趾臂指数预测静息踝臂指数正常患者平板运动试验结果的能力
这项前瞻性对比研究纳入415例疑似血管性跛行且静息ABI在0.91至1.40之间的患者,共830条肢体,评估静息TBI与平板运动后ABI诊断PAD的一致性。结果显示两种方法一致性仅60%(kappa=0.166),TBI降低程度与运动后ABI异常概率相关,但部分因低TBI肢体静息ABI更低所致,二者不可互换用于诊断PAD。
要点
- 静息ABI正常(0.91–1.40)的疑似跛行患者中,低TBI(≤0.70)占39%。
- TBI与运动后ABI诊断PAD的一致性仅60%(kappa=0.166,95%CI 0.096–0.232)。
- TBI降低程度与运动后ABI异常概率相关,但不能替代运动后ABI诊断PAD。
核心结论
- TBI降低程度与运动后ABI异常概率增加相关,但部分归因于低TBI肢体静息ABI平均更低。
- TBI与运动后ABI在建立PAD诊断上不可互换。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性对比研究,历时30个月,纳入415例疑似血管性跛行且静息0.91≤ABI<1.40的患者,共830条肢体。
- 所有肢体均评估静息TBI和平板运动后ABI。
主要发现
- 830条肢体中325条(39%)TBI低(≤0.70),505条(61%)TBI正常。
- 低TBI肢体中160条(49%)运动后ABI诊断PAD,正常TBI肢体中165条(33%)诊断PAD。
- 两种方法诊断PAD总体一致性为500/830(60%),Cohen kappa=0.166(95%CI 0.096–0.232)。
- 低TBI肢体平均静息ABI低于正常TBI肢体(1.07±0.09 vs. 1.13±0.10,P<0.001)。
- 在ABI 0.96–1.00和ABI>1.10区间,低TBI组异常试验结果比例显著高于正常TBI组(P≤0.022),其他ABI区间无显著差异(P>0.200)。
关键数值与推荐
- 低TBI定义为≤0.70。
- 静息ABI纳入范围为0.91≤ABI<1.40。
- 两种方法诊断PAD一致性60%,kappa=0.166(95%CI 0.096–0.232)。
临床怎么用
- 对静息ABI正常但疑似跛行的患者,TBI与运动后ABI不可互相替代,需分别评估。
- 低TBI肢体静息ABI平均更低,解读TBI结果时应结合静息ABI水平。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) in the presence of a normal ankle-brachial index (ABI) can be diagnosed noninvasively by measuring a postexercise ABI or by measuring the toe-brachial index (TBI). METHODS: This was a prospective comparative study. Over a period of 30 months, a total of 415 patients who were referred with the suspicion of vascular claudication and resting values of 0.91 ≤ ABI<1.40 were further evaluated for the resting TBI and postexercise ABI by treadmill testing. RESULTS: A total of 325 (39%) of the 830 investigated limbs had a low TBI (≤0.70), and 505 (61%) had a normal TBI. Of the limbs with a low TBI, 160 (49%) had PAD according to a postexercise ABI versus 165 (33%) of the limbs with normal TBI. The overall agreement in PAD classification between the two methods was 500/830 (60%) with a Cohen's kappa = 0.166 (95% CI: 0.096-0.232). The data showed an inverse correlation between the magnitude of the TBI decrease, as well as the resting ABI, and the probability of an abnormal postexercise ABI. On average, limbs with a low TBI had a lower resting ABI than patients with a normal TBI (1.07 ± 0.09 vs. 1.13 ± 0.10, P < 0.001). The groups with a low TBI had a significantly higher ratio of abnormal test results than patients with a normal TBI, in limbs with ABI (0.96-1.00) and ABI >1.10 (P ≤ 0.022 for both), but there were no statistically significant differences found in other ABI intervals (P > 0.200 for all). CONCLUSIONS: The magnitude of the TBI reduction correlates with an increased probability of an abnormal postexercise ABI. However, this is due in part to limbs with a low TBI having a lower resting ABI on average than limbs with a normal TBI, which also correlates with the probability of an abnormal exercise test result. This study shows that the TBI and the postexercise ABI are not interchangeable for establishing a PAD diagnosis.
引用
- Høyer C, Strandberg J, Overvad Jordansen MK, et al. The Ability of the Toe-Brachial Index to Predict the Outcome of Treadmill Exercise Testing in Patients with a Normal Resting Ankle-Brachial Index. Ann Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31639481. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2019.10.041
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。