术者年手术量与执业年限对开放腹主动脉瘤修复结局的影响
基于SVS-VQI 2003-2019年11,900例肾下腹主动脉瘤开放修复,分析术者年手术量与执业年限对结局的影响。发现年手术量比累积执业年限与结局关联更强,低年资高量术者结局与高年资低量术者相似。
要点
- 年手术量>5例的术者结局优于≤5例者,各执业年限层均如此。
- 执业年限与未调整死亡率无关,但≥16年术者择期修复并发症较少。
- 早期职业医师(≤5年)应通过导师制提高开放修复结局。
核心结论
- 术者年手术量比累积执业年限与开放腹主动脉瘤修复结局的关联更显著。
- 低年资高量术者的结局与高年资低量术者相似。
- 建议对早期职业及低量主动脉瘤修复术者实施导师制以保证最佳结局。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列分析,纳入SVS-VQI 2003-2019年11,900例肾下开放腹主动脉瘤修复(择期70%,非择期30%)。
- 术者执业年限分为≤5年(n=1667)、6-10年(n=1887)、11-15年(n=1806)、≥16年(n=6540)。
- 年手术量以每年开放修复例数确定,中位数5例,按≤5例 vs >5例分层。
- 采用逻辑回归进行风险调整,评估院内主要并发症及30天和1年死亡率。
主要发现
- 风险调整(AUC=0.776)显示低量术者(年≤5例)在各经验层结局均劣于高量术者。
临床怎么用
- 评估开放腹主动脉瘤修复术者时,应优先关注年手术量而非仅执业年限。
- 对低年资高量及高年资低量术者均应考虑导师制带教。
- 监管与认证体系可参考年手术量阈值(如每年5例)制定政策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Widespread adoption of endovascular aneurysm repair has led to a consequential decline in the use of open aneurysm repair (OAR). This evolution has had significant ramifications on vascular surgery training paradigms and contemporary practice patterns among established surgeons. Despite being the subject of previous analyses, the surgical volume-outcome relationship has remained a focus of controversy. At present, little is known about the complex interaction of case volume and surgeon experience with patient selection, procedural characteristics, and postoperative complications of OAR. The purpose of the present analysis was to examine the association between surgeon annual case volume and years of practice experience with OAR. METHODS: All infrarenal OARs (n = 11,900; elective, 70%; nonelective, 30%) included in the Society for Vascular Surgery Vascular Quality Initiative from 2003 to 2019 were examined. Surgeon experience was defined as years in practice after training. The experience level at repair was categorized chronologically (≤5 years, n = 1667; 6-10 years, n = 1887; 11-15 years, n = 1806; ≥16 years, n = 6540). The annual case volume was determined by the number of OARs performed by the surgeon annually (median, five cases). Logistic regression was used to perform risk adjustment of the outcomes across surgeon experience and volume (five or fewer vs more than five cases annually) strata for in-hospital major complications and 30-day and 1-year mortality. RESULTS: Practice experience had no association with unadjusted mortality (30-day death: elective, P = .2; nonelective, P = .3; 1-year death: elective, P = .2; nonelective, P = .2). However, more experienced surgeons had fewer complications after elective OAR (25% with ≥16 years vs 29% with ≤5 years; P = .004). A significant linear correlation was identified between increasing surgeon experience and performance of a greater proportion of elective OAR (P-trend < .0001). Risk adjustment (area under the curve, 0.776) revealed that low-volume (five or fewer cases annually) surgeons had inferior outcomes compared with high-volume surgeons across the experience strata for all presentations. In addition, high-volume, early career surgeons (≤5 years' experience) had outcomes similar to those of older, low-volume surgeons (P > .1 for all pairwise comparisons). Early career surgeons (≤5 years) had operated on a greater proportion of elective patients with American Society of Anesthesiologists class ≥4 (35% vs 30% [≥16 years' experience]; P = .0003) and larger abdominal aortic aneurysm diameters (mean, 62 vs 59 mm [≥16 years' experience]; P < .0001) compared with all other experience categories. Similarly, the use of a suprarenal cross-clamp occurred more frequently (26% vs 22% [≥16 years' experience]; P = .0009) but the total procedure time, estimated blood loss, and renal and/or visceral ischemia times were all greater for less experienced surgeons (P-trend < .0001). CONCLUSIONS: Annual case volume appeared to be more significantly associated with OAR outcomes compared with the cumulative years of practice experience. To ensure optimal OAR outcomes, mentorship strategies for "on-boarding" early career, as well as established, low-volume, aortic aneurysm repair surgeons should be considered. These findings have potential implications for widespread initiatives surrounding regulatory oversight and credentialing paradigms.
引用
- Scali ST, Arnaoutakis DJ, Neal D, et al. Association between surgeon case volume and years of practice experience with open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair outcomes. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32707388. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.07.065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。