心血管操作行政索赔研究中编码列表的转换:从ICD-9到ICD-10
本研究描述了一种方法,用于将先前验证过的ICD-9编码列表转换为ICD-10编码,以识别下肢血运重建、胸主动脉腔内修复、腹主动脉瘤再干预和颈动脉血运重建后的结局。使用通用等价映射工具从475个ICD-9编码衍生出46630个ICD-10编码,经手动审查后77%被删除(重复或不相关),最终列表保留4736个编码(49倍增加),表明手动临床审查至关重要。
要点
- ICD-10显著增加了描述血管操作后结局所需的编码数量。
- 通用等价映射产生的编码中超过75%为重复或不相关,需手动审查。
- 具有临床知识的研究者手动审查编码是确保事件准确检测的必要步骤。
核心结论
- ICD-10扩展了描述血管操作后结局所需的编码数量,通用等价映射数据库获得的编码中超过75%为重复或不相关,手动临床审查至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 方法学描述:基于先前验证的ICD-9编码列表(下肢血运重建、胸主动脉腔内修复、腹主动脉瘤再干预、颈动脉血运重建),使用公开通用等价映射工具衍生ICD-10编码,并由多位作者手动审查以确保临床相关性,删除不相关和重复编码。
主要发现
- 475个ICD-9编码转换为46630个ICD-10编码,增加98倍。
- 总体77%的编码(n=35833)在手动审查时为重复或不相关。
- 以胸主动脉腔内修复为例,97个ICD-9编码映射到14661个ICD-10编码,删除890个重复和9035个不相关编码后,最终列表含4736个编码,较初始ICD-9列表增加49倍。
- 其他操作的研究结果类似。
临床怎么用
- 在基于行政索赔数据的血管操作结局研究中,使用ICD-10编码前需由具备临床知识的研究者进行手动审查,以删除重复和不相关编码。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To effectively use administrative claims for healthcare research, clinical events must be inferred from coding data according to validated algorithms. In October 2015, the United States transitioned from the International Classification of Diseases Ninth Revision (ICD-9) to the Tenth Revision (ICD-10). We describe our method to derive new ICD-10 codes for outcomes after vascular procedures from our prior, validated ICD-9 codes. METHODS: We began with validated ICD-9 coding lists known to represent outcomes after lower extremity revascularization, thoracic aortic endograft placement, abdominal aortic aneurysm reintervention, and carotid revascularization. We used the publicly available general equivalence mapping tools to derive corresponding ICD-10 codes for each of the ICD-9 codes in our current lists. The resulting lists were then manually reviewed by multiple authors to ensure clinical relevance for appropriate event detection. Clinically nonrelevant and duplicated codes were removed. RESULTS: A total of 475 ICD-9 codes were translated to ICD-10 with a 98-fold increase (n = 46,630) in the total number of codes. Overall, we found that 77% of codes (n = 35,833) were either duplicated or not clinically relevant upon manual review. For example, for thoracic aortic endograft placement, 97 ICD-9 codes mapped to 14,661 ICD-10 codes in total. A total of 890 codes were removed as duplicates and 9035 codes were removed during manual clinical review. The resultant, reviewed list contained 4736 ICD-10 codes representing a 49-fold increase from the initial ICD-9 list. Findings were similar across the other procedures studied. CONCLUSIONS: ICD-10 has expanded the number of codes necessary to describe outcomes after vascular procedures. More than 75% of the codes obtained using the general equivalence mapping database were either duplicated or not clinically relevant. Manual review of codes by researchers with clinical knowledge of the procedures is imperative.
引用
- Wanken ZJ, Anderson PB, Bessen SY, et al. Translating coding lists in administrative claims-based research for cardiovascular procedures. J Vasc Surg. 2020. PMID: 32081477. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2019.09.040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。