监督运动、家庭运动与血管内血运重建对间歇性跛行患者体力活动影响的网状Meta分析
本研究通过网状Meta分析比较监督运动疗法(SET)、家庭运动疗法(HBET)和血管内血运重建(ER)对间歇性跛行(IC)患者体力活动的影响。纳入8项随机对照试验共656例患者,结果显示SET和HBET较对照组改善每日步数,ER无显著改善,但证据质量较低。
要点
- SET较对照组显著改善体力活动,相当于每日多走803步。
- HBET可能同样获益,相当于每日多走980步,但证据质量低。
- ER与对照组相比无统计学显著改善,仅基于一项试验。
核心结论
- SET可改善IC患者的每日体力活动水平,优于常规护理。
- HBET可能有类似获益,而ER未显示统计学显著改善。
- 涉及ER和HBET比较的证据质量低,限制确定性结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索多个数据库至2018年5月,纳入客观测量体力活动的随机对照试验。
- 共纳入8项试验,656例间歇性跛行患者,比较短期治疗效果。
- 采用贝叶斯网状Meta分析,计算标准化均数差(SMD)及95%可信区间(CI)。
主要发现
- SET vs 对照:SMD 0.41(95% CI 0.10-0.72),相当于每日多803步(计步器)。
- HBET vs 对照:SMD 0.50(95% CI 0.18-0.88),相当于每日多980步。
- ER vs 对照:SMD 0.36(95% CI -0.22至0.99),相当于每日多705步,仅一项试验提供直接证据。
- 治疗间比较均无统计学显著差异,结果经敏感性分析稳健。
临床怎么用
- 对于IC患者,可优先推荐SET以改善每日体力活动。
- HBET可作为替代选择,但需告知证据质量较低。
- ER对体力活动的改善不明确,决策时应结合其他结局。
局限性
- 涉及ER和HBET比较的证据质量低,阻碍确定性结论。
- 仅纳入8项试验,样本量有限,尤其ER直接证据仅来自一项试验。
- 短期效果,缺乏长期体力活动数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: It is unclear whether supervised exercise therapy (SET), home based exercise therapy (HBET), and endovascular revascularisation (ER) for intermittent claudication (IC) have a meaningful impact on physical activity, despite extensive research on their effect on walking performance. METHODS: Multiple databases were searched systematically up to May 2018 for randomised controlled trials with objective measurements of physical activity in patients with IC. A Bayesian network meta-analysis was performed comparing the change in physical activity between baseline and follow up between treatments (SET, HBET, ER) and control (usual care). The standardised mean difference (SMD) with 95% credible interval (CI) was calculated as a summary statistic and converted into steps per day to aid interpretation. RESULTS: Eight trials involving 656 patients with IC investigating the short-term effect of treatment on daily physical activity were included. Both SET (SMD 0.41, 95% CI 0.10-0.72: this corresponds to a difference of + 803 steps/day on a pedometer) and HBET (SMD 0.50, 95% CI 0.18-0.88: + 980 steps/day) displayed a benefit over control, based on evidence of moderate and low quality, respectively. The benefit of ER compared with control was SMD 0.36 (95% CI -0.22 to 0.99: + 705 steps/day), but only one trial supplied direct evidence, resulting in a low rating of the quality of evidence. Comparisons between treatments yielded no statistically significant differences. The results were robust to several sensitivity analyses. CONCLUSION: SET improves daily physical activity levels in patients with IC over control. HBET may have a similar benefit, while invasive treatment failed to lead to a statistically significant improvement of physical activity compared with control. However, the underlying quality of evidence for comparisons with ER and HBET is low, impeding definite conclusions.
引用
- van den Houten MML, Hageman D, Gommans LNM, et al. The Effect of Supervised Exercise, Home Based Exercise and Endovascular Revascularisation on Physical Activity in Patients With Intermittent Claudication: A Network Meta-analysis. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31235306. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2018.12.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。