美国 Medicare 数据中静脉腔内消融实践趋势回顾
该研究查询 Medicare 提供者利用与支付数据库中 2012 至 2015 年的热消融 CPT 代码,分析静脉腔内消融的实践趋势。结果显示大多数大隐静脉消融由血管外科医生(29%)、心内科医生(21%)或普外科医生(14%)完成,其余三分之一由 33 个其他专科提供者完成。南部地区占 51% 的消融量,西部增长率最高(62%),平均每患者消融次数为 1.8 次,且无正式血管培训专科的每患者消融次数高于平均水平。
要点
- 静脉腔内消融由多种亚专科医生实施,血管外科占比最高(29%)。
- 南部地区消融量占 51%,西部增长最快(62%)。
- 平均每患者消融 1.8 次,无血管培训专科的每患者消融次数高于平均。
核心结论
- 静脉腔内消融由不同正式培训水平的多种亚专科医生实施,用于慢性静脉疾病管理。
- 该数据分析有助于建立更好的指南和治理,但需注意这只是平均值,许多患者可能需要超过两次消融才能获得适当治疗。
- 随着医疗体系从按服务付费转向价值导向,应使用数据驱动举措审查实践趋势,以确保适当医生以适当理由治疗适当患者。
研究设计与样本
- 查询 Medicare 提供者利用与支付数据库中 2012 至 2015 年的热消融 CPT 代码(36475、36476、36478、36479)。
- 将结果导入关系数据库程序,设计查询以确定所有提供者(包括所有专科)的实践趋势,并导出至电子表格分析。
- 通过评估提供者实施至少一次消融的受益人数与该提供者实施的总消融次数,计算每患者消融次数。
主要发现
- 大多数大隐静脉消融由血管外科医生(29%)、心内科医生(21%)或普外科医生(14%)完成。
- 其余三分之一由 33 个其他提供者专科完成,范围从核医学专家到眼科医生。
- 区域差异显著,51% 的消融在南部进行(佛罗里达州 15.7%,德克萨斯州 11.4%)。
- 西部区域百分比增长最大,为 62%,2012 至 2015 年间新增 14,788 例。
- 总体数据集中每患者消融次数平均为 1.8 次。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应知晓静脉腔内消融由多种专科提供者实施,包括无正式血管培训的专科。
- 在评估患者是否需要多次消融时,应考虑平均每患者消融 1.8 次仅为平均值,部分患者可能需要超过两次消融。
- 应关注区域实践差异和每患者消融次数,以促进适当使用。
局限性
- 该分析仅基于 Medicare 提供者利用与支付数据库,可能不涵盖所有支付方或患者人群。
- 每患者消融次数为平均值,不能反映个体患者适当需求。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The growth of endovenous ablation in the United States over the last few years has raised concerns of overuse by many vascular societies and payers. Reasons for such growth are unclear (ie, increased awareness, less invasive procedure, or inappropriate overuse). The Medicare Provider Utilization and Payment database was analyzed to define metrics of current practice trends in Medicare patients by providers. METHODS: The Medicare Provider Utilization and Payment database was queried for endothermal ablation Current Procedural Terminology codes (36475, 36476, 36478, and 36479) from 2012 through 2015. These results were imported into a relational database program. Queries were designed to ascertain the practice trends of all providers, inclusive of all specialties, and the data were exported to a spreadsheet program for analysis. Analysis for ablations per patient was calculated by assessing the number of beneficiaries who underwent at least one ablation by a provider in relation to the total number of ablations performed by that provider. RESULTS: Most saphenous vein ablations were done by vascular surgeons (29%), cardiologists (21%), or general surgeons (14%). The remaining one-third was performed by 33 other provider specialties ranging from nuclear medicine specialists to ophthalmologists. Regional variation was significant with 51% of ablations being performed in the south (Florida, 15.7% and Texas, 11.4%). The Western region had the greatest percentage growth of 62% with the addition of 14,788 cases added between 2012 and 2015. Ablations per patient averaged 1.8 in the aggregate dataset. Over the 4-year period, there was a steady increase seen in the number of patients undergoing ablation, number of ablations performed, number of providers performing ablation, average amount of ablations being performed as well as the number and proportion of providers performing more than ablations per patient. The number of ablations per patient was higher than average in specialties without any formal vascular training. CONCLUSIONS: Endovenous ablation is performed by a wide variety of subspecialists with different levels of formal training for the management of chronic venous disease. This data analysis can help to establish better guidelines and governance over the use of endovenous ablation, but care should be taken to realize this is only an average and many patients will require more than two ablations for appropriate care. As our health care system shifts from a fee-for-service to a value-based system, and taxpayer-funded resources in Medicare patients become less available, it is important that practice trends be scrutinized using data-driven initiatives so that the appropriate physician treats the appropriate patient for the appropriate reasons.
引用
- Crawford JM, Gasparis A, Almeida J, et al. A review of United States endovenous ablation practice trends from the Medicare Data Utilization and Payment Database. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2019. PMID: 31203856. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2019.01.066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。