标准化CT最大主动脉直径测量方法可减少专家间差异与不一致并提高准确性
本研究比较基于正交平面与中心线血流两种方法测量148例腹主动脉瘤CT最大直径的一致性,由三位经验丰富的阅片者按标准化方案测量。两种方法在3 mm内一致率高且组内相关系数高,但与原始报告及外院报告相比不一致率分别达10%和20%以上。标准化测量方法可减少差异与不一致。
要点
- 正交平面法与中心线法测量AAA最大直径在3 mm内一致性均高,差异无统计学意义。
- 与原始报告和外院报告相比,阅片者间测量不一致率分别≥10%和≥20%。
- 标准化最大直径测量方法可减少不同方法间的差异与不一致。
核心结论
- 正交平面与中心线测量方法在高容量中心具有同等高的一致性和低变异,3 mm内一致性高。
- 与官方阅片报告相比不一致率高,可能显著改变患者管理及结局。
- 标准化最大直径测量方法可减少不同方法间的差异与不一致。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入148例腹主动脉瘤的CT血管造影最大直径,由血管外科医生、放射科医生和影像心内科医生三位经验丰富阅片者测量。
- 采用两种标准化方案:基于正交平面的多平面重建,以及基于3D主动脉重建创建中心线血流管腔并垂直于该管腔横截面取径。
- 采用组内相关系数和Bland-Altman分析评估测量方法的一致性与可靠性。
主要发现
- 队列平均年龄75岁,主动脉直径范围3.8至9.6 cm。
- 正交读数法在86%至92%的测量中3 mm内一致,中心线读数法为88%至94%,差异无统计学意义。
- 方法间及阅片者间组内相关系数均高:方法内一致性0.96至0.97,阅片者内一致性0.96至0.98。
- 与原始报告和外院报告相比,≥10%的原始报告测量和≥20%的外院报告测量在阅片者间存在不一致。
关键数值与推荐
- 正交读数法3 mm内一致性为86%至92%,中心线读数法为88%至94%,差异无统计学意义。
- 方法内组内相关系数为0.96至0.97,阅片者内为0.96至0.98。
- 与原始报告相比不一致率≥10%,与外院报告相比不一致率≥20%。
临床怎么用
- 在高容量中心,正交平面法与中心线法均可用于AAA最大直径测量,二者一致性相当。
- 应关注与原始报告及外院报告间的高不一致率,避免因测量差异影响患者管理决策。
- 推荐采用标准化测量方案以减少不同方法和阅片者间的差异与不一致。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is no consensus on the method of obtaining abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) maximum diameters based on computed tomographic angiography, and the reproducibility and accuracy of different methods have recently been debated due to advancements in imaging. This study compared the two most common methods based on orthogonal planes and centerline of flow to determine the discordances and accuracy amongst experiences readers. METHODS: The computed tomographic angiography max diameters of 148 AAAs were measured by three experienced observers, including a vascular surgeon, a radiologist and an imaging cardiologist. Observers used two different methods with standardized protocols: multiplanar reformations based on orthogonal planes, and a software using 3D aortic reconstructions to create centerline flow lumen providing diameters based on cross sections perpendicular to this lumen. Agreements and reliability of measurement methods were assessed by intra-class correlation coefficient and Bland - Altman analysis. Discordances between measurements of the methods and the original reported measurement, as well as outside hospitals were compared. RESULTS: The average age of the cohort was 75 years and aortic diameters ranged from 3.8 to 9.6 cm. For orthogonal readings, there were agreements within 3 mm between 86% and 92% of the time, while centerline - reading agreement was between 88% and 94%, which was not statistically significant. The intra-class correlation coefficient was high between method type and between readers. Within methods, agreement was between 0.96 and 0.97, while within - reader agreement measures was between 0.96 and 0.98. In comparison to the original and the outside hospital reports, 10% ≥ of the original and 20% ≥ of the outside hospital reported measurements were discordant between the readers. CONCLUSION: Maximal AAA measurements can have substantial variability leading to clinical significance and change in patient management and outcomes. Based on the results, orthogonal and centerline measurement methods have equally high agreements and concordance within 3 mm and low variations at a high volume center. However, when compared to the official read reports, there is high discordance rates that can significantly alter patient outcomes. A standardized method of measurement maximum diameter can reduce variations and discordances among different methods.
引用
- Perry JW, Schoenhagen P, Huang SSL, et al. Standardizing Methods of Reading CT Maximum Aortic Diameters Amongst Experts Reduces Variations and Discordance, Improving Accuracy. Ann Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34656714. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.07.049
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。