异常锁骨下动脉与主动脉病理的关联及分类系统提议
该研究基于南加州大学Keck医院2006至2018年的胸部横断面影像数据库,识别出312例异常锁骨下动脉(aSCA)患者,发现aSCA常伴有症状并与主动脉夹层和动脉瘤相关,提出了基于主动脉弓分支和椎动脉起源的分类系统。
要点
- aSCA在影像学中的检出率为0.82%,右侧占90.1%。
- Kommerell憩室在左侧aSCA中更常见且更大,症状更频繁。
- 提出的分类系统涵盖四种弓部变异和椎动脉起源亚型。
核心结论
- aSCA常伴有症状,并与主动脉夹层和动脉瘤相关。
- 提出的分类系统描述了所有四种aSCA弓部变异并考虑了椎动脉起源变异。
- 了解这些解剖变异对规划主动脉弓病理的血管内和开放修复至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,查询2006至2018年南加州大学Keck医院胸部横断面影像数据库。
- 共98,580例轴位影像研究,识别出810例研究(0.82%)存在aSCA,涉及312例独特患者。
- 评估aSCA侧别、变异解剖、主动脉及分支血管疾病,并复习病历了解相关症状和诊断。
主要发现
- 右侧aSCA占多数(90.1%),所有aSCA均经食管后走行。
- Kommerell憩室存在于184例(59%),平均直径1.67 cm(范围1.2-3.3 cm)。
- 左侧aSCA患者的Kommerell憩室更频繁(84% vs 56%;P = .0003)且更大(2.05 cm vs 1.61 cm;P < .0001)。
- 左侧aSCA的Kommerell憩室更常有症状(77.4% vs 49.1%;P = .005),吞咽困难、胸痛、反流和哮喘在左侧aSCA患者中更常见。
- 男性Kommerell憩室更常见(73.3% vs 50%;P < .0001)且更大(1.81 cm vs 1.54 cm;P < .0001),但症状无性别差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 分类系统:类型1,左弓伴右侧aSCA(59.9%);类型2,左弓伴共同颈动脉干和右侧aSCA(30.1%);类型3,右弓伴左侧aSCA(9.6%);类型4,右弓伴共同颈动脉干和左侧aSCA(0.3%)。
- 亚型基于椎动脉起源:锁骨下(s,右椎动脉90.1%,左椎动脉96.8%)、颈动脉(c,右椎动脉9.6%,左椎动脉0.3%)或弓部(a,右椎动脉0.3%,左椎动脉2.9%)。
临床怎么用
- 识别aSCA及其相关变异有助于规划主动脉弓病理的血管内和开放修复。
- 对于aSCA患者,应注意评估主动脉病理和Kommerell憩室,尤其左侧aSCA和男性患者。
- 提出的分类系统可用于描述解剖变异并指导临床决策。
局限性
- 研究为回顾性设计,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 研究不足以检测右侧与左侧aSCA在主动脉病理方面的差异(P = .213)。
- 样本来自单一中心,结果可能不完全具有普遍性。
- 未报告症状与主动脉病理之间的直接关联分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Aberrant subclavian artery (aSCA) is a rare anatomic variant whose association with other aortic branch variations and aortic pathology has yet to be established. Knowledge of such an association could be relevant to recommendations for screening and awareness as associated variations are important for operative planning. We describe the incidence of aSCA variations, its association with aortic pathology, and a proposed classification system. METHODS: The thoracic cross-sectional imaging database at Keck Hospital of the University of Southern California from 2006 to 2018 was queried for presence of aSCA. Studies were evaluated for aSCA laterality, variant anatomy, and aortic and branch vessel disease. Medical records were reviewed for associated symptoms and diagnoses. The primary outcome was association of aSCA with aortic pathology (aneurysm or dissection). Secondary outcomes were comparison of right and left aSCA, comparison between the sexes, and creation of a proposed classification system. RESULTS: Of 98,580 axial imaging studies, 810 studies (0.82%) were identified with aSCA in 312 unique patients. Right aSCA made up the majority of cases (90.1%). All aSCAs had a retroesophageal course. Kommerell's diverticulum (KD) was present in 184 (59%) with an average diameter of 1.67 cm (range, 1.2-3.3 cm). KD was more frequent (84% vs 56%; P = .0003) and larger (2.05 cm vs 1.61 cm; P < .0001) in left aSCA patients. When present, KD was more often symptomatic in left aSCA compared with right aSCA (77.4% vs 49.1%; P = .005). Dysphagia, chest pain, reflux, and asthma were all more common in left aSCA patients. KD was also more common in men (73.3% vs 50%; P < .0001) and larger in men (1.81 cm vs 1.54 cm; P < .0001) but with no difference in symptoms between sexes. Our proposed classification system based on aortic arch branching is as follows: type 1, left arch with right aSCA (59.9%); type 2, left arch with common carotid trunk and right aSCA (30.1%); type 3, right arch with left aSCA (9.6%); and type 4, right arch with common carotid trunk and left aSCA (0.3%). Subtypes describe the right vertebral artery (RVA) and left vertebral artery (LVA) origin: subclavian (s, RVA 90.1%, LVA 96.8%), carotid (c, RVA 9.6%, LVA 0.3%), or arch (a, RVA 0.3%, LVA 2.9%). Overall, 9.9% (31/312) had associated aortic pathology, although the study was underpowered to detect a difference between right aSCA and left aSCA (9.3% vs 16.1%; P = .213). Type 3 and type 4 arches more often have associated aortic pathology, KD, and symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: aSCAs are frequently symptomatic and commonly associated with aortic dissection and aneurysm. Our proposed classification scheme depicts all four aSCA arch variants and accounts for vertebral artery origin variation. These variants are common, and vertebral anatomy can differ greatly. Knowledge of these anatomic variations is critical to planning for endovascular and open repair of aortic arch pathology.
引用
- Plotkin A, Ng B, Han SM, et al. Association of aberrant subclavian arteries with aortic pathology and proposed classification system. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32238310. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2020.01.042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。