择期EVAR不遵守临床实践指南直径阈值的长期影响
基于SVS血管质量倡议与Medicare理赔链接数据,回顾19,018例择期EVAR,35%不符合指南直径阈值且比例逐年上升。不符合者5年再干预率、破裂率及死亡率更低,但多数未达最低影像随访质量指标。
要点
- 择期EVAR中35%不符合指南直径阈值,且比例从2003年24%升至2016年36%。
- 不符合阈值者5年免于再干预率86% vs 81%,破裂无生存率94% vs 92%,总生存率71% vs 61%。
- 整体队列影像随访率从2003年93%降至2014年63%,多数EVAR未达复合质量指标。
核心结论
- 择期EVAR对SVS指南直径阈值的依从性差且不依从率上升,不依从修复多见于合并症少、解剖条件好的患者,并与更优的再干预、破裂和生存结局相关,但多数不依从修复未达最低质量标准。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2003至2016年SVS血管质量倡议中接受择期EVAR并链接Medicare理赔的患者,排除周末手术、孤立性髂动脉瘤及症状性/破裂表现,共19,018例。
主要发现
- 35%的择期EVAR不符合指南直径阈值,其中26%在阈值5 mm以内,不依从率从2003年24%升至2016年36%(P < .001)。
- 不依从修复者更年轻、合并症更少,且更常符合器械使用说明(89% vs 79%;P < .001)。
- 不依从修复者5年免于再干预率86% vs 81%(P < .001),无破裂生存率94% vs 92%(P = .01),总生存率71% vs 61%(P < .001)。
- 不依从修复者1年影像随访率略高(68% vs 65%;P = .003),但整体队列随访率从2003年93%降至2014年63%(P < .001)。
- 不依从修复者达到复合质量指标的比例更高(43% vs 38%;P < .001),但大多数修复未达该指标。
关键数值与推荐
- 不依从直径阈值定义为男性<55 mm、女性<50 mm且髂动脉直径<30 mm。
- 复合质量指标定义为无中转开放、5年无破裂生存及术后6至24个月至少一次CT随访。
临床怎么用
- 对合并症少、解剖条件好的患者,小于指南直径阈值的EVAR与更优中长期结局相关,但需加强术后影像随访以达质量指标。
- 整体EVAR术后影像随访依从性下降,应制定政策改善AAA诊疗质量与 appropriateness。
局限性
- 原文未报告具体局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Compliance with Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) clinical practice guideline (CPG)-diameter thresholds is variable for endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR). To evaluate the implications and appropriateness of repairs that are noncompliant with current guidelines, we investigated the long-term outcomes, adherence to imaging follow-up, and associated health care costs in patients undergoing EVAR for AAA who do or do not meet recommended diameter thresholds. METHODS: All patients receiving elective EVAR from 2003 to 2016 in the SVS Vascular Quality Initiative with linked Medicare claims were reviewed. Weekend procedures and isolated iliac aneurysms, as well as symptomatic and ruptured presentations, were excluded. Diameter thresholds for noncompliant repairs were defined as: men <55 mm; women <50 mm who did not have an iliac diameter ≥30 mm. We evaluated adherence to postoperative imaging surveillance, reimbursement amounts, reintervention, rupture, and all-cause mortality. We defined an EVAR quality metric as performance of the index procedure with freedom from conversion to open repair, 5-year rupture-free survival, and adherence to minimum imaging surveillance (at least one computed tomography scan documented between 6 and 24 months postoperatively). RESULTS: Among 19,018 elective EVARs, 35% did not meet CPG diameter thresholds (26% within 5 mm of threshold). The rate of noncompliant repairs increased over time (24% in 2003 vs 36% in 2016; P < .001). Patients undergoing noncompliant repairs were younger, less likely to have multiple comorbidities, and more likely to receive EVAR with adherence to instructions for use criteria (89% vs 79%; P < .001). Patients undergoing noncompliant repairs had greater 5-year freedom from reintervention (86% vs 81%; P < .001), rupture-free survival (94% vs 92%; P = .01), and overall survival rates (71% vs 61%; P < .001) compared with repairs that complied with CPG diameter thresholds. Although noncompliant repairs had higher rates of 1-year imaging surveillance, overall differences were modest (68% vs 65%; P = .003). Importantly, for the entire cohort, follow-up imaging surveillance decreased over time (93% in 2003 vs 63% in 2014; P < .001). Notably, although noncompliant repairs had higher rates of achieving the composite quality metric compared with compliant repairs (43% vs 38%; P < .001), failure occurred with a significant majority of all repairs. CONCLUSIONS: Compliance with SVS-endorsed CPG diameter thresholds for elective EVAR is poor, and rates of noncompliance are increasing. Noncompliant repairs appear to be offered more commonly to patients with fewer comorbidities and favorable anatomy, and these repairs are associated with improved rates of reintervention, rupture, and survival compared with procedures meeting CPG diameter thresholds. Importantly, noncompliant repairs fail to meet minimum quality standards in a majority of cases, which underscores the need for further policies to improve the overall quality and appropriateness of AAA care delivery nationally.
引用
- de Guerre LEVM, Dansey KD, Patel PB, et al. Long-term implications of elective evar that is non-compliant with clinical practice guideline diameter thresholds. J Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34508797. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2021.08.068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。