文献速递主动脉疾病外周动脉疾病颈动脉与弓上血管

血管外科在谷歌与YouTube搜索结果中的存在感与教育内容现状

The current state of vascular surgery presence and educational content in Google and YouTube internet search results.
PubMed 文献 · J Vasc Surg · 2021-02-09

研究于2019年3–7月独立检索谷歌与YouTube共25个血管疾病关键词,评估血管外科医生(VS)的曝光度与内容覆盖。谷歌首页56%含SVS页面,68%提及专科的网站中56%提及VS;YouTube仅36%搜索含SVS关联视频,内容全面性普遍不足。

要点

  • 谷歌首页56%含SVS页面,但跛行、坏疽、颈动脉支架等搜索最少出现。
  • 提及专科的网站中56%提及VS,介入放射20%、心胸外科19%。
  • 仅4%网站和0.24%视频覆盖全部疾病相关内容类别。

核心结论

  • 互联网血管疾病信息丰富但内容差异大且不全面,仅半数搜索将VS列为首选转诊医生。

研究设计与样本

  • 两位研究者于2019年3–7月独立检索谷歌与YouTube的25个血管疾病关键词/短语。
  • 谷歌分析1241个网页、357个唯一域名;YouTube分析1247条结果、613个唯一视频。

主要发现

  • 谷歌75%网页面向公众,SVS页面出现在56%首页结果中。
  • 68%网站提及专科,其中VS占56%、介入放射20%、心胸外科19%。
  • YouTube 64%视频面向公众,36%搜索含SVS关联视频。
  • 47%提及专科的视频中VS占56%、介入放射10%、心胸外科7%。
  • 仅4%网站和0.24%视频覆盖全部内容类别;透析通路搜索内容类别最少。

临床怎么用

  • 血管外科需加强网络存在感,提升血管疾病在线教育质量并引导患者至血管专科。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Information on the internet regarding vascular disease has not been extensively assessed. Our goal was to compile and appraise the information available via Google and YouTube searches regarding various topics of interest for vascular surgeons (VS) and related procedures with a focus on the role of the VS. METHODS: The Google and YouTube platforms were independently queried for 25 keywords/phrases relating to common vascular diagnoses and procedures by two separate researchers from March to July 2019. Paid advertisements or a Society for Vascular Surgery (SVS) webpage or affiliated video in the first 25 results was documented. Results were reviewed for information regarding the responsible medical specialty and the target audience, and disease-related information (screening, risk factors, risk reduction, diagnostic testing, operative treatment, alternative treatment, follow-up, complications, and recovery). RESULTS: From the Google search, 357 unique domains of 1241 total webpages were identified with 75% directed toward the public. An SVS page was present in 56% of the first-page results and least likely to be present in searches for claudication, gangrene, carotid stent, rib resection, and thrombolysis. VS were mentioned as referral physicians in 56% of the 68% of websites that mentioned a specialty, endovascular specialists/interventional radiology in 20%, and cardiothoracic surgeons in 19%. Only 4% of the websites contained information from all categories, with the greatest number for aortic dissection. Advertisements were present in 18% of all searches (most commonly for "varicose vein," "varicose vein surgery," and "inferior vena cava filter"). From YouTube, 1247 search results (613 unique videos) were evaluated with 64% directed toward the public. An SVS affiliated video was present in 36% of searches. In the 47% of videos where a specialty was mentioned, 56% mentioned VS, interventional radiology in 10%, and cardiothoracic surgeons in 7%. Only 0.24% of the videos contained information from all categories. The greatest number of content categories was in videos related to peripheral arterial disease. Across both platforms, dialysis access searches yielded results with the least number of content categories. CONCLUSIONS: Patient-related information regarding vascular surgical topics is readily available on the internet, but the content is highly variable and not comprehensive. Only half of the searches mention VS as the referral physician of choice or authority for these medical conditions. Further efforts should focus on developing the online presence of vascular surgery, improving the quality of education of vascular disease on the internet, and directing patients to the vascular specialists to treat these conditions.

来源:J Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Phair J, Dalmia V, Sanon O, et al. The current state of vascular surgery presence and educational content in Google and YouTube internet search results. J Vasc Surg. 2021. PMID: 33577914. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.12.112

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。