腹股沟切口闭合切口负压治疗降低血管外科手术部位感染风险的临床意义
单中心前瞻性队列研究纳入59例患者(67个切口),对比历史对照54例(60个切口),评估ciNPT对腹股沟切口SSI的影响。结果显示ciNPT组与标准护理组SSI发生率分别为12.1%和13.0%(OR 0.80, CI 0.26-2.48),无显著差异,深部SSI、再入院和再干预均无显著差异。结论认为常规使用ciNPT未能有效减少腹股沟伤口并发症。
要点
- ciNPT组与标准护理组腹股沟SSI发生率无显著差异。
- 深部SSI仅出现在再干预患者中,两组再干预率无差异。
- 常规使用ciNPT可能不必要,需基于风险因素选择患者。
核心结论
- 常规使用ciNPT未能有效减少腹股沟伤口并发症,未能复制既往研究的积极结果。
- ciNPT未降低深部SSI发生率,而深部SSI与最高发病率和费用相关。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心前瞻性队列研究,在荷兰非学术医院进行,纳入2019年1月至10月59例连续患者(67个切口)。
- 研究组接受6天ciNPT(PREVENA Incision Management System),与2018年1月至10月54例连续患者(60个切口)的历史回顾队列进行匹配比较。
- 标准护理组采用常规自粘敷料(10×15cm, Mepore)。
主要发现
- 血清肿、血肿、伤口裂开和SSI形成两组无显著差异。
- 腹股沟SSI在ciNPT组为12.1%,标准护理组为13.0%(OR 0.80, CI 0.26-2.48)。
- ciNPT组7例SSI中4例为深部SSI,标准护理组7例中2例为深部SSI(P>0.05)。
- 再入院和再干预发生率两组无显著差异,仅深部SSI导致再干预。
临床怎么用
- 基于本研究,不建议将ciNPT作为所有下肢血运重建和腹主动脉瘤手术腹股沟切口术后护理的新标准。
- 需进一步研究建立基于风险因素的模型以确定ciNPT的适应症。
局限性
- 单中心研究,样本量较小。
- 采用历史回顾性队列作为对照,可能存在选择偏倚。
- ciNPT组BMI显著高于标准护理组。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vascular surgery, especially lower limb revascularization surgery, has one of the highest rates of surgical complications, predominantly surgical site infections (SSI). Resulting in a significant burden of additional costs due to longer hospital stays, re-admissions and re-interventions, mainly attributable to deep incisional SSIs. Closed incisional negative pressure therapy (ciNPT) is a relatively new strategy in the postoperative management surgical wounds, aiming to reduce surgical wound complications. When discussing the clinical relevance of ciNPT, it is crucial to take into account the outcome of therapy as well as the additional costs related to ciNPT. Since, the additional costs must be justified by an associated decrease in the morbidity and costs associated with groin wound complications, which are particularly attributable to deep incisional SSIs. The current literature evaluating the beneficial effect of ciNPT in groin incisional vascular surgery, predominantly focusses on the decrease in superficial SSIs. Whereas this study aims to address and discuss the clinical relevance of ciNPT over conventional wound dressings, by separately evaluating and comparing the incidence of superficial and deep SSIs and their related re-admissions and re-interventions. METHODS: In this single center prospective cohort study performed in a non-academic hospital in The Netherlands, 59 consecutive patients (67 incisions) were included between January and October 2019. All underwent elective vascular surgery with groin (access) incisions for either lower limb revascularization surgery or abdominal aortic aneurysm surgery. The study group was treated with six days ciNPT (PREVENA Incision Management System; KCI/3M, San Antonio, TX, USA) and matched for equal comparison to a historical retrospectively analysed cohort of 54 consecutive patients (60 incisions), all of whom have undergone elective vascular surgery for equal indications with groin (access) incisions in our center between January and October 2018. The standard-care group was treated following standard surgical wound care protocol with conventional surgical self-adhesive plaster (10 × 15cm, Mepore, Mölnlycke Health Care AB, Gothenburg, Sweden). RESULTS: Study groups were comparable at baseline, except for Body Mass Index (BMI), which was significantly higher in the ciNPT-group (P =.021). No significant differences for formation of seroma, hematoma, as well as wound dehiscence and SSIs were found between both groups. Groin SSIs were seen in 12.1% of the patients in the ciNPT-group and in 13.0% in the Standard-care group (OR 0.80, CI ((0.26, 2.48)), deep SSI contributed for 4 out of 7 patients of total SSIs in the ciNPT-group and for 2 out of 7 patients in the standard of care group (P-value >0.05). Analysis for incidence of hospital re-admission and re-intervention in both study groups showed no significant difference. Subset analysis in both study groups for SSIs differentiated in superficial and deep SSIs showed that only deep SSIs resulted in re-interventions. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the findings in the population of our single center study, we conclude that routine use of ciNPT was not effective in reducing groin wound complications, and therefore could not replicate the promising findings from some previous studies. Furthermore, we did not find a reduction in the incidence of deep SSIs, which comprise the highest morbidity and costs. Considering our findings as well as the associated additional expenses related to ciNPT, it might be superfluous at this stage to use ciNPT as the new standard of post-operative groin incision care for all lower limb revascularization and abdominal aortic aneurysm surgeries. In our opinion further research is warranted for establishing a risk-factor based model for determination of the indication of ciNPT. To be able to achieve a more substantiated decision for utilizing ciNPT compared to standard surgical wound care in groin incisional vascular surgical interventions.
引用
- van Dam MA, Strietman M, van Eps RG, et al. Clinical Relevance of Closed-Incision Negative Pressure Therapy (ciNPT) for SSI-Risk Reduction in Vascular Surgery Through a Groin Incision. Ann Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34537352. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.06.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。