文献速递外周动脉疾病

血管外科学会CLTI客观性能目标在单纯伤口护理患者中可达到

The Society for Vascular Surgery Objective Performance Goals for Critical Limb Ischemia are attainable in select patients with ischemic wounds managed with wound care alone.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2021-09-17

本研究评估仅用伤口护理的非手术管理能否达到血管外科学会为CLTI血运重建设定的客观性能目标(OPG)。2013-2017年349例CLTI患者中,21%仅接受伤口护理;该组2年生存率65%、无截肢生存51%、大截肢19%、主要不良心脏事件17%。伤口护理组2年死亡风险高13%,但肢体丧失风险低12%。

要点

  • 约21%的CLTI患者仅接受伤口护理,其2年无截肢生存率为51%。
  • 伤口护理组2年死亡风险较血运重建组高13%,但肢体丧失风险低12%。
  • 单纯伤口护理在部分CLTI患者中可达到与血运重建相当的保肢效果。

核心结论

  • 在部分CLTI患者中,单纯伤口护理可达到血管外科学会设定的客观性能目标。
  • 伤口护理组2年生存率65%、无截肢生存率51%、大截肢率19%、主要不良心脏事件率17%。
  • 伤口护理组2年死亡风险高13%,但肢体丧失风险低12%。
  • 需要多中心或前瞻性研究验证,但本研究显示相当的甚至更好的保肢率是可能的。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,纳入2013-2017年单中心349例新发CLTI患者(符合血流动力学和症状标准)。
  • 277例(79%)接受初次血运重建,72例(21%)仅接受伤口护理。
  • 主要结局为死亡,次要结局为肢体丧失和无截肢生存失败。
  • 使用协作目标最大似然估计法估计两组结局的风险差。

主要发现

  • 血运重建组股腘动脉病变比例高于伤口护理组(72% vs. 36%)。
  • 两组膝下动脉病变比例均较高(62% vs. 57%)。
  • 伤口护理组合并症更多:充血性心力衰竭(42% vs. 34%)、复杂性糖尿病(79% vs. 52%)、肥胖(33% vs. 19%)、终末期肾病(28% vs. 14%)。
  • 伤口护理组2年结局:生存65%、无截肢生存51%、大截肢19%、主要不良心脏事件17%。

关键数值与推荐

  • CLTI诊断依据血流动力学和症状标准。
  • Rutherford 4级占20%,Rutherford 5级占80%。
  • 血管外科学会2009年定义的OPG用于血运重建的1年通畅率基准。

临床怎么用

  • 综合治疗目标应涵盖血运重建和非血运重建患者,确保非手术患者也能达到适当结局。
  • 本队列2年结局可为非血运重建CLTI患者的预后评估提供参考。
  • 对于部分CLTI患者,单纯伤口护理可作为可选策略,但需权衡死亡风险增加。

局限性

  • 单中心回顾性研究,需要多中心或前瞻性研究验证。
  • 伤口护理组样本量较小(72例),且合并症负担更重。
  • 原文未报告统计学显著性检验结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: To set therapeutic benchmarks, in 2009 the Society for Vascular Surgery defined objective performance goals (OPG) for treatment of patients with chronic limb threatening ischemia (CLTI) with either open surgical bypass or endovascular intervention. The goal of these OPGs are to set standards of care from a revascularization standpoint and to provide performance benchmarks for 1 year patency rates for new endovascular therapies. While OPGs are useful in this regard, a critical decision point in the treatment of patients with CLTI is determining when revascularization is necessary. There is little guidance in the comprehensive treatment of this patient population, especially in the nonoperative cohort. Guidelines are needed for the CLTI patient population as a whole and not just those revascularized, and our aim was to assess whether CLTI OPGs could be attained with nonoperative management alone. METHODS: Our cohort included patients with an incident diagnosis of CLTI (by hemodynamic and symptomatic criteria) at our institution from 2013-2017. The primary outcome measured was mortality. Secondary outcomes were limb loss and failure of amputation-free survival. Descriptive statistics were used to define the 2 groups - patients undergoing primary revascularization and patients undergoing primary wound management. The risk difference in outcomes between the 2 groups was estimated using collaborative-targeted maximum likelihood estimation. RESULTS: Our cohort included 349 incident CLTI patients; 60% male, 51% white, mean age 63 +/- 13 years, 20% Rutherford 4, and 80% Rutherford 5. Most patients (277, 79%) underwent primary revascularization, and 72 (21%) were treated with wound care alone. Demographics and presenting characteristics were similar between groups. Although the revascularized patients were more likely to have femoropopliteal disease (72% vs. 36%), both groups had a high rate of infrapopliteal disease (62% vs. 57%). Not surprisingly, the patients in the revascularization group were less likely to have congestive heart failure (34% vs. 42%), complicated diabetes (52% vs. 79%), obesity (19% vs. 33%), and end stage renal disease (14% vs. 28%). In the wound care group, 2-year outcomes were 65% survival, 51% amputation free survival, 19% major limb amputation, and 17% major adverse cardiac event. The wound care cohort had a 13% greater risk of death at 2 years; however, the risk of limb loss at 2 years was 12% less in the wound care cohort. CONCLUSIONS: A comprehensive set treatment goals and expected amputation free survival outcomes can guide revascularization, but also assure that appropriate outcomes are achieved for patients treated without revascularization. The 2-year outcomes achieved in this cohort provide an estimate of outcomes for nonrevascularized CLTI patients. Although multi-center or prospective studies are needed, we demonstrate that equal, even improved, limb salvage rates are possible.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Crowner JR, Marston WA, Freeman NLB, et al. The Society for Vascular Surgery Objective Performance Goals for Critical Limb Ischemia are attainable in select patients with ischemic wounds managed with wound care alone. Ann Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34543715. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.06.034

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。