随机对照试验为何不总能反映真实世界
该综述回顾血管外科文献,比较随机对照试验(RCT)与观察性或人群研究在颈动脉狭窄和破裂腹主动脉瘤治疗中的结果。发现RCT与真实世界注册研究存在显著差异,提示RCT有时不能反映临床现实,需谨慎解读和应用。
要点
- 颈动脉狭窄:观察性研究报告颈动脉支架置入术结局劣于内膜剥脱术,而RCT报告两者相似。
- 破裂腹主动脉瘤:人群研究报告腔内修复术优于开放手术,而RCT报告两者相似。
- RCT结果需结合完整证据和良好临床判断谨慎解读。
核心结论
- 有证据表明RCT有时不反映临床现实,可能误导读者。
- 每个RCT都需结合完整可用证据和良好临床判断谨慎解读和应用。
研究设计与样本
- 文献综述,比较血管外科领域RCT与观察性或人群研究的结果。
- 聚焦两个主题:颈动脉狭窄的血栓内膜剥脱术与支架置入术,以及破裂腹主动脉瘤的开放手术与腔内修复术。
主要发现
- 两个主题中RCT结果与真实世界注册和观察性研究存在显著差异。
- 颈动脉狭窄:观察性研究报告支架置入术后结局劣于内膜剥脱术。
- 破裂腹主动脉瘤:人群研究报告腔内修复术结果优于开放手术。
- 两个主题的RCT均报告两种手术结果相似。
临床怎么用
- 解读RCT时需结合观察性研究和真实世界证据,避免仅依据RCT做出治疗决策。
- 应用RCT结果时应结合完整可用证据和良好临床判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) constitute level I evidence and are used as the backbone of guidelines and recommendations for treatment. Although RCTs are theoretically the studies of choice for the assessment of the effectiveness of health care interventions, these trials (and their interpretation) may sometimes result in erroneous conclusions, erroneous therapeutic decisions, and incorrect recommendations. We aimed to check the applicability of the results of RCTs to everyday practice. METHODS: We reviewed the literature for studies comparing the results of RCTs with observational or population-based studies in the field of vascular surgery, focusing on two specific topics: the results of carotid artery stenting vs carotid endarterectomy for the management of carotid artery stenosis; and the results of open surgical repair vs endovascular aneurysm repair for the management of ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms. RESULTS: We found considerable discrepancy in the results of RCTs with real-life registries and observational studies in both topics. In the management of carotid artery stenosis, observational studies reported worse outcomes after carotid artery stenting compared with carotid endarterectomy. Regarding ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms, population-based studies reported better results for endovascular aneurysm repair compared with open repair. In contrast, RCTs in both topics reported similar results for the two procedures. CONCLUSIONS: There is evidence that RCTs sometimes do not reflect clinical reality and are therefore potentially misleading to the reader. Every RCT has to be interpreted and applied carefully using complete available evidence and good clinical judgment.
引用
- Paraskevas KI, de Borst GJ, Veith FJ, et al. Why randomized controlled trials do not always reflect reality. J Vasc Surg. 2019. PMID: 30878256. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2019.01.052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。