上肢超声在疑似胸廓出口综合征相关锁骨下静脉血栓初始评估中的假阴性问题
该单中心回顾性研究纳入2008至2017年间接受首次手术治疗的静脉型胸廓出口综合征患者214例,初始均行上肢双功超声检查。结果显示超声在证实性VTOS患者中假阴性率达21%,假阴性报告极少注明中央锁骨下静脉显像受限,且假阴性结果与确定性影像和溶栓延迟及手术时更常需锁骨下静脉旁路重建相关。
要点
- 疑似SCV血栓患者初始上肢超声假阴性率可达21%。
- 假阴性超声报告仅18%注明中央SCV显像受限。
- 假阴性者确定性影像48小时内完成率更低(24% vs 44%)。
核心结论
- 双功超声在疑似SCV血栓初始评估中有明显局限,证实性VTOS患者中21%为假阴性。
- 初始超声假阴性可能延迟确定性影像、溶栓及进一步治疗。
- 初始超声假阴性结果与血栓进展及手术时更常需SCV旁路重建相关。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,纳入2008至2017年接受首次手术治疗的VTOS患者。
- 共214例以超声作为初始诊断检查的患者,平均年龄30.7±0.8岁(范围14-69)。
- 男性122例(57%),女性92例(43%),均表现为自发性特发性上肢肿胀。
主要发现
- 超声在症状出现后23.8±12.2天进行,169例(79%)证实腋-锁骨下静脉血栓,45例(21%)阴性。
- 假阴性超声报告中仅8例(18%)注明中央SCV显像受限。
- 确定性影像包括上肢静脉造影175例(82%)、CTA 24例(11%)、MRA 15例(7%)。
- 142例(66%)接受导管导向腋-锁骨下静脉溶栓。
- 超声阳性组48小时内完成确定性影像比例高于假阴性组(44% vs 24%;P = .02)。
关键数值与推荐
- 超声假阴性定义为初始上肢双功超声未见血栓但后续证实VTOS。
- 确定性影像方式包括静脉造影、CTA或MRA。
- 假阴性者需SCV旁路重建比例44% vs 超声阳性者25%(P = .02)。
临床怎么用
- 对疑似SCV血栓/VTOS患者,超声阴性不能排除诊断,应结合临床并考虑静脉造影、CTA或MRA。
- 超声报告应明确注明中央锁骨下静脉显像是否受限,以提示假阴性可能。
- 对超声阴性但临床高度怀疑者应尽快完成确定性影像,避免延迟溶栓和手术。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性设计。
- 样本仅纳入最终接受手术治疗的患者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the utilization and consequences of upper extremity Duplex ultrasound in the initial diagnostic evaluation of patients with suspected subclavian vein (SCV) thrombosis and venous thoracic outlet syndrome (VTOS). METHODS: A retrospective single-center review was conducted for patients that underwent primary surgical treatment for VTOS between 2008 and 2017, in whom an upper extremity ultrasound had been performed as the initial diagnostic test (n = 214). Clinical and treatment characteristics were compared between patients with positive and false-negative ultrasound studies. RESULTS: There were 122 men (57%) and 92 women (43%) that had presented with spontaneous idiopathic arm swelling, including 28 (13%) with proven pulmonary embolism, at a mean age of 30.7 ± 0.8 years (range 14-69). Upper extremity ultrasound had been performed 23.8 ± 12.2 days after the onset of symptoms, with confirmation of axillary-SCV thrombosis in 169 patients (79%) and negative results in 45 (21%). Of the false-negative ultrasound study reports, only 8 (18%) acknowledged limitations in visualizing the central SCV. Definitive diagnostic imaging (DDI) had been obtained by upper extremity venography in 175 (82%), computed tomography angiography in 24 (11%), and magnetic resonance angiography in 15 (7%), with 142 (66%) undergoing catheter-directed axillary-SCV thrombolysis. The mean interval between initial ultrasound and DDI was 48.9 ± 14.2 days with no significant difference between groups, but patients with a positive ultrasound were more likely to have DDI within 48 hours than those with a false-negative ultrasound (44% vs 24%; P = .02). At the time of surgical treatment, the SCV was widely patent following paraclavicular decompression and external venolysis alone in 74 patients (35%). Patch angioplasty was performed for focal SCV stenosis in 76 (36%) and bypass graft reconstruction for long-segment axillary-SCV occlusion in 63 (29%). Patients with false-negative initial ultrasound studies were significantly more likely to require SCV bypass reconstruction than those with a positive ultrasound (44% vs 25%; P = .02). CONCLUSIONS: Duplex ultrasound has significant limitations in the initial evaluation of patients with suspected SCV thrombosis, with false-negative results in 21% of patients with proven VTOS. This is rarely acknowledged in ultrasound reports, but false-negative ultrasound studies have the potential to delay definitive imaging, thrombolysis, and further treatment for VTOS. Initial false-negative ultrasound results are associated with progressive thrombus extension and a more frequent need for SCV bypass reconstruction at the time of surgical treatment.
引用
- Brownie ER, Abuirqeba AA, Ohman JW, et al. False-negative upper extremity ultrasound in the initial evaluation of patients with suspected subclavian vein thrombosis due to thoracic outlet syndrome (Paget-Schroetter syndrome). J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2019. PMID: 31732483. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.08.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。