颈动脉手术按亚组评估的疗效:卒中预防潜力概念
该研究重新审视症状性与无症状性颈动脉狭窄的标志性研究,设计简化计算器评估每1000例颈动脉内膜剥脱术(CEA)的5年卒中预防率(SPP,范围0-478),并纳入赫尔辛基大学医院2008-2016年1861例CEA队列。结果显示症状性与无症状性狭窄的卒中加死亡率分别为3.6%和0.3%,SPP从2008年的123升至2016年的229,期间估计预防350例缺血性卒中。作者认为不考虑纳入标准时CEA系列的国际比较无意义。
要点
- SPP整合症状状态、症状新旧、性别、狭窄程度与并发症率,量化CEA的卒中预防潜力。
- 症状性CEA卒中加死亡率为3.6%,无症状性为0.3%,两亚组差异明显。
- 2016年77%的CEA在索引事件两周内完成,SPP由2008年123升至2016年229。
核心结论
- 不考虑纳入标准时,不同CEA系列的国家和国际比较无意义。
- SPP随时间升高,可能提示患者选择改善及CEA预防卒中数量增加。
研究设计与样本
- revisited症状性与无症状性CEA标志性研究,利用已发表疗效估计设计简化计算器。
- 纳入赫尔辛基大学医院2008-2016年经血管登记(HUSVASC)收集的CEA患者并分类分析。
主要发现
- 症状性CEA卒中加死亡率为3.6%,无症状性为0.3%。
- 索引事件两周内完成CEA的比例随访期内上升,2016年为77%。
- SPP从2008年123升至2016年229;2008-16年估计预防350例缺血性卒中。
关键数值与推荐
- SPP计算器范围0-478,评估每1000例CEA的5年卒中预防率。
- 模型纳入症状存在与近期性、性别、狭窄严重度增加及并发症率。
临床怎么用
- 可用SPP计算器结合登记数据比较不同CEA实践的真实卒中预防效果。
- 评估CEA质量时应同时报告治疗延迟、症状状态与手术并发症率,而非孤立解读。
局限性
- 为单中心登记队列分析,SPP模型基于已发表疗效估计而非本队列随机对照验证。
- 理论患者选择场景为模型推演,非实际干预试验结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Considering carotid endarterectomy (CEA), reporting treatment delay, symptom status, and surgical complication rates separately gives an incomplete picture of efficacy; therefore, the aim was to combine these factors and develop a reporting standard that better describes the number of potentially prevented strokes. With a real life cohort and theoretical inclusion scenarios, the aim was to explore the stroke prevention potential of different carotid practices. METHODS: Landmark studies for symptomatic and asymptomatic patients were revisited. By using published estimates of treatment effect, a simplified calculator was designed to assess the five year stroke prevention rate per 1000 CEAs (stroke prevention potential [SPP], range 0-478), including the presence and recentness of symptoms, sex, increasing stenosis severity, and complication rates. Patients operated on for carotid stenosis at Helsinki University Hospital (HUH) between 2008 and 2016 were collected from a vascular registry (HUSVASC) and categorised according to the model. The local annual complication rate was re-evaluated and added to the model. The HUH patient cohort was incorporated into the SPP model, and changes over time analysed. Finally, theoretical changes in patient selection were compared in order to explore the theoretical impact of patient selection and shortening of the delay. RESULTS: Fifteen hundred and five symptomatic and 356 asymptomatic carotid stenoses were operated on with stroke plus death rates of 3.6% and 0.3%, respectively. The proportion of CEAs performed within two weeks of the index event increased over the follow up period, being 77% in 2016. The SPP increased from 123 in 2008 to 229 in 2016. Theoretically, 350 ischaemic strokes were prevented in the period 2008-16, with 1861 CEAs. CONCLUSIONS: National and international comparison of different CEA series is irrelevant if the inclusion criteria are not considered. A calculator that is easy to apply to large scale high quality registered data was developed and tested. SPP was found to increase over time, which is a probable sign of improved patient selection and an increased number of strokes prevented by the CEAs performed.
引用
- Aro E, Ijäs P, Vikatmaa L, et al. The Efficacy of Carotid Surgery by Subgroups: The Concept of Stroke Prevention Potential. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31182335. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2019.04.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。