年龄≥50岁运动诱发下肢疼痛患者中慢性运动性筋膜室综合征与外周动脉疾病的鉴别特征
本研究为病例对照研究,比较了43例年龄≥50岁的慢性运动性筋膜室综合征(CECS)患者与41例新诊断外周动脉疾病(PAD)患者的症状特征。CECS患者静息时疼痛、紧绷感、肌无力和皮肤感觉异常更明显,运动诱发症状出现更晚(15分钟 vs 4分钟,P<.01),且运动停止后73%的患者症状未完全缓解,而PAD患者全部缓解。这些差异有助于血管外科医生在老年运动诱发下肢疼痛患者中识别CECS。
要点
- 年龄≥50岁运动诱发下肢疼痛患者中,CECS静息症状比PAD更明显。
- CECS运动诱发症状出现时间显著晚于PAD(15分钟 vs 4分钟,P<.01)。
- 运动停止后症状持续不缓解强烈提示CECS(特异度100%,阳性预测值100%)。
核心结论
- 年龄≥50岁的CECS患者症状模式与PAD患者不同,这些差异有助于血管外科医生识别老年CECS患者。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照研究,CECS组43例(42%女性,平均57岁,范围50-76岁)来自前瞻性随访队列,PAD组41例(39%女性,平均72岁,范围51-93岁)为新诊断患者,均≥50岁,通过问卷评估静息和运动时下肢疼痛、紧绷感、痉挛、肌无力和皮肤感觉异常的频率与严重程度。
主要发现
- 静息时,CECS患者报告疼痛、紧绷感、肌无力和皮肤感觉异常均显著多于PAD患者(均P<.01),CECS与静息症状综合评分显著更高相关(P=.02)。
- 运动时,CECS患者紧绷感、肌无力和感觉异常更明显(P<.01),但疼痛和痉挛无显著差异(P=.36;P=.70)。
- CECS患者运动诱发症状出现时间显著晚于PAD患者(15分钟 vs 4分钟,P<.01)。
- 疼痛持续超过4.5分钟对CECS最具鉴别力(敏感度95%,特异度54%,阳性预测值65%)。
- 运动停止后所有PAD患者症状完全缓解,而73%(29例)CECS患者未完全缓解;持续不适强烈预测CECS(敏感度73%,特异度100%,阳性预测值100%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 疼痛持续超过4.5分钟:敏感度95%,特异度54%,阳性预测值65%。
- 运动停止后持续不适:敏感度73%,特异度100%,阳性预测值100%。
- 运动诱发症状出现时间:CECS 15分钟 vs PAD 4分钟(P<.01)。
临床怎么用
- 对年龄≥50岁运动诱发下肢疼痛患者,应询问静息症状及运动停止后症状是否完全缓解,以鉴别CECS与PAD。
- 运动停止后症状持续不缓解或疼痛持续超过4.5分钟时,需考虑CECS可能。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Peripheral artery disease (PAD) and chronic exertional compartment syndrome (CECS) both cause exercise-induced lower limb pain. CECS is mostly described in young individuals and may therefore not be considered in older patients with intermittent claudication. The aim of our study was to identify differences in characteristics and symptomatology between patients with CECS and PAD that may help in recognizing CECS in patients ≥50 years with exercise-induced lower limb pain. METHODS: In this case-control study, patients with CECS ≥50 years were selected from a prospectively followed cohort and compared with a sample of newly diagnosed patients with PAD ≥50 years. A questionnaire assessed frequency and severity of lower limb pain, tightness, cramps, muscle weakness, and altered skin sensation at rest and during exercise. RESULTS: At rest, patients with CECS (n = 43, 42% female, 57 years; range, 50-76 years) reported significantly more pain, tightness, muscle weakness and altered skin sensation (all P < .01) than patients with PAD (n = 41, 39% female, 72 years; range, 51-93 years). Having CECS was associated with a significantly higher combined symptom score at rest (P = .02). During exercise, patients with CECS experienced more tightness, muscle weakness and altered sensation (P < .01), but not pain and cramps (P = .36; P = .70). Exercise-induced complaints occurred much later in patients with CECS than in patients with PAD (15 minutes vs 4 minutes; P < .01). Persistence of pain over 4.5 minutes proved most discriminative for the presence of CECS (sensitivity, 95%; specificity, 54%; positive predictive value, 65%). Exercise cessation completely alleviated complaints in all patients with PAD (n = 41) but not in 73% (n = 29) of the patients with CECS. Ongoing discomfort strongly predicted the presence of CECS (sensitivity, 73%; specificity, 100%; positive predictive value, 100%). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with CECS ≥50 years report a symptom pattern that is different from patients with PAD. These differences may aid vascular surgeons in identifying older patients with CECS.
引用
- de Bruijn JA, Wijns KCA, van Kuijk SMJ, et al. Chronic exertional compartment syndrome in the differential diagnosis of peripheral artery disease in older patients with exercise-induced lower limb pain. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 33278541. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.11.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。