 记录层面敏感度试点队列0.78、扩展队列0.91;阳性预测值试点队列0.40、扩展队列0.08;阴性预测值试点队列0.88、扩展队列0.97。
  • 软件版本12与13表现相似。
  • 含局灶起源发作的记录敏感度高于含全面起源发作的记录(0.93 vs 0.85,p=0.012)。

临床怎么用

  • 自动检测单次发作的假阴性和假阳性率使其作为临床发作报警的效用存疑。
  • 无自动检测可准确预测无真性发作的EEG记录。
  • 自动癫痫检测的真正价值似乎在于低风险EEG的分诊。

局限性

  • 本研究提供II级证据表明自动癫痫检测程序不能准确识别含癫痫发作的EEG记录。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The aim of this work was to test the accuracy of Persyst commercially available automated seizure detection in critical care EEG by comparing automated seizure detections to human review in a manually reviewed cohort and on a large scale. METHODS: Automated seizure detections (Persyst versions 12 and 13) were compared to human review in a pilot cohort of 229 seizures from 85 EEG records and then in an expanded cohort of 7,924 EEG records. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were calculated for individual seizures (pilot cohort) and for entire records (pilot and expanded cohorts). We assessed EEG features associated with the accuracy of automated seizure detections. RESULTS: In the pilot cohort, accuracy of automated detection for individual seizures was modest (sensitivity 0.50, PPV 0.60). At the record level (did the recording contain seizures or not?), sensitivity was higher (pilot cohort 0.78, expanded cohort 0.91), PPV was low (pilot cohort 0.40, expanded cohort 0.08), and NPV was high (pilot cohort 0.88, expanded cohort 0.97). Different software versions (version 12 vs 13) performed similarly. Sensitivity was higher for records containing focal-onset seizures compared to generalized-onset seizures (0.93 vs 0.85, p = 0.012). DISCUSSION: In critical care continuous EEG recordings, automated detection of individual seizures had rates of both false negatives and false positives that bring into question its utility as a seizure alarm in clinical practice. At the level of entire EEG records, the absence of automated detections accurately predicted EEG records without true seizures. The true value of Persyst automated seizure detection appears to lie in triaging of low-risk EEGs. CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE: This study provides Class II evidence that an automated seizure detection program cannot accurately identify EEG records that contain seizures.

来源:Neurology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ganguly TM, Ellis CA, Tu D, et al. Seizure Detection in Continuous Inpatient EEG: A Comparison of Human vs Automated Review. Neurology. 2022. PMID: 35410905. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000200267

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。