四种可回收下腔静脉滤器体外血栓捕获效率比较
本研究利用静脉血流模拟装置,比较Denali、OptEase、Celect和Option四种可回收下腔静脉滤器对10种不同尺寸(2mm×10mm至6mm×20mm)血栓的体外捕获效率。结果显示,在20mm和25mm直径模拟下腔静脉中,较大血栓(≥4×10mm或≥6×10mm)时四种滤器捕获率均达100%;较小血栓(≤3×20mm或≤5×20mm)时捕获率存在显著差异,Denali最高;25mm直径下较小血栓(≤5×10mm)捕获率显著低于20mm直径,Option变化最大。
要点
- 较大血栓时四种滤器捕获率均达100%,较小血栓时捕获率存在显著差异。
- 20mm和25mm模拟下腔静脉中,Denali对较小血栓的捕获效率最高。
- 25mm直径下较小血栓捕获率显著低于20mm直径,Option下降最明显。
核心结论
- 四种滤器血栓捕获效率存在显著差异,较小血栓捕获率显著低于较大血栓,25mm直径模拟下腔静脉捕获率显著低于20mm直径。
研究设计与样本
- 体外实验研究,使用静脉血流模拟装置比较四种市售可回收下腔静脉滤器(Denali、OptEase、Celect、Option)对10种尺寸血栓的捕获效率。
主要发现
- 20mm直径模拟下腔静脉中,≥4×10mm血栓时四种滤器捕获率均100%;≤3×20mm血栓时捕获率显著不同,Denali最高,依次为OptEase、Celect、Option。
- 25mm直径模拟下腔静脉中,≥6×10mm血栓时四种滤器捕获率均100%;≤5×20mm血栓时捕获率显著不同,Denali最高。
- 25mm直径下≤5×10mm血栓的捕获率显著低于20mm直径,Option变化最大,依次为Celect、OptEase、Denali。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择滤器时需考虑血栓大小和静脉直径,Denali在体外对小血栓和较大直径下腔静脉的捕获效率较高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We compared the in vitro clot-capturing efficiencies (CCEs) of commercially available retrievable inferior vena cava (IVC) filters. METHODS: Four types of commercially available retrievable IVC filters were included in the present study: Denali (BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ), OptEase (Cordis Corp, Hialeah, Fla), Celect (Cook Medical, Bloomington, Ind), and Option (Argon Medical Devices, Frisco, Tex). The CCE of each IVC filter for 10 different size clots, ranging from 2 mm × 10 mm to 6 mm × 20 mm, was analyzed using a venous flow simulator. RESULTS: When ≥4 × 10-mm clots were used, the CCEs were 100% for all four types of IVC filters in a 20-mm-diameter simulated IVC filter. However, when ≤3 × 20-mm clots were used, the CCEs were significantly different among the four types of filters in a 20-mm-diameter simulated IVC, with the Denali showing the highest CCE, followed by the OptEase, Celect, and Option. When ≥6 × 10-mm clots were used, the CCEs were 100% for all four types of IVC filters in the 25-mm-diameter simulated IVC. However, when ≤5 × 20-mm clots were used, the CCEs were significantly different among the four types of filters in the 25-mm-diameter simulated IVC, with the Denali showing the highest CCE. When ≤5 × 10-mm clots were used, the CCEs were significantly lower in the 25-mm-diameter simulated IVC than in the 20-mm-diameter simulated IVC for all four types of IVC filters, with Option showing the greatest change in CCEs, followed by the Celect, OptEase, and Denali. CONCLUSIONS: The CCEs were significantly different among the four IVC filters and were significantly lower for the smaller size clots than for the larger size clots and for the larger diameter simulated IVC than for the smaller diameter simulated IVC.
引用
- Zhao H, Zhang X, Tsauo J, et al. Comparison of the in vitro clot-capturing efficiencies of commercially available retrievable inferior vena cava filters. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2021. PMID: 34487891. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2021.08.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。