现代开放腹主动脉瘤修复中术者与医院手术量对死亡率的关联及交互作用
基于VQI注册数据,2013至2018年共3078例择期开放腹主动脉瘤修复,由520名术者在128家医院完成,30天和90天死亡率分别为4.1%和5.4%。术者年均手术量和医院年均手术量均与30天死亡率负相关,且两者存在显著交互作用,术者年均4例以上即有96%概率达到30天死亡率<5%。
要点
- 术者年均4例以上开放AAA修复有96%概率30天死亡率<5%。
- 低手术量医院(年均5例)中术者年均3例时仅69%概率30天死亡率<5%。
- 高手术量医院(年均40例)中术者年均3例时96%概率30天死亡率<5%。
核心结论
- VQI注册中术者和医院年均手术量均与择期开放AAA修复30天死亡率负相关。
- 术者与医院手术量存在显著交互作用,制定最低手术量指南需结合医院手术量背景。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性横断面研究,纳入VQI注册2013至2018年择期开放AAA修复患者3078例,由520名术者在128家医院完成。
- 采用分层贝叶斯模型分析医院和术者平均手术量与30天死亡率的关联,允许跨层交互并纳入随机截距。
主要发现
- 30天和90天术后死亡率分别为4.1%(n=126)和5.4%(n=166)。
- 术者年均手术量和医院年均手术量均与30天死亡率呈负相关。
- 所有患者和医院平均后,术者年均4例以上有96%概率实现30天死亡率<5%。
- 低手术量医院(年均5例)中术者年均3例时仅69%概率30天死亡率<5%,而高手术量医院(年均40例)中术者年均3例时概率为96%。
关键数值与推荐
- 以SVS指南围手术期死亡率<5%为比较标准。
- 术者年均4例以上有96%概率达到30天死亡率<5%。
- 医院年均5例且术者年均3例时,仅69%概率达到30天死亡率<5%。
- 医院年均40例且术者年均3例时,96%概率达到30天死亡率<5%。
临床怎么用
- 评估开放AAA修复质量时需同时考虑术者和医院手术量。
- 低手术量医院中即使术者手术量低,仍可能通过高医院手术量达到可接受死亡率。
- 制定最低手术量标准时应结合医院手术量背景进行分层考量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Operative volume has been used as a marker of quality. Research from previous decades has suggested minimum open abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair volume requirements for surgeons of 9 to 13 open AAA repairs annually and for hospitals of 18 open AAA repairs annually to purportedly achieve acceptable results. Given concerns regarding the decreased frequency of open repairs in the endovascular era, we examined the association of surgeon and hospital volume with the 30- and 90-day mortality in the Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI) registry. METHODS: Patients who had undergone elective open AAA repair from 2013 to 2018 were identified in the VQI registry. We performed a cross-sectional evaluation of the association between the average hospital and surgeon volume and 30-day postoperative mortality using a hierarchical Bayesian model. Cross-level interactions were permitted, and random surgeon- and hospital-level intercepts were used to account for clustering. The mortality results were adjusted by standardizing to the observed distribution of relevant covariates in the overall cohort. The outcomes were compared to the Society for Vascular Surgery guidelines recommended criteria of <5% perioperative mortality. RESULTS: A total of 3078 patients had undergone elective open AAA repair by 520 surgeons at 128 hospitals. The 30- and 90-day risks of postoperative mortality were 4.1% (n = 126) and 5.4% (n = 166), respectively. The mean surgeon volume and hospital volume both correlated inversely with the 30-day mortality. Averaged across all patients and hospitals, we found a 96% probability that surgeons who performed an average of four or more repairs per year achieved <5% 30-day mortality. Substantial interplay was present between surgeon volume and hospital volume. For example, at lower volume hospitals performing an average of five repairs annually, <5% 30-day mortality would be expected 69% of the time for surgeons performing an average of three operations annually. In contrast, at higher volume hospitals performing an average of 40 repairs annually, a <5% 30-day mortality would be expected 96% of the time for surgeons performing an average of three operations annually. As hospital volume increased, a diminishing difference occurred in 30-day mortality between lower and higher volume surgeons. Likewise, as surgeon volume increased, a diminishing difference was found in 30-day mortality between the lower and higher volume hospitals. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeons and hospitals in the VQI registry achieved mortality outcomes of <5% (Society for Vascular Surgery guidelines), with an average surgeon volume that was substantially lower compared with previous reports. Furthermore, when considering the development of minimal surgeon volume guidelines, it is important to contextualize the outcomes within the hospital volumes.
引用
- Sharma G, Madenci AL, Wanis KN, et al. Association and interplay of surgeon and hospital volume with mortality after open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair in the modern era. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32976969. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.07.108
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。