ESVS 2019与NICE 2020腹主动脉瘤指南差异分析
本文比较了ESVS 2019与NICE 2020腹主动脉瘤指南在推荐意见上的差异原因。NICE采用多学科委员会、严格方法和随机对照试验证据及内部经济模型,形成46条推荐;ESVS采用专家委员会、较少严谨的证据评估,形成125条推荐。指南视角、方法和质量保证的不同可部分解释推荐差异。
要点
- NICE指南基于严格方法和经济模型,推荐开放手术优先治疗非破裂腹主动脉瘤。
- ESVS指南基于较不严谨的证据评估,推荐EVAR优先治疗非破裂腹主动脉瘤。
- 两指南在女性筛查、破裂腹主动脉瘤治疗选择等方面存在差异。
核心结论
- NICE与ESVS指南的差异可部分由视角、方法和质量保证的不同解释。
研究设计与样本
- 对两份指南委员会的方法、方法和证据进行回顾性分析。
主要发现
- NICE指南使用多学科委员会,严格依赖随机对照试验和内部经济模型,形成46条推荐。
- ESVS指南使用专家委员会,证据评估较不严谨,形成125条推荐。
- ESVS委员会更更新的证据检索部分解释了女性筛查推荐的差异。
- NICE推荐男性<71岁破裂腹主动脉瘤开放修复基于内部经济模型。
- NICE推荐非破裂腹主动脉瘤开放优先主要基于早期随机对照试验和英国经济模型,ESVS推荐EVAR优先基于现代但质量较低的观察性研究证据。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策时应理解指南推荐背后的方法学差异,结合患者具体情况选择治疗方案。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The aim was to understand why two recently published guidelines for the diagnosis and management of patients with abdominal aortic aneurysm, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) 2020 guidelines and the European Society for Vascular Surgery (ESVS) 2019 guidelines, have discordant recommendations in several important areas. METHODS: A review of the approach, methodology, and evidence used by the two guideline committees was carried out to understand potential reasons for their differing recommendations in their two final published guidelines. RESULTS: NICE guidelines use a multidisciplinary committee to address a limited number of prospectively identified questions, using rigorous methods heavily reliant on evidence from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) supported by in house economic modelling, with the purpose of providing the best, cost-effective health care in the UK in 46 main recommendations. The ESVS guidelines use an expert committee to encourage clinical effectiveness across a range of European health economies. ESVS guideline topics, but not questions, are prospectively identified, assessment of evidence was less rigorous, and 125 recommendations were made. More up to date evidence searches by the ESVS committee partially underscore the differences in recommendations for screening women. The NICE committee did not consider sex specific analysis or evidence for thresholds for intervention but relied on sex specific modelling to support their advice to use endovascular repair (EVAR) for ruptures in women. Their recommendation to use open repair for ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) in men aged < 71 years was based on in house economic modelling. NICE recommends an open first strategy for non-ruptured AAA mainly based on earlier RCTs and UK specific economic modelling, while the ESVS guidelines recommend an EVAR first strategy after consideration of modern, but lower quality, evidence from observational studies. Similar reasons explain differences in the recommended treatments of juxtarenal aneurysms. CONCLUSION: Differences between the NICE and ESVS guidelines can be explained, at least in part, by their differing perspectives, methodologies, and quality assurance. Future ESVS guidelines may benefit from more multidisciplinary input and prospectively identified questions.
引用
- Powell JT, Wanhainen A. Analysis of the Differences Between the ESVS 2019 and NICE 2020 Guidelines for Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32439141. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2020.04.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。