经验丰富术者内镜取静脉可提高下肢旁路通畅率并减少伤口并发症
单中心回顾113例重症肢体缺血患者,比较内镜取大隐静脉(EVH,n=49)与单切口开放取静脉(OVH,n=64)行腹股沟下旁路的结果。EVH由具有>5年该技术经验的术者完成,其伤口并发症更少,次级通畅率更优,90天再入院更少。与作者早期EVH系列相比,本队列3年各通畅率均显著改善。
要点
- 经验丰富术者行EVH可减少伤口并发症(28% vs 2%,P < .001)。
- EVH次级通畅率优于OVH(3年95% vs 79%,P = .03)。
- EVH较早期经验阶段3年通畅率显著提升,提示学习曲线效应。
核心结论
- 经验丰富的术者采用EVH行下肢旁路,通畅率可优于OVH及早期EVH经验,同时减少伤口并发症和再入院,手术时间与住院天数相当。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,2012至2017年113例重症肢体缺血行腹股沟下旁路并取连续大隐静脉段,EVH 49例、OVH 64例。
- EVH由具有>5年该技术经验的术者完成。
- 将EVH数据与作者既往报告的早期EVH系列比较以评估经验效应。
主要发现
- 两组患者人口学、用药、手术指征及流入/流出血管无显著差异。
- OVH平均手术时间322分钟、住院中位6天;EVH为340分钟、5天,均无统计学意义。
- 伤口并发症OVH 28% vs EVH 2%(P < .001)。
- 1年与3年初级通畅率OVH 65%、58%,EVH 79%、71%(P = .18);辅助初级通畅率OVH 77%、74%,EVH 94%、89%(P = .05);次级通畅率OVH 82%、79%,EVH 95%、95%(P = .03)。
- 30天再入院率OVH 20% vs EVH 12%(P = .26);90天再入院率OVH 34% vs EVH 14%(P = .018)。
关键数值与推荐
- 伤口并发症:OVH 28% vs EVH 2%,P < .001。
- 次级通畅率3年:OVH 79% vs EVH 95%,P = .03。
- 90天再入院率:OVH 34% vs EVH 14%,P = .018。
- 与早期EVH系列比较:3年初级通畅率71% vs 42%(P = .012)、辅助初级通畅率89% vs 66%(P = .034)、次级通畅率95% vs 66%(P = .003)。
临床怎么用
- 在具备EVH经验的中心,可将EVH作为下肢旁路取大隐静脉的首选方式,以减少伤口并发症和再入院。
- EVH的学习曲线可能影响通畅率,需在经验积累后评估其获益。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性设计,样本量113例,可能存在选择偏倚。
- EVH组由>5年经验术者完成,结果不能直接外推至初学者。
- 与早期EVH系列为历史对照比较,非同期随机对照。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Prior studies have suggested improved wound complication rates but decreased primary patency in lower extremity bypasses performed with endoscopic vein harvest (EVH) vs open vein harvest (OVH). We hypothesize that the inferior patency reflects the initial learning curve for EVH and that improved patency can be achieved with experience. METHODS: This was a single-institution review of 113 patients with critical limb ischemia who underwent infrainguinal bypass with a continuous segment of great saphenous vein harvested endoscopically (n = 49) or through a single open incision (n = 64) from 2012 to 2017. EVH was performed by surgeons with >5 years' experience with this technique. Operative outcomes, patency, complications, and readmission rates were compared between the harvest methods. EVH data were also compared with our prior reported series of our initial experience with this technique to determine the effects of experience on outcomes. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in patient demographics, medications, operative indications, or inflow/outflow vessels between the two groups. Mean operative time was 322 minutes and median hospital length of stay was 6 days for OVH, and was 340 minutes and 5 days for EVH, which was not significant. Harvest-related wound complications were more frequent with OVH (28% vs 2%, P < .001). Primary patency at 1 and 3 years was 65% and 58% for OVH, and 79% and 71% for EVH, respectively (P = .18), assisted primary patency was 77% and 74% for OVH and 94% and 89% for EVH, respectively (P = .05), and secondary patency was 82% and 79% for OVH and 95% and 95% for EVH, respectively (P = .03). The 30-day readmission rates were similar between OVH (20%) and EVH (12%, P = .26), but 90-day readmissions were more frequent in the OVH group (34% vs 14%, P = .018). Compared with our earlier series of EVH, the current cohort had significantly improved 3-year primary (71% vs 42%, P = .012), primary assisted patency (89 vs 66%, P = .034), and secondary patency (95% vs 66%, P = .003). CONCLUSIONS: With experience, lower extremity bypass using EVH can result in improved patency compared with OVH and initial EVH use, while also resulting in fewer wound complications and readmissions, with comparable operative times and hospital length of stay. This technique should be more widely adopted by vascular surgeons as a primary method of vein harvest.
引用
- Kronick M, Liem TK, Jung E, et al. Experienced operators achieve superior patency and wound complication rates with endoscopic great saphenous vein harvest compared with open harvest in lower extremity bypasses. J Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31153700. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2019.02.043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。