联合颈动脉内膜剥脱与冠脉搭桥的区域差异与结局
基于VQI 2003-2017年1495例联合手术(CCAB)数据,分析美国四区域使用和结局差异。CCAB占CEA的1.8%,区域比例0.7%-2.5%显著不同,但围术期卒中、死亡、心梗无区域差异。仅少数患者符合SVS指南指征。
要点
- CCAB占VQI中CEA的1.8%,区域使用比例差异显著(0.7%-2.5%)。
- 围术期卒中3.6%、死亡3.0%、复合终点6.8%,无区域差异。
- 无症状单侧重度狭窄是最常见指征(37%),多数不符合SVS指南。
核心结论
- CCAB使用存在显著区域差异,但围术期结局相似;多数患者不符合SVS指南指征。
- 无症状单侧重度狭窄患者卒中率低于症状性及双侧重度狭窄患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,基于VQI 2003-2017年1495例CCAB手术,按美国人口普查局四区域分层。
- CCAB占VQI所有CEA的1.8%;患者70%男性,92%白人。
主要发现
- 区域CCAB占CEA比例从0.7%(西部)到2.5%(中西部),P < .001。
- 补片使用78%(西部)至93%(中西部),转流29%(西部)至71%(中西部),EEG监测13%(西部)至52%(东北部),均P < .001。
- 总体围术期卒中3.6%、死亡3.0%、SDM 6.8%;死亡率区域间1.5%(中西部)至4.2%(东北部),P = .05,Bonferroni校正后显著。
- 卒中区域间2.8%(东北部)至4.4%(中西部),P = .52;心梗0.6%(中西部)至1.8%(西部),P = .62。
- 无症状单侧重度狭窄(UNI)占37%(n=552),症状性(SYMP)占15%(n=218),双侧重度(BIL)占18%(n=267)。
关键数值与推荐
- SVS指南考虑CCAB的指征包括症状性颈动脉狭窄和≥70%无症状双侧颈动脉疾病。
- 本队列中仅15%为症状性狭窄,18%为双侧重度狭窄,37%为无症状单侧重度狭窄。
临床怎么用
- CCAB在美国各区域实施效果良好,围术期结局相似。
- 多数CCAB患者不符合SVS指南指征,需进一步评估患者选择。
局限性
- 回顾性设计,仅纳入VQI中心,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 西部样本量仅占4%,区域比较效能有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: In treating concomitant carotid and coronary disease, some recommend staged carotid endarterectomy (CEA) and coronary artery bypass grafting, whereas others favor the combined approach (CCAB). Pressure to reduce surgical variation and to improve quality is real, yet little is known about how geographic practice differences affect outcomes. Using the Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI), this study evaluated regional variation in use and outcomes of CCAB. METHODS: All CCAB procedures in the VQI from 2003 to 2017 were reviewed and stratified into four regions, as defined by the United States Census Bureau. Primary outcomes included perioperative stroke, death, myocardial infarction (MI), and these as composite (SDM). A χ2 analysis was performed. RESULTS: There were 1495 CCAB procedures identified, representing 1.8% of the VQI CEAs. Regions included the following: Midwest (MW), 32%; Northeast (NE), 39%; South (S), 25%; and West (W), 4%. Most were male (70%) and white (92%). There was significant regional variation in proportional volume of CCABs to all CEAs (0.7% [W] to 2.5% [MW]; P < .001). Regional variation in patch use (78% [W] to 93% [MW]; P < .001), shunting (29% [W] to 71% [MW]; P < .001), and electroencephalography monitoring (13% [W] to 52% [NE]; P < .001) was also significant. Overall perioperative stroke was 3.6%; death, 3.0%; and SDM, 6.8%. No regional difference was seen in outcomes of mortality (1.5% [MW] to 4.2% [NE]; P = .05), stroke (2.8% [NE] to 4.4% [MW]; P = .52), and MI (0.6% [MW] to 1.8% [W]; P = .62). When the Bonferroni correction was used, there remained no difference in stroke, MI, or SDM across regions, but mortality became significant. Using the Society for Vascular Surgery guidelines for consideration of CCAB, the minority of patients fell within the symptomatic carotid stenosis (SYMP, 15%; n = 218) or severe (≥70%) asymptomatic bilateral carotid disease (BIL, 18%; n = 267) categories. The most common indication was asymptomatic unilateral severe carotid stenosis (UNI, 37%; n = 552). There were no differences in regional outcomes stratified by indication (SYMP, BIL, UNI). Overall, when SYMP and BIL were compared with UNI, UNI had lower rates of stroke (2.4% vs 4.9%; P = .03) but similar MI (0.7% vs 1.2%; P = .40) and mortality (2.2% vs 2.5%; P = .75). CONCLUSIONS: Significant variation exists across VQI centers in the use of CCAB. Despite differences in volume and practices, regional perioperative outcomes are similar. UNI is the most commonly used indication and has lower stroke rates relative to SYMP and BIL. CCAB is performed well across the United States, but most patients fall outside of Society for Vascular Surgery guidelines.
引用
- Wang LJ, Ergul EA, Mohebali J, et al. Regional variation in use and outcomes of combined carotid endarterectomy and coronary artery bypass. J Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 30922761. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2019.02.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。