重症肢体缺血远端旁路移植的移植物流量预测方程
研究纳入2011至2016年198例重症肢体缺血静脉旁路移植,用135例术后早期超声无异常的移植物建立流量预测方程,以实测流量低于预计流量减14.6定义为次优流量移植物,发现其旁路异常、狭窄、闭塞及再次手术率更高,通畅率更低。
要点
- 移植物流量决定因素为流出道、移植物质量、糖尿病和血液透析。
- 实测流量低于预计流量减14.6时旁路异常风险显著增加。
- 该方程有助于术中判断是否需附加手术以优化预后。
核心结论
- 移植物流量可由流出道、移植物质量、糖尿病和血液透析良好估计。
- 比较实测与预计流量有助于检测旁路异常并决定是否需附加术中操作。
研究设计与样本
- 2011至2016年198例重症肢体缺血静脉远端旁路移植,其中135例早期超声无异常者用于建立和验证方程。
- 采用逐步选择和多线性回归分析移植物流量决定因素并建立预测方程,另以ROC曲线确定14.6的 cutoff 值。
主要发现
- 次优流量移植物旁路异常率64.0% vs 12.2%(P < .0001)。
- 次优流量移植物移植物中间狭窄率10.7% vs 1.6%(P = .0071)。
- 次优流量移植物移植物严重狭窄率28.0% vs 3.2%(P < .0001)。
- 次优流量移植物早期移植物闭塞率17.3% vs 4.3%(P = .0037)。
- 次优流量移植物术后2年内再次手术率50.7% vs 34.2%(P = .026),原发和继发通畅率均显著更低(P < .0001和P = .0005)。
关键数值与推荐
- 预测方程:GF(ml/min)=(32.9×run-off)+(9.9×GQ)-(13.0×DM)-(35.1×HD)+12.1(R2 = 0.71)。
- run-off和GQ赋值:3(good)、2(fair)、1(poor);DM和HD赋值:1(yes)、0(no)。
- 最优流量移植物定义为mGF > eGF - 14.6,次优流量移植物定义为mGF < eGF - 14.6。
临床怎么用
- 术中可依据方程计算预计流量,与实测流量比较以识别次优流量移植物。
- 对次优流量移植物可考虑附加术中操作以降低旁路异常和再次手术风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Graft flow (GF) seems to be an important prognostic predictor in distal bypass for critical limb ischemia, but previous studies have failed to clarify the association between GF and the graft prognosis. GF differs significantly among grafts, and each graft seems to have an optimal GF depending on various factors. We hypothesized that comparison between the measured GF (mGF) and optimal estimated GF (eGF) would be important in predicting graft prognosis. Herein, we aimed to develop a GF predictive equation by assessing GF determinants and to validate the equation against a clinical dataset. METHODS: A total of 198 distal bypasses with vein grafts for critical limb ischemia from 2011 to 2016 were enrolled. Of these grafts, 135 normal grafts without any abnormalities on early postoperative ultrasound examination were used to develop and validate the equation. Various anatomic and patient-related factors were analyzed to detect GF determinants with stepwise selection, and the GF predictive equation was developed with multiple linear regression analysis. After developing the equation, all 198 grafts were categorized into two groups according to the equation developed based on data from the 135 normal grafts as follows: optimal flow grafts (OFGs), in which mGF > eGF - 14.6, and suboptimal flow grafts (SFGs), in which mGF < eGF - 14.6. The cutoff value of 14.6 was determined using receiver operating characteristic curves to detect graft abnormalities. By comparing OFGs and SFGs, the efficacy of the equation in predicting bypass abnormalities and graft prognosis was assessed. RESULTS: The GF determinants were runoff, hemodialysis (HD), diabetes mellitus (DM), and graft quality (GQ). The predictive equation was estimated as follows: GF(ml/min)=(32.9×run-off)+(9.9×GQ)-(13.0×DM)-(35.1×HD)+12.1 (R2 = 0.71, coefficient: runoff and GQ, 3 [good], 2 [fair], 1 [poor]; DM and HD, 1 [yes], 0 [no]). In the efficacy assessment of the equation, SFGs showed a significantly higher rate of bypass abnormalities (64.0% vs 12.2%; P < .0001), graft intermediate stenosis (10.7% vs 1.6%; P = .0071), graft critical stenosis (28.0% vs 3.2%; P < .0001), and early graft occlusion (17.3% vs 4.3%; P = .0037) than OFGs and were associated with a higher rate of revision surgery within 2 years after surgery (50.7% vs 34.2%; P = .026). SFGs also showed significantly lower primary patency rates (P < .0001) and secondary patency rates (P = .0005). CONCLUSIONS: GF was well-estimated with runoff, GQ, and the presence of DM and HD. A comparison between mGF and eGF, calculated with the equation, will help to detect bypass abnormalities and determine the necessity of additional intraoperative procedures and, thus, achieve optimal outcomes.
引用
- Miyake K, Kikuchi S, Okuda H, et al. Graft flow predictive equation in distal bypass grafting for critical limb ischemia. J Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 31078341. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2018.12.057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。