开放腹主动脉瘤修复的医院手术量标准与临床结局改善无关
该研究基于2013-2014年美国Medicare≥65岁接受开放腹主动脉瘤修复(OAR)的患者,分析医院年手术量与围手术期结局的关系。结果显示仅13.1%医院年OAR量≥15例,高流量与低流量医院在并发症、再手术、抢救失败及死亡率上无显著差异。结论认为现行OAR医院手术量标准可能给患者和医院带来负担而无结局改善。
要点
- 仅13.1%医院年OAR量≥15例,53.3%医院年OAR量<5例。
- 高流量与低流量医院在并发症、再手术、抢救失败及死亡率上无显著差异。
- 将患者集中至高流量医院需每年转移超5000例患者,围手术期结局无改善。
核心结论
- 现行OAR医院年手术量≥15例的标准与围手术期结局改善无关,实施该标准可能给患者和医院带来显著负担。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2013-2014年美国Medicare≥65岁接受OAR的21191例患者,覆盖1445家医院。
- 医院年OAR量分为<5例/年、5-9例/年、10-14例/年、≥15例/年(高流量),比较2014年调整后围手术期结局。
主要发现
- 1445家医院中仅190家(13.1%)年OAR量≥15例,756家(53.3%)年OAR量<5例。
- 2014年接受OAR的患者中5395例(53.3%)在年OAR量<15例的医院接受治疗。
- 高流量与低流量医院在并发症、再手术、抢救失败率上无差异。
- 年OAR量<5例医院死亡率为5.7%,高流量医院为5.6%(P=0.817),无显著差异。
- 在低流量医院接受治疗的患者中四分之一需旅行超过60英里才能到达高流量医院。
关键数值与推荐
- Leapfrog Group现行OAR医院年手术量标准为≥15例/年。
- 医院平均年OAR量为7.8(标准差±9.3),中位数为4.5。
临床怎么用
- 血管外科智能体在评估OAR医院资质时,不应仅依据年手术量≥15例的标准判断结局优劣。
- 需结合患者转运距离与医院实际结局综合决策,避免盲目集中转诊。
局限性
- 研究基于2013-2014年数据,结论外推至当前实践需谨慎。
- 医院年OAR量基于Medicare在VQI中的覆盖比例估算,可能存在估计偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Volume-outcome relationships exist for many complex surgical procedures, prompting institutions to adopt surgical volume standards for credentialing. The current Leapfrog Group Hospital volume standard for open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair (OAR) is 15 per year. However, this is primarily based on data from the 1990s and may not be appropriate given the dramatic decline in OAR. We sought to quantify the proportion of hospitals meeting volume standards, the difference in perioperative outcomes between low-volume and high-volume hospitals, and the potential travel burden of volume credentialing on patients. METHODS: We identified Medicare beneficiaries for individuals aged ≥65 years undergoing OAR in 2013-2014. Hospital "all-payer" annual volume was estimated based on the national proportion of patients undergoing OAR covered by Medicare in the Vascular Quality Initiative. Hospital annual OAR volume was characterized as <5/year, 5-9/year, 10-14/year, and ≥15/year (high volume). Adjusted rates of postoperative morbidity, reoperation, failure to rescue, and mortality in 2014 were compared across volume cohorts. Distance between patients' home zip code and high-volume hospitals was calculated. RESULTS: A total of 21,191 OARs were performed at 1,445 hospitals between 2013 and 2014. The average hospital OAR annual volume was 7.8 (standard deviation [SD] ± 9.3) with a median of 4.5. Among the 1,445 hospitals, only 190 (13.1%) performed ≥15 OARs per year whereas 756 hospitals (53.3%) performed <5 per year. Among patients who underwent OAR in 2014, 5,395 (53.3%) received care at a hospital that performed <15 per year. There was no difference in complication, reoperation, or failure to rescue rates between high-volume and low-volume hospitals. Mortality did not significantly differ among OAR volume cohorts. Hospitals performing <5 OARs per year had a mortality rate of 5.7% compared with 5.6% at high-volume hospitals (P = 0.817). One-quarter of patients who received care at a low-volume hospital would have had to travel more than 60 miles to reach a high-volume hospital. CONCLUSIONS: By conservative estimates, only 13% of hospitals performing OAR meet current volume standards. Triaging all patients to high-volume hospitals would require shifting over 5,000 patients annually with no associated improvement in perioperative outcomes. Implementation of the current OAR hospital volume standard may significantly burden patients and hospitals without improving surgical outcomes.
引用
- Smith ME, Sutzko DC, Davis FM, et al. Volume Standards for Open Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Repair Are Not Associated With Improved Clinical Outcomes. Ann Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31207399. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2019.05.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。