三维和二维超声在EVAR术后瘤囊评估中与CT同样准确
本研究以三维CTA体积为金标准,比较三维超声、二维超声和传统CT多平面重建在EVAR术后3个月和12个月评估主动脉瘤囊变化的能力。结果显示所有方法在3个月时漏诊真实增长的风险为18%-22%,敏感性低(0%-21%),12个月时漏诊风险降至5%-6%,敏感性仍仅17%-33%。结论认为所有方法与传统CT-MPR OTO直径相当,但与3D-CTA体积一致性差。
要点
- 3个月时各方法漏诊瘤囊真实增长风险达18%-22%,敏感性0%-21%。
- 12个月时漏诊风险降至5%-6%,但敏感性仍仅17%-33%。
- 所有超声方法与传统CT-MPR OTO直径评估效能相当。
核心结论
- 所有测试的瘤囊变化评估方法与传统CT-MPR OTO直径相当,但与3D-CTA体积在术后3个月一致性差,12个月后一致性明显改善。
研究设计与样本
- 以三维CTA体积为金标准,连续纳入113例EVAR术后患者,在两个时间间期(术前至术后3个月、术后3至12个月)比较2D-US前后径、3D-US中心线前后径、3D-US部分体积和CT-MPR OTO直径。
主要发现
- 术后3个月漏诊真实瘤囊增长的风险:3D-US部分体积19%、3D-US中心线前后径21%、2D-US前后径22%、CT-MPR OTO直径18%。
- 术后3个月检测瘤囊变化的敏感性为0%至21%,kappa值均小于0.50。
- 术后3至12个月漏诊真实增长的风险分别为6%、5%、6%、6%,对应敏感性分别为33%、33%、17%、17%。
临床怎么用
- 现有超声和传统CT方法在术后早期评估瘤囊变化时漏诊风险较高,需谨慎解读阴性结果。
- 术后12个月时各方法漏诊风险降低,但仍需结合三维CTA体积评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To compare aortic sac changes after endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) assessed by three-dimensional ultrasound (3D-US), two-dimensional ultrasound (2D-US), and traditional computed tomographic angiography (CTA). METHODS: Using volume assessment with three-dimensional CTA (3D-CTA-volume) as the gold standard, this study investigated aortic sac changes at three and 12 months after EVAR with three different ultrasound methods (2D-US anterior-posterior (AP) diameter, 3D-US AP centerline diameter, and 3D-US partial volume), and traditional CT multiplanar outer-to-outer diameter (CT-MPR OTO diameter). From august 1st, 2011 to January 2014, consecutive EVAR patients (n = 113) were available for analysis in two time intervals; 1) between preoperative and three-month follow-up and 2) between three and 12 month follow-up. RESULTS: The risk of missing true aortic sac growth (false negative finding) at three-month postoperative visit using 3D-US partial volume, 3D-US AP centerline diameter, 2D-US AP diameter, and CT-MPR OTO diameter was 19%, 21%, 22%, and 18%, respectively. Corresponding low sensitivities (0% to 21%) and kappa-values (<0.50) in detecting aortic sac changes were found. The risk of missing true growth between three and 12 months were lower (6%, 5%, 6%, and 6%, respectively), and matching sensitivities 33%, 33%, 17%, and 17%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: All tested methods for aortic sac changes were as good as traditional CT-MPR OTO diameter and corresponded poorly with 3D-CTA-volume at three months postoperative visit but substantially better after 12 months where the residual sac change was more profound.
引用
- Bredahl KK, Taudorf M, Ghulam QM, et al. Three- and Two-Dimensional Ultrasound is as Accurate as Computed Tomography in Aortic Sac Assessment after Endovascular Aortic Repair. Ann Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 33160060. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2020.09.061
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。