机械化学消融与热消融治疗静脉性溃疡愈合的比较
回顾性分析66例临床6级慢性静脉功能不全伴静脉性溃疡患者,比较机械化学消融(MOCA)与热消融的溃疡愈合情况。MOCA组74%愈合,热消融组35%愈合(P=.01);平均愈合时间分别为2.3个月和4.4个月(P=.01)。多因素分析显示年龄和治疗方式独立影响溃疡愈合。
要点
- MOCA组溃疡愈合率显著高于热消融组(74% vs 35%,P=.01)。
- MOCA组平均愈合时间更短(2.3个月 vs 4.4个月,P=.01)。
- 年龄和治疗方式(MOCA)是溃疡愈合的独立影响因素。
核心结论
- MOCA治疗慢性静脉性溃疡安全有效,结果与依赖热消融的方法相当。
- 年轻和采用MOCA有利于伤口愈合,MOCA是溃疡愈合的独立预测因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性电子病历 review,纳入2012年2月至2015年11月因静脉性溃疡接受主干或穿通支消融的患者。
- 共66例患者、82个静脉节段,热消融29个、MOCA 53个;16%患者有既往静脉干预史。
- 热消融组3例、MOCA组7例有深静脉血栓史;热消融组平均年龄57.2岁,MOCA组67.9岁(P=.0003)。
- 干预前溃疡持续时间热消融组9.2个月、MOCA组11.2个月(P=NS)。
主要发现
- MOCA组74%患者溃疡愈合,热消融组35%(P=.01);愈合定义为溃疡深度消除且表面皮肤覆盖。
- 平均愈合时间热消融组4.4个月,MOCA组2.3个月(P=.01)。
- 平均随访时间热消融组12.8个月,MOCA组7.9个月(P=.02)。
- 多因素logistic回归显示年龄(P=.03)和治疗方式(P=.03)独立影响溃疡愈合。
临床怎么用
- MOCA可作为静脉性溃疡患者消融治疗的替代选择,尤其对老年患者可能更有利。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,样本量有限,需随机对照研究进一步证实。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We aimed to compare mechanochemical ablation (MOCA) and thermal ablation (radiofrequency ablation and endovenous laser therapy) for venous ulcer healing in patients with clinical class 6 chronic venous insufficiency. METHODS: Electronic medical records were reviewed of patients with venous ulcers who underwent truncal or perforator ablation between February 2012 and November 2015. These records contained history of venous disease and ulcer history, procedures, complications, follow-up, method of wound care, and current status of the ulcer. The patients were grouped according to the method of ablation for comparison. RESULTS: In 66 patients, 82 venous segments were treated, 29 with thermal methods and 53 with MOCA; 16% of patients had prior venous intervention. Before ablation, three patients in the thermal group had a history of deep venous thrombosis compared with seven in the MOCA group. On average, patients treated with MOCA were older (thermal ablation, 57.2 years; MOCA, 67.9 years; P = .0003). Ulcer duration before intervention ranged from 9.2 months for thermal ablation to 11.2 months for MOCA (P = NS). In total, 74% of patients treated with MOCA healed their ulcers compared with 35% of those treated with thermal ablation (P = .01). A healed ulcer was defined as elimination of ulcer depth and superficial skin coverage. The mean time to heal was 4.4 months in the thermal ablation group compared with 2.3 months with MOCA (P = .01). The mean length of follow-up was 12.8 months after thermal ablation and 7.9 months after MOCA (P = .02). Both age (P = .03) and treatment modality (P = .03) independently had an impact on ulcer healing on multiple logistic regression analysis. All but two patients were treated with an Unna boot after venous ablation. Complications included readmission of two patients with nonaccess-related infections, one nonocclusive deep venous thrombosis, and one late death unrelated to the procedure second to pneumonia in the setting of advanced colon cancer. There were three recurrent ulcers at 1 week, 2 months, and 7 months after MOCA that rehealed with Unna boot therapy and continued compression. CONCLUSIONS: MOCA is safe and effective in treating chronic venous ulcers and appears to provide comparable results to methods that rely on thermal ablation. Younger age and use of MOCA favored wound healing. MOCA was an independent predictor of ulcer healing. Randomized studies are necessary to further support our findings.
引用
- Kim SY, Safir SR, Png CYM, et al. Mechanochemical ablation as an alternative to venous ulcer healing compared with thermal ablation. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2019. PMID: 31421838. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.05.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。