CTA面积狭窄法高估颈动脉狭窄程度:与NASCET直径法对比
单中心回顾性盲法分析显示,在颈动脉超声提示≥70%狭窄且1年内行CTA的患者中,CTA面积狭窄法与NASCET直径法一致性差(≥70%:κ=0.32;≥80%:κ=0.25),面积法显著高估狭窄程度,可能导致不必要的颈动脉血运重建。
要点
- CTA面积狭窄法较NASCET直径法显著高估颈动脉狭窄程度。
- 面积法高估可能导致不必要的颈动脉血运重建。
- 使用CTA评估颈动脉狭窄时应标准化采用NASCET方法。
核心结论
- CTA面积狭窄法较NASCET直径法显著高估颈动脉狭窄程度,可能高估卒中风险并导致不必要的血运重建。
- 使用CTA评估颈动脉狭窄时需标准化采用NASCET方法以确定血运重建阈值。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、盲法、回顾性分析,纳入2008至2017年颈动脉超声提示≥70%狭窄且1年内行CTA的320条动脉。
- 超声狭窄标准为收缩期峰值流速≥125 cm/s且颈内动脉/颈总动脉比值≥4。
- CTA采用三维工作站中心线测量,分别以NASCET法和面积狭窄法评估。
主要发现
- 面积法与NASCET法一致性差:≥70%狭窄κ=0.32,≥80%狭窄κ=0.25。
- 247条面积法≥70%的动脉中,127条(51.4%)NASCET法≥70%。
- 169条面积法≥80%的动脉中,44条(26.0%)NASCET法≥80%。
- 超声与CTA检查中位间隔9.5天。
关键数值与推荐
- 超声定义≥70%狭窄:收缩期峰值流速≥125 cm/s且颈内动脉/颈总动脉比值≥4。
- CTA分别以NASCET直径法和面积狭窄法评估,比较≥70%和≥80%的阈值一致性。
临床怎么用
- CTA评估颈动脉狭窄用于血运重建决策时应采用NASCET直径法而非面积狭窄法。
- 面积狭窄法结果可能高估狭窄程度,需结合NASCET法重新判读以避免不必要的干预。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性研究,样本量有限(320条动脉)。
- 仅纳入超声提示≥70%狭窄且1年内有CTA的患者,存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The degree of carotid artery stenosis, calculated using catheter-based angiography and the North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial (NASCET) method, has been shown to predict the stroke risk in several, large, randomized controlled trials. In the present era, patients have been increasingly evaluated using computed tomography (CT) angiography (CTA) before carotid artery revascularization, especially as the use of transcarotid artery revascularization has increased. Interpretation of CTA findings regarding the degree of carotid stenosis has not been standardized, with both NASCET methods and the area stenosis used. We performed a single-institution, blinded, retrospective analysis of CTA studies using both the NASCET method and the CT-derived area stenosis to assess the concordance and discordance between the two methods when evaluating ≥70% and ≥80% stenosis. METHODS: The UMass Memorial Medical Center vascular laboratory database was queried for all carotid duplex ultrasound scans performed from 2008 to 2017. The included patients were limited to those with duplex-defined ≥70% stenosis (defined as a peak systolic velocity of ≥125 cm/s and an internal carotid artery/common carotid artery ratio of ≥4), and a correlative CTA study performed within 1 year of the duplex ultrasound examination. A blinded review of all correlative CTA studies using centerline measurements on a three-dimensional workstation (Aquarius iNtuition Viewer; Terarecon, Durham, NC) was performed to characterize the degree of carotid stenosis using the NASCET method and the area stenosis method. Patients were excluded if revascularization had been performed between the two imaging studies. RESULTS: Of the 37,204 carotid duplex ultrasound scans reviewed (performed from 2008 to 2017), 3480 arteries met the criteria for duplex ultrasound-defined ≥70% stenosis. A correlative CTA study within 1 year of the duplex ultrasound examination was identified in 460 arteries, of which 320 were adequate quality for blinded review. The median interval between the duplex ultrasound and CTA examinations was 9.5 days. Concordance between the area stenosis and NASCET methods was poor for both ≥70% (κ = 0.32) and ≥80% (κ = 0.25) stenosis. Of the 247 arteries considered to have ≥70% area stenosis, 127 (51.4%) were considered to have ≥70% stenosis using the NASCET method. Of the 169 arteries considered to have ≥80% area stenosis, 44 (26.0%) were considered to have ≥80% stenosis using the NASCET method. CONCLUSIONS: The area stenosis CTA calculations of carotid artery stenosis dramatically overestimated the degree of carotid stenosis compared with that calculated using the NASCET method. Given that stroke risk estimates have been determined from trials that used the NASCET method, the area stenosis method likely overestimates the risk of stroke. Therefore, area stenosis calculations could lead to unnecessary carotid revascularization procedures. This model highlights the need for standardized usage of the NASCET method when using CTA as the imaging modality to determine the threshold for carotid revascularization.
引用
- Arous EJ, Judelson DR, Agrawal A, et al. Computed tomography angiography-derived area stenosis calculations overestimate degree of carotid stenosis compared with North American Symptomatic Carotid Endarterectomy Trial-derived diameter stenosis calculations. J Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 33548432. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.12.085
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。