患者安全指标不足以追踪和评级开放主动脉修复术的结局
本研究为病例对照研究,纳入2004至2018年在约翰霍普金斯医院接受开放腹主动脉瘤修复术的154例患者,比较PSI、NSQIP和VQI三种系统对并发症的识别能力。结果显示VQI识别51.0%的并发症,NSQIP识别29.7%,PSI仅识别9.7%(P<.001),PSI系统识别的重要并发症少于临床数据库,不应作为评级医院开放主动脉手术性能的基础。
要点
- PSI系统仅识别9.7%的开放主动脉修复术后并发症,显著低于VQI的51.0%和NSQIP的29.7%。
- VQI识别最多的肾脏并发症(52例),PSI与VQI在肾脏结局上相关性弱(ρ=0.163)。
- PSI系统不应作为评级医院开放主动脉手术临床相关并发症性能的基础。
核心结论
- PSI系统识别的重要并发症少于NSQIP和VQI,VQI捕获最多术后事件,主要因其对肾损伤的严格定义。
- PSI系统不应形成评级医院开放主动脉手术项目临床相关并发症的基础。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照研究,纳入2004至2018年约翰霍普金斯医院接受开放腹主动脉瘤修复术的154例患者。
- 采用NSQIP、VQI和PSI各自对开放腹主动脉瘤修复术的独特定义识别出血、心脏、呼吸、肾脏、伤口和血栓栓塞并发症。
主要发现
- 154例患者中,VQI识别79例(51.0%)有并发症,NSQIP识别46例(29.7%),PSI识别15例(9.7%)(P<.001)。
- PSI系统识别并发症的患者更可能为肾旁或更广泛动脉瘤、基线充血性心力衰竭、需肠系膜上动脉以上阻断(均P<.01)或动脉瘤直径>6.5 cm(P=.02)。
- NSQIP和VQI识别的术后出血、呼吸、肾脏和伤口并发症均多于PSI系统(P<.05)。
- VQI识别最多的肾脏并发症(52例,P<.001);VQI中发生并发症的独特因素包括使用肾上阻断和作为修复一部分的主动脉肾动脉旁路术(P<.01)。
- PSI系统与VQI在肾脏结局方面相关性特别弱(ρ=0.163)。
临床怎么用
- 在评估开放主动脉修复术的临床相关并发症时,应优先使用VQI或NSQIP等临床聚焦数据库,而非PSI系统。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: National rankings of hospitals rely on outcomes-based evaluation to assess the performance of surgical programs, particularly those performing high-risk elective surgical procedures such as open aortic repair. Various classification systems exist for tracking outcomes, but increasingly the International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision-based Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Patient Safety Indicators (PSIs) are used as a publicly reported comparison measure of hospital quality performance. We sought to critically evaluate the accuracy of the existing vehicles to assess open aortic repair outcomes in an established program. METHODS: This is a case-control study of patients who underwent open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair at the Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions from 2004 to 2018. Patients' characteristics and outcomes were collected as part of a prospectively maintained retrospective database. For each case, hemorrhagic, cardiac, respiratory, renal, wound, and thromboembolic complications were identified with the unique definitions used for open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair by the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database, the Society for Vascular Surgery Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI) database, and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality PSI initiative. RESULTS: Of the 154 patients included in the study, 79 (51.0%) were identified as having a complication as defined by the VQI, 46 (29.7%) according to the NSQIP, and 15 (9.7%) according to the PSI system (P < .001). Patients most likely to incur a complication in the PSI system were those with a pararenal or more extensive aneurysm, with baseline congestive heart failure, requiring a supramesenteric clamp (all P < .01), or with an aneurysm >6.5 cm in diameter (P = .02). The NSQIP and VQI systems both identified more postoperative hemorrhagic, respiratory, renal, and wound complications than the PSI system did (P < .05). The VQI system identified the most renal complications (52; P < .001); factors unique to incurring a complication in the VQI include use of a suprarenal clamp and performance of an aortorenal bypass procedure as part of the repair (P < .01). Particularly weak correlation was noted between the PSI system and the VQI with respect to renal outcomes (ρ = 0.163). CONCLUSIONS: The PSI system identified fewer important complications than either of the clinically focused databases, with the VQI capturing the most postoperative events, mostly because of its stringent definition of renal injury. We conclude that the PSI system should not form the basis of grading hospital performance in comparing clinically relevant complications of open aortic surgery programs.
引用
- Sorber R, Giuliano KA, Hicks CW, et al. Patient Safety Indicators are an insufficient performance metric to track and grade outcomes of open aortic repair. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32442611. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.04.517
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。