通过患者参与提升腹主动脉瘤筛查接受率:区域项目层面策略分析与结果
本研究对390名未参加AAA筛查邀请的男性进行前瞻性研究,通过信件和电话联系,分析 ethnicity、工作状态和 deprivation 五分位。患者建议的服务改进实施后,筛查接受率从75.2%(2015-16筛查年)升至81.3%(2017-2018)。未参加者AAA发生率几乎是参加人群的3倍。
要点
- 电话联系未参加者响应率是信件的四倍,NAAASP联系信息准确率97%。
- 实施患者建议改进后两年内筛查接受率提高6%。
- 未参加筛查者AAA发生率约为参加人群的3倍。
核心结论
- 实施患者建议的改进策略后,区域筛查接受率两年内提高6%。
- 社会剥夺等外部因素不利影响筛查接受率,且AAA在社会剥夺群体中更普遍。
- 联系和吸引未参加者很重要,他们可能AAA风险最高。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入390名未参加AAA筛查邀请的男性。
- 通过信件和电话联系未参加者,按 ethnicity、工作状态和 deprivation 五分位分析。
- 记录、分析并实施患者建议的服务改进,收集随后两年的接受率数据。
主要发现
- NAAASP使用的筛查管理和转诊跟踪系统在保存患者联系方式方面准确率97%。
- 未参加者回应电话联系的可能性是信件的四倍。
- 未参加者群体AAA发生率几乎是参加人群的3倍。
- 非洲-加勒比男性参加筛查的可能性不成比例地低。
- 筛查接受率从75.2%(2015-16筛查年)升至81.3%(2017-2018)。
临床怎么用
- 区域项目应通过电话主动联系未参加筛查者以提高接受率。
- 针对不便的筛查时间和地点、缺乏对AAA筛查意义的认识以及语言/识字障碍等可区域层面解决的因素进行改进。
- 关注社会剥夺群体和非洲-加勒比男性的筛查参与不平等。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To identify areas of health inequality that adversely affect patient engagement at a regional level within the National Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Screening Program (NAAASP). Patient-reported improvements to services were implemented and analysis of subsequent uptake undertaken. METHODS: A prospective study of 390 men who failed to attend their AAA screening invitation. Nonattendees were contacted by post and telephone. Patients were analyzed as per ethnicity, working status, and Index of Multiple Deprivation quintile. Patient-suggested improvements to the service were recorded, analyzed, and implemented. Uptake data were then collected for the subsequent two years. RESULTS: The Screening Management and Referral Tracking system used by NAAASP is 97% accurate in holding patient contact details, and nonattenders are four times more likely to respond to telephone contact. Reasons for failing to attend screening invitations include factors that can be addressed at a regional level such as: inconvenient timings/locations of screening clinics and a lack of awareness or understanding of what AAA screening means as well as language/literacy barriers. The incidence of AAAs in the nonattendee group was almost 3 times that of our general (attending) population. Afro-Caribbean men were disproportionately less likely to attend for screening. After implementing patient-suggested improvements to the service, screening uptake increased from 75.2% (2015-16 screening year) to 81.3% (2017-2018). CONCLUSIONS: To date, no other studies have gone on to assess the effectiveness of interventions targeted at reducing inequalities in NAAASP attendance, but we show an increase in local screening uptake of 6% in a 2-year period after implementing improvement strategies. This article adds to existing literature by confirming external factors such as social deprivation adversely influence screening uptake and that AAAs are more prevalent in socially deprived groups. It reinforces the importance of regional attempts to contact and engage nonattenders as they may be most at risk of developing AAAs.
引用
- Ahmad M, Reading K, Gannon MX, et al. Improving Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm (AAA) Screening Uptake through Patient Engagement-Analysis and Outcomes of Strategies to Improve Uptake at a Regional Program Level. Ann Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32949734. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2020.08.146
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。