足部动脉血管成形术的疗效不受踝下病变严重程度影响:多中心RENDEZVOUS注册研究亚组分析
本研究基于RENDEZVOUS注册研究,纳入257例慢性肢体威胁性缺血(CLTI)患者,按踝下病变严重程度(Kawarada 2型中度144例,3型重度113例)分组,比较足部动脉血管成形术(PAA)与非PAA组的结局。结果显示,无论病变严重程度,PAA组12个月伤口愈合率均显著高于非PAA组(中度58.8% vs 40.0%,p=0.049;重度59.6% vs 33.2%,p=0.021)。重度病变非PAA组保肢率最差(76.9%),总体比较p=0.028。
要点
- PAA可提高CLTI患者12个月伤口愈合率,不受踝下病变严重程度影响。
- 重度踝下病变患者中,PAA可能改善保肢率。
- PAA成功率在中度与重度病变间无显著差异(89.4% vs 87.8%,p=0.683)。
核心结论
- PAA改善CLTI患者伤口愈合率,与踝下病变严重程度无关。
- PAA可能改善累及前后足部循环的重度踝下病变患者的保肢率。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心RENDEZVOUS注册研究亚组分析,纳入257例连续CLTI患者(平均年龄73.2岁,175例男性),均有新发膝下及踝下动脉病变。
- 踝下病变分为中度(Kawarada 2型,144例)和重度(Kawarada 3型,113例);140例接受PAA(中度66例,重度74例),117例未接受PAA(中度78例,重度39例)。
- 主要结局为初始治疗后12个月的伤口愈合率和保肢率。
主要发现
- PAA成功率在中度与重度踝下病变患者中分别为89.4%和87.8%(p=0.683)。
- 12个月伤口愈合率:中度病变PAA组58.8% vs 非PAA组40.0%(p=0.049);重度病变PAA组59.6% vs 非PAA组33.2%(p=0.021)。
- 保肢率:非PAA/重度组最差(76.9%),非PAA/中度组94.8%,PAA/中度组90.9%,PAA/重度组87.8%(p=0.028)。
临床怎么用
- 对于CLTI合并踝下动脉病变患者,可考虑行PAA以改善伤口愈合,无论病变严重程度。
- 重度踝下病变累及前后足部循环时,PAA可能有助于保肢。
局限性
- 回顾性注册研究设计,存在选择偏倚可能。
- 样本量有限,亚组分析结果需谨慎解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Purpose: To examine the efficacy of pedal artery angioplasty (PAA) for chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI) according to the severity of inframalleolar disease. Methods: In total, 257 consecutive CLTI patients (mean age 73.2 years; 175 men) with de novo infrapopliteal and inframalleolar artery disease were enrolled from the retrospective RENDEZVOUS registry. Inframalleolar artery disease was classified as moderate (Kawarada type 2, 144 patients) or severe (Kawarada type 3, 113 patients). PAA was performed in 140 patients: 66 (45.8%) with moderate disease and 74 (65.5%) with severe disease. The remaining 117 patients (78 with moderate disease and 39 with severe disease) underwent interventions that did not include PAA. The primary outcomes were the wound healing and limb salvage rates at 12 months after the initial treatment. The outcomes of the PAA and no-PAA groups were examined to determine any correlation between treatment efficacy and baseline disease severity. Results: The success rates of PAA among the patients with moderate and severe inframalleolar disease were 89.4% and 87.8%, respectively (p=0.683). The wound healing rate at 12 months was significantly higher in the PAA group than in the no-PAA group regardless of the severity of inframalleolar disease [moderate: 58.8% vs 40.0% (p=0.049); severe: 59.6% vs 33.2% (p=0.021), respectively]. The worst limb salvage rate (76.9%) was seen among patients in the no-PAA group with severe inframalleolar disease (no-PAA/moderate: 94.8%; PAA/moderate: 90.9%; and PAA/severe: 87.8%, p=0.028). Conclusion: PAA improves the wound healing rate of patients with CLTI regardless of the severity of inframalleolar disease. This treatment modality also might improve limb salvage rates in patients with severe inframalleolar disease affecting both the anterior and posterior pedal circulations.
引用
- Tsubakimoto Y, Nakama T, Kamoi D, et al. Outcomes of Pedal Artery Angioplasty Are Independent of the Severity of Inframalleolar Disease: A Subanalysis of the Multicenter RENDEZVOUS Registry. J Endovasc Ther. 2020. PMID: 31997714. doi:10.1177/1526602820901838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。