低危患者复杂主髂动脉病变开放手术与腔内覆膜支架治疗的比较
单中心回顾性研究比较低危患者TASC C/D级主髂动脉病变开放手术与自膨式覆膜支架腔内治疗的疗效。共114例患者(开放组56例,腔内组58例)纳入分析。结果显示两组5年一期通畅率、保肢率及免于相关再干预率相似,腔内组住院时间更短;女性是腔内组通畅率的独立负性预测因子。
要点
- 低危年轻患者复杂主髂动脉病变,腔内覆膜支架治疗与开放手术远期通畅率相当。
- 腔内治疗可显著缩短住院和ICU停留时间。
- 女性患者腔内治疗后通畅率较差,开放手术仍是参考标准。
核心结论
- 在低危和年轻患者中,使用覆膜支架的腔内修复治疗严重主髂动脉阻塞性病变可视为与开放手术同样有效。
- 腔内修复允许更短的住院时间,并在长期保持相似的通畅率。
- 然而,对于女性患者,开放手术仍是治疗的参考标准。
研究设计与样本
- 排除合并主动脉瘤或病变累及整个肾下主动脉的患者。
- 低手术风险定义为血管外科学会合并症评分≤0.7且年龄<75岁。
- 年轻患者定义为年龄≤60岁。
- 共114例患者(开放手术组n=56,腔内修复组n=58),其中70例(63%)为双侧髂动脉病变,共182条肢体血运重建(开放组n=96,腔内组n=86)。
主要发现
- 髂动脉病变按肢体分类为TASC C级71条(39%)或D级111条(61%)。
- 平均年龄61.4±8.4岁,平均血管外科学会合并症评分0.51±0.39,两组间无统计学显著差异(0.48±0.29 vs 0.56±0.47;P=.357)。
- 30天时,腔内组住院时间(8.5±6.2 vs 2.6±0.8天;P<.001)和ICU停留时间(0.1±0.6 vs 0.9±0.5天;P<.001)均短于开放组。
- 累计内科并发症率(开放组7%;腔内组5%;P=.714)和外科并发症率(开放组10%;腔内组8%;P=.759)相似。
- 5年时,两组一期通畅率相似(开放组87.3%;腔内组81.4%;P=.317),在年轻患者亚组中亦得到证实(开放组84.7%;腔内组75.0%;P=.272)。
临床怎么用
- 对于低危、年轻(≤60岁)的复杂主髂动脉病变患者,可考虑腔内覆膜支架治疗作为开放手术的替代方案。
- 腔内治疗可缩短住院和ICU停留时间,且远期通畅率与开放手术相当。
- 女性患者选择腔内治疗时需谨慎,开放手术仍是参考标准。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性研究设计。
- 样本量有限(114例患者,182条肢体)。
- 排除合并主动脉瘤或病变累及整个肾下主动脉的患者,结论可能不适用于这些人群。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the present study was to compare open surgical repair (OSR) versus endovascular repair (ER) using self-expanding covered stents for complex TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus II (TASC) class C or D aortoiliac lesions in low-risk patients, with a specific subanalysis for younger patients. METHODS: A single-center retrospective review of TASC C/D lesions treated from January 2008 to December 2017 was conducted. Patients with associated aortic aneurysm or lesions involving the entire infrarenal aorta were excluded. Thirty-day outcomes, long-term patency, limb salvage, and freedom from related reinterventions were compared between OSR and ER. "Low surgical risk" was defined as a Society for Vascular Surgery comorbidity score of ≤0.7 and age <75 years. Patients were considered "young" if aged ≤60 years. The follow-up results were analyzed using Kaplan-Meier curves. Major clinical and anatomic characteristics were evaluated for their association with patency using Cox proportional hazards. RESULTS: Overall, 114 patients (OSR, n = 56; ER, n = 58) were treated, of whom, 70 patients (63%) had bilateral iliac disease involvement, for a total of 182 limbs revascularized (OSR, n = 96; ER, n = 86). Iliac lesions were classified by limb as TASC C (n = 71; 39%) or D (n = 111; 61%). Their mean age was 61.4 ± 8.4 years, and the mean Society for Vascular Surgery comorbidity score was 0.51 ± 0.39, without statistically significant differences between the OSR and ER groups (0.48 ± 0.29 vs 0.56 ± 0.47; P = .357). At 30 days, the ER group had had a shorter length of hospitalization (8.5 ± 6.2 vs 2.6 ± 0.8 days; P < .001) and intensive care unit stay (0.1 ± 0.6 vs 0.9 ± 0.5 day; P < .001) than the OSR group. The cumulative medical (OSR, 7%; ER, 5%; P = .714) and surgical (OSR, 10%; ER, 8%; P = .759) complication rates were similar. At 5 years, the primary patency rate was similar between the two groups (OSR, 87.3%; ER, 81.4%; P = .317). This result was confirmed in the subgroup of "young" patients (OSR, 84.7; ER, 75.0; P = .272). The limb salvage (OSR, 98.9%; ER, 98.4%; P = .920) and freedom from related reintervention (OSR, 74.4%; ER, 73.0%; P = .703) rates were similar. This trend was also confirmed in the "young" patients for both limb salvage (OSR, 98.5%; ER, 97.6%; P = .896) and freedom from related reintervention (OSR, 76.9%; ER, 63.6%; P = .223). Multivariate analysis indicated that the only independent negative predictor of patency was female gender in the ER group (hazard ratio, 2.89; 95% confidence interval, 1.45-26.60; P = .024). CONCLUSIONS: In the case of severe aortoiliac obstructive lesions in low-risk and young patients, ER using a covered stent can be considered as valid as OSR. In addition, it allows for shorter hospitalization and maintains a similar patency rate in the long term. However, for female patients, OSR remains the reference standard of treatment.
引用
- Antonello M, Squizzato F, Bassini S, et al. Open repair versus endovascular treatment of complex aortoiliac lesions in low risk patients. J Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 30850298. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2018.12.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。