腹腔干上 vs 腹腔干下近端锚定区在开窗/分支EVAR中的比较
本研究基于单中心175例开窗/分支腔内主动脉修复(F/B-EVAR)前瞻数据库,比较腹腔干上锚定区(4血管修复,n=67)与腹腔干下锚定区(<4血管修复,n=108)的围术期特征与术后结局。4血管修复手术时间和手术室直接费用更高,但死亡率、 paraparesis、瘫痪及1年生存、靶动脉通畅率和再干预率无差异;4血管修复1年无1/3型内漏率更低(82% vs 94%,P=0.02),主要由3型内漏增加驱动。
要点
- 腹腔干上锚定区增加手术时间和手术室直接费用,但临床结局无显著差异。
- 4血管修复1年无1/3型内漏率更低(82% vs 94%),主要因3型内漏增加。
- 为获得足够近端锚定区长度,应低阈值纳入腹腔干。
核心结论
- F/B-EVAR中使用腹腔干上锚定区与腹腔干下锚定区相比,在手术特征和资源利用上有统计学差异,但临床意义可忽略。
- 消除开窗/分支处的3型内漏仍是未满足的需求。
- 为达到足够的F/B-EVAR近端锚定区长度,应低阈值纳入腹腔干。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心前瞻性数据库(IRB批准、医生发起的IDE试验,2010年10月至2017年6月)纳入175例F/B-EVAR。
- 按纳入内脏-肾动脉数量分类:4血管修复(n=67,38%) vs <4血管修复(n=108,62%)。
- 比较动脉瘤特征、围术期细节和术后并发症,采用Kaplan-Meier估计1年生存、靶动脉通畅、无1/3型内漏和无再干预。
主要发现
- 4血管修复组中位手术时间更长(4.8小时,IQR 4.1-5.8 vs 3.6小时,IQR 2.9-4.1,P<0.0001)。
- 4血管修复组平均手术室直接费用更高($52,532,SD=18,640 vs $40,128,SD=15,135,P<0.0001)。
- 两组死亡率(1.9% vs 4.5%)、paraparesis(0% vs 3.0%)、瘫痪(0.9% vs 0%)均无差异(P=NS)。
- 1年生存、靶动脉通畅率和无再干预率无差异。
- 4血管修复组1年无1/3型内漏率更低(82% vs 94%,log-rank P=0.02),由3型内漏增加驱动。
临床怎么用
- 为获得足够近端锚定区长度,应低阈值纳入腹腔干。
- 需进一步创新以消除开窗/分支处的3型内漏。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Fenestrated/branched endovascular aneurysm repair (F/B-EVAR) achieves more extensive proximal seal than conventional infrarenal devices, thereby increasing aneurysm exclusion durability. Optimal seal zone length remains undefined. We assessed relative risks and benefits of extending the proximal seal above the celiac artery. METHODS: The prospective database of all complex endovascular aortic aneurysm repairs at a single institution (institutional review board-approved, physician-sponsored investigational device exemption trial, 10/2010-6/2017) was used to classify repairs according to the number of target visceral-renal arteries incorporated: 4-vessel versus <4-vessel. Comparisons of aneurysm characteristics, perioperative details, and postoperative complications were performed, stratified by repair type. One-year survival, target artery patency, freedom from type 1 or 3 endoleak, and freedom from reintervention were estimated with Kaplan-Meier analysis. RESULTS: Among 175 F/B-EVARs, 38% (n = 67) were 4-vessel and 62% (n = 108) were <4-vessel. Intraoperatively, there was no difference in mean contrast use (76 mL vs. 74 mL, P = non significant [NS]) or dose area product (63,428 mGy cm2 vs. 96,015 mGy cm2), but there was increased median procedure time (4.8 hr, interquartile range [IQR] = 4.1-5.8 versus 3.6 hr, IQR = 2.9-4.1, P < 0.0001) and mean operating room direct costs ($52,532, standard deviation [SD] = 18,640 versus $40,128, SD = 15,135, P < 0.0001) in 4-vessel repairs. There were no differences in mortality (1.9% vs. 4.5%), paraparesis (0% vs. 3.0%), or paralysis (0.9% vs. 0%), all P = NS. There were no differences in one-year survival, target artery patency, or freedom from reintervention. There was a lower 1-year freedom from type 1 or 3 endoleak with 4-vessel repairs (82% vs. 94%, log-rank P = 0.02), driven by an increased rate of type 3 endoleaks. Endoleak resolution after treatment was equivalent in both groups (4-vessel, 10 of 12, 83% resolved; <4-vessel, 7 of 7, 100% resolved, P = NS). CONCLUSIONS: With F/B-EVAR, utilization of a supraceliac seal zone, compared with an infraceliac seal zone, is associated with statistical differences in operative characteristics/resource utilization, but with negligible clinical significance. Further innovation to eliminate type 3 endoleaks at fenestrations/branches remains an unmet need. To achieve adequate F/B-EVAR proximal seal zone length, one should have a low threshold to incorporate the celiac artery.
引用
- Simons JP, Podder S, Dossabhoy SS, et al. Fenestrated/Branched Endovascular Aortic Aneurysm Repair Using a Supraceliac Aortic Proximal Seal Zone Versus an Infraceliac Aortic Proximal Seal Zone. Ann Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31382008. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2019.04.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。