文献速递颈动脉与弓上血管

颈动脉内膜剥脱术外科医生年手术量阈值与患者预后

Defining the threshold surgeon volume associated with improved patient outcomes for carotid endarterectomy.
PubMed 文献 · J Vasc Surg · 2020-02-19

基于美国全国住院患者样本2003–2009年104,918例颈动脉内膜剥脱术(CEA)病例,分析外科医生年手术量与住院期间卒中或死亡复合终点的关系。无症状患者中,低、中、高手术量医生对应的卒中/死亡率分别为1.66%、0.91%、0.65%(P < .0001),最佳阈值为每年19.4例CEA;有症状患者中该关系不显著(P = .435)。

要点

  • 无症状颈动脉狭窄患者中,CEA年手术量≥20例与更低的住院卒中/死亡风险相关。
  • 有症状患者中,外科医生手术量与卒中/死亡复合终点无显著关系(P = .435)。
  • 数据库中仅16%的外科医生达到每年20例CEA的阈值。

核心结论

  • 较高的外科医生手术量与无症状颈动脉疾病患者CEA术后改善的预后相关,但与有症状患者无关。
  • 对于无症状颈动脉疾病,年手术量达到20例或以上时,卒中或死亡概率不再显著降低。
  • 目前基于医生手术量限制手术权限为时过早。

研究设计与样本

  • 分析美国全国住院患者样本(Nationwide Inpatient Sample)中2003年至2009年接受CEA的患者。
  • 共纳入104,918例有外科医生标识的CEA病例。
  • 采用混合线性回归分析确定年手术量是否为复合终点的独立预测因素,并用ROC曲线和Youden指数确定最佳截断点。

主要发现

  • CEA住院期间卒中或死亡的粗发生率为1.26%。
  • 有症状患者卒中或死亡率高于无症状患者(6.46% vs 0.72%;P < .0001)。
  • 无症状患者中,低、中、高手术量医生的卒中/死亡率分别为1.66%、0.91%、0.65%(P < .0001)。
  • 有症状患者中,手术量与复合终点的关系不显著(P = .435)。
  • 多变量分析确定年龄、非裔美国人种族、Charlson合并症指数和外科医生手术量为无症状颈动脉狭窄CEA术后卒中/死亡的独立预测因素。

关键数值与推荐

  • 预测无症状患者卒中/死亡的最佳年手术量截断点为19.4例CEA(敏感度=74.9%,特异度=72.6%,Youden指数=0.475)。
  • 年手术量低于20例CEA时粗并发症发生率和调整后卒中或死亡概率较高,20例或以上时较低。
  • 截断点高于20例/年并未显示卒中/死亡率显著低于20例/年,确认20例/年为阈值。
  • 数据库中仅16%的外科医生达到每年20例CEA的阈值。

临床怎么用

  • 对于无症状颈动脉狭窄患者,可考虑将年CEA手术量≥20例作为评估外科医生手术量的参考阈值。
  • 有症状患者中手术量与预后无关,提示不能仅凭手术量限制其CEA手术权限。
  • 其他影响CEA临床结局的变量较多,基于手术量限制权限需谨慎。

局限性

  • 研究为回顾性分析,可能存在混杂因素。
  • 仅使用住院期间卒中或死亡复合终点,未涵盖出院后结局。
  • 数据库仅16%外科医生达到阈值,推广性受限。
  • 作者指出还有其他变量影响CEA临床结局,基于手术量限制权限为时过早。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The outcomes for common vascular operations, such as carotid endarterectomy (CEA), are associated with surgeon volume. However, the number of operations associated with an improved stroke or death rate for CEA is not known. The objective of the current study was to define the annual surgeon volume of CEAs that is associated with a lower risk of stroke or death rate. METHODS: The Nationwide Inpatient Sample was analyzed to identify patients undergoing CEA between 2003 and 2009. Annual surgeon volume was correlated with a composite end point of in-hospital stroke or death. Mixed linear regression analyses were conducted to determine if annual surgeon volume of CEAs is independent predictor of the composite outcome. Receiver operating characteristic curves were constructed from the regression models and used to calculate the Youden Index, which defined the optimal cutoff point of annual surgeon volume of CEAs in predicting in-hospital stroke and death. This cutoff point was further assessed using Chi square analyses to determine whether incremental increases in the annual volume of CEAs were associated with a lower in-hospital stroke or death rate. RESULTS: A total of 104,918 CEA cases with surgeon identifiers were included in the analysis. The crude in-hospital stroke or death rate for CEA was 1.26 %. As expected, the stroke or death rate after CEA was higher for symptomatic patients, compared to asymptomatic patients (6.46 % vs 0.72%; P < .0001). For symptomatic patients, the relationship between surgeon volume and the composite end point was not significant (P = .435). In contrast, there was a strong relationship between surgeon volume and outcomes for asymptomatic patients undergoing CEA with a stroke/death rate of 1.66%, 0.91%, and 0.65% for low-, moderate-, and high-volume surgeons (P < .0001). Multivariate analysis identified age, African-American race, Charlson Comorbidity Index, and surgeon volume as independent predictors of stroke/death after CEA for asymptomatic carotid stenosis. For asymptomatic patients, the optimal cutoff number of CEAs to predict stroke/death rate was 19.4 CEAs per year (sensitivity = 74.9%, specificity = 72.6%, Youden index = 0.475). Analyses of outcomes at different cutoff points of surgeon volume revealed that the rate of crude complications and the adjusted probability of stroke or death was higher with case numbers less than 20 CEAs per year and lower with case numbers of 20 CEA or higher per year. Cutoff points above 20 cases were year did not yield a stroke/death rate that was significantly lower than the stroke/death rate at 20 CEAs per year, which confirmed the cutoff point of 20 CEAs per year. Only 16% of surgeons in the database achieved the threshold of 20 CEAs per year. CONCLUSIONS: Higher surgeon volume is associated with improved outcomes for CEAs performed in patients with asymptomatic carotid disease, but not for symptomatic carotid disease. For asymptomatic carotid disease, the probability of stroke or death was no longer reduced significantly at cutoff points of 20 or more CEAs per year. There are a number of other variables that may impact the clinical outcomes for CEA, so it is premature at this time to restrict privileges based on surgeon volume criteria.

来源:J Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Modrall JG, Tsai S, Ramanan B, et al. Defining the threshold surgeon volume associated with improved patient outcomes for carotid endarterectomy. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32085960. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2019.10.057

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。