加拿大血管外科培训学员手术量趋势
该研究通过问卷调查2007-2019年加拿大血管外科培训毕业生,评估其培训最后两年手术量变化。结果显示2012年整合血管外科住院医师项目引入后,总手术量呈下降趋势,主要由开放手术量显著减少驱动,但学员对多数标准血管手术仍保持足够信心。
要点
- oAAA、LEB和CEA手术量分别下降44%、40%和45%。
- IVSR学员aEVAR和LEEI手术量显著高于VF学员(分别约2.5倍和1.5倍)。
核心结论
- 2012年引入IVSR后加拿大血管外科培训学员手术量下降,主要由开放手术减少驱动,但学员毕业时对多数标准血管手术仍保持足够信心。
研究设计与样本
- 对2007-2019年加拿大皇家学院认证的血管外科专科培训(VF)和整合血管外科住院医师(IVSR)项目毕业生进行问卷调查,记录培训最后两年手术量。
- 共60名参与者(10%女性)来自全部10所加拿大培训 institutions,回应率63%。
主要发现
- oAAA、LEB和CEA手术量分别下降44%、40%和45%。
- 学员对oAAA、EVAR、LEB、LEEI和CEA的信心范围为90%-100%,对oTAA/TAAA和aEVAR信心最低分别为20%和49%。
临床怎么用
- 培训项目需关注开放手术暴露减少的趋势,确保学员在oAAA、LEB和CEA等开放手术方面获得足够训练。
- IVSR学员在aEVAR和LEEI方面暴露更多,可针对性地补强开放手术经验。
- 学员对oTAA/TAAA和aEVAR信心较低,培训中应加强这些复杂术式的教学。
局限性
- 研究为问卷调查,依赖学员回忆,可能存在回忆偏倚。
- 样本量60人,回应率63%,可能存在无回应偏倚。
- 仅纳入加拿大培训项目毕业生,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Vascular surgery has evolved with increasing use of endovascular therapies and a decline in open surgery. The influence of these changes, in addition to a new vascular surgery training program introduced in 2012, on case volumes of vascular trainees is not known. We sought to evaluate trends in operative case volumes of Canadian vascular surgery trainees. METHODS: A survey was administered to graduates of the Canadian Royal College-accredited Vascular Fellowships (VFs) and Integrated Vascular Surgery Residency (IVSR) programs (2007-2019) to record cases performed during their final 2 years of training. Procedures of interest were open abdominal aortic aneurysm (oAAA) repair, open thoracic/thoracoabdominal aortic (oTAA/TAAA) repair, lower extremity bypass (LEB), carotid endarterectomy (CEA), lower extremity endovascular intervention (LEEI), and endovascular abdominal, advanced, and thoracic aortic repair (EVAR, aEVAR, and TEVAR). Case volumes were analyzed overall, and by graduation year, type of training program, and resident demographics. RESULTS: A total of 60 participants (10% female) from all the 10 Canadian training institutions responded (response rate, 63%). There was a declining trend in overall procedures performed since the introduction of IVSR in 2012 (median, 427 [interquartile range (IQR), 304-496] in 2007-2012 vs median, 342 [IQR, 279-405] in 2013-2019; P = .055), driven by a significant decline in open vascular surgery cases (median, 273 [IQR, 221-339] in 2007-2012 vs median, 156 [IQR, 128-181] in 2013-2019; P = .001). Case volumes of oAAA, LEB, and CEA declined by 44%, 40%, and 45%, respectively. Compared with vascular fellows, IVSR residents logged ∼2.5 times more aEVARs (median, 8; IQR, 2-11 vs median, 19; IQR, 8-27; P = .001) and ∼1.5 times more LEEIs (median, 60; IQR, 40-99 vs median, 93; IQR, 69-120; P = .018). Trainees were most confident (range, 90%-100%) in performing oAAA, EVAR, LEB, LEEI, and CEA after training, and least confident in performing oTAA/TAAA and aEVAR (20% and 49% confidence, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Operative case volumes of Canadian vascular surgery trainees since the introduction of IVSR program in 2012 have decreased, driven by declining exposure to open cases. However, trainees continue to receive adequate operative exposure to perform most standard vascular procedures confidently upon graduation.
引用
- AlHamzah M, Hussain MA, Greco E, et al. Trends in operative case volumes of Canadian vascular surgery trainees. J Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 34461218. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2021.07.230
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。