荷兰颈动脉内膜剥脱术围手术期血流动力学与脑监测策略差异调查
该研究于2017年5月至7月对荷兰全部50家颈动脉内膜剥脱术(CEA)中心进行42题问卷调查,回复率100%。结果显示术前基线血压测量、麻醉方式、术中及术后脑监测、目标收缩压范围与住院时长等均存在广泛差异,提示需制定标准化围手术期监测方案。
要点
- 荷兰50家CEA中心的围手术期血流动力学与脑监测策略差异显著。
- 术中目标收缩压范围从>100 mmHg至160 mmHg不等,缺乏统一标准。
- 术后脑监测仅16家中心常规使用经颅多普勒(TCD),24家不监测。
核心结论
- 荷兰各CEA中心的围手术期血流动力学与脑监测策略广泛多样,可能导致过度或不足治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 2017年5月至7月对荷兰全部50家CEA中心进行42题问卷调查,至2017年11月所有中心均完成。
主要发现
- 术前基线血压在多数中心(n=28)基于门诊单次双侧血压测量。
- 43家中心(86%)进行术前监测作为基线参考,包括TCD(n=6)、脑电图(EEG,n=11)或TCD+EEG(n=26)。
- 术中麻醉方式全身麻醉45家、局部麻醉5家;目标收缩压>100 mmHg至160 mmHg(n=12)、基于术前门诊或入院血压(n=18)、其他(n=20)。
- 术中脑监测包括EEG+TCD(n=28)、单独EEG(n=13)、局部麻醉下临床神经检查(n=5)、近红外光谱联合残端压(n=1)、因常规放置分流管而不监测(n=3)。
- 术后标准住院或高护单元时长范围3-48小时(均值12小时),可接受最高收缩压范围>100 mmHg至180 mmHg(n=32),术后脑监测常规TCD(n=16)、按指征TCD(n=5)或不监测(n=24),监测时机从术后即刻至术后24小时(中位3小时)。
临床怎么用
- 该调查结果可作为制定CEA围手术期血流动力学与脑监测标准化方案的基线数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hemodynamic disturbances cause half of the perioperative strokes following carotid endarterectomy (CEA). Guidelines strongly recommend strict pre- and postoperative blood pressure (BP) monitoring in CEA patients, but do not provide firm practical recommendations. Although in the Netherlands 50 centres perform CEA, no national protocol on perioperative hemodynamic, and cerebral monitoring exists. To assess current monitoring policies of all Dutch CEA-centres, a national survey was conducted. METHODS: Between May and July 2017 all 50 Dutch CEA-centres were invited to complete a 42-question survey addressing perioperative hemodynamic and cerebral monitoring during CEA. Nonresponders received a reminder after 1 and 2 months. By November 2017 the survey was completed by all centres. RESULTS: Preoperative baseline BP was based on a single bilateral BP-measurement at the outpatient-clinic in the majority of centres (n = 28). In 43 centres (86%) pre-operative monitoring (transcranial Doppler (TCD, n = 6), electroencephalography (EEG, n = 11), or TCD + EEG (n = 26)) was performed as a baseline reference. Intraoperatively, large diversity for type of anaesthesia (general: 45 vs. local [LA]:5) and target systolic BP (>100 mm hg - 160 mm hg [n = 12], based on preoperative outpatient-clinic or admission BP [n = 18], other [n = 20]) was reported. Intraoperative cerebral monitoring included EEG + TCD (n = 28), EEG alone (n = 13), clinical neurological examination with LA (n = 5), near-infrared spectroscopy with stump pressure (n = 1), and none due to standard shunting (n = 3). Postoperatively, significant variation was reported in standard duration of admission at a recovery or high-care unit (range 3-48 hr, mean:12 hr), maximum accepted systolic BP (range >100 mm hg - 180 mm Hg [n = 32]), postoperative cerebral monitoring (standard TCD [n = 16], TCD on indication [n = 5] or none [n = 24]) and in timing of postoperative cerebral monitoring (range directly postoperative - 24 hr postoperative; median 3 hr). CONCLUSIONS: In Dutch centres performing CEA the perioperative hemodynamic and cerebral monitoring policies are widely diverse. Diverse policies may theoretically lead to over- or under treatment. The results of this national audit may serve as the baseline dataset for development of a standardized and detailed (inter)national protocol on perioperative hemodynamic and cerebral monitoring during CEA.
引用
- Fassaert LM, Toorop RJ, Petri BJ, et al. Variation in perioperative cerebral and hemodynamic monitoring during carotid endarterectomy. Ann Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34461241. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2021.06.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。