搏动性人体尸体循环模型在血管腔内训练中的教育影响
研究招募24名血管腔内新手,随机分入搏动性人体尸体模型(PHCM)组和虚拟现实模拟器(VRS)组,各完成8次肾动脉插管训练并交叉验证。PHCM组整体操作评分从19.42逐步升至39.50(p < .0005),VRS组从20.54升至36.04(p < .0005)但第2次后提升有限;PHCM训练后VRS交叉考核评分显著改善(p ≤ .0001)且与完成VRS训练者相当(p = .398),而VRS训练后PHCM交叉考核评分虽改善(p < 0.05)但显著差于完成PHCM训练者(p ≤ .001)。结论支持在患者血管腔内手术前先进行VRS训练再行PHCM训练。
要点
- PHCM训练学习曲线更长、逐步提升,反映模型难度更高更接近真实。
- PHCM训练后转至VRS操作表现与完成VRS训练者相当。
- 建议血管腔内术前先VRS后PHCM序贯训练。
核心结论
- PHCM训练学习曲线更长且逐步改善,反映更真实模型带来的更高难度。
- 结果支持在患者血管腔内手术前采用VRS训练后接PHCM训练的序贯方案。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入24名血管腔内新手,均分为PHCM组和VRS组。
- 每人在指定模型上连续完成8次肾动脉插管训练,并在另一模型上进行最终交叉考核。
- 操作录像由两名对受试者身份和尝试次数设盲的血管腔内专家使用经验证评分工具评分。
- 评分包括任务特异性清单评分(TSC)、全局评分(GRS)和整体操作评分(OPS)。
主要发现
- PHCM组平均OPS从19.42(TSC 8.58,GRS 10.83)逐步提升至39.50(TSC 15.00,GRS 24.5)(p < .0005)。
- VRS组OPS从20.54(TSC 10.29,GRS 10.25)提升至36.04(TSC 14.21,GRS 21.88)(p < .0005),第2次尝试后提升有限。
- PHCM训练显著改善其VRS交叉考核OPS(p ≤ .0001),与完成VRS训练者OPS相似(p = .398)。
- VRS训练显著改善PHCM交叉考核OPS(p < 0.05),但显著差于完成PHCM训练者(p ≤ .001)。
临床怎么用
- 血管腔内手术培训可先使用VRS降低初始学习难度,再过渡至PHCM进行高仿真训练。
- PHCM适合作为患者手术前的进阶训练模型,因其学习曲线更长且更接近真实操作。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The face and construct validity of a novel pulsatile human cadaver model (PHCM) was recently demonstrated for endovascular training. This study aimed to assess the model's educational impact. METHODS: Twenty-four endovascular novices were recruited and split into two equal training groups: PHCM and virtual reality simulator (VRS). Each candidate performed eight consecutive training attempts of endovascular renal artery catheterisation on their designated model, and a final crossover attempt on the alternate model. Performances were video recorded and scored using a validated scoring tool by two independent endovascular experts, blinded to the candidate's identity and attempt number. Each participant was given a task specific checklist score (TSC), global rating score (GRS), and overall procedure score (OPS). RESULTS: In the PHCM group average OPS improved gradually from 19.42 (TSC 8.58, GRS 10.83) to 39.50 (TSC 15.00, GRS 24.5) over eight attempts (p < .0005). In the VRS group OPS improved from 20.54 (TSC 10.29, GRS 10.25) to 36.04 (TSC 14.21, GRS 21.88) between the first and eighth attempts (p < .0005), with limited improvement after the second attempt. PHCM training significantly improved OPS on their VRS crossover attempt (p ≤ .0001), achieving a similar OPS to candidates who had completed VRS training (p = .398). VRS training significantly improved OPS on PHCM (p < 0.05); however, OPS was significantly worse than candidates who had completed PHCM training (p ≤ .001). CONCLUSIONS: PHCM training has a longer learning curve, with gradual improvement, reflecting the enhanced difficulty of a more realistic model. These results support the use of PHCM preceded by VRS training, prior to performing endovascular surgery on patients.
引用
- Nesbitt CI, Tingle SJ, Williams R, et al. Educational Impact of a Pulsatile Human Cadaver Circulation Model for Endovascular Training. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31495728. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2019.03.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。