教育干预对医学生踝臂指数操作表现的影响及六个月保真度评估
这项随机对照试验将30名医学生随机分为单纯教学组(10人)与教学联合体验学习组(20人),用Wyatt评分评估踝臂指数(ABI)操作熟练度。最终评估时,Wyatt评分合格人数为单纯教学组1/10、联合组15/20;ABI操作合格人数为单纯教学组0/10、联合组16/20。结论认为Wyatt评分对教育干预敏感,无体验学习时未见提高。
要点
- 医学生30人随机分组,最终评估Wyatt评分合格为单纯教学组1/10、联合体验学习组15/20。
- ABI操作合格为单纯教学组0/10、联合体验学习组16/20。
- 6个月时,通过最终评估的12名学生中4人Wyatt评分与ABI测量均通过。
核心结论
- 研究表明Wyatt评分对教育干预敏感,在无体验学习的情况下未发现提高。
- Wyatt评分可用于评估教育干预后医学生的ABI测量表现。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,在法国雷恩大学医院血管医学科开展,经本机构伦理审查委员会批准(编号16.150)。
- 30名医学生先接受包括ABI指南讲解和视频演示的教学学习,随后随机分为无体验学习组和体验学习组。
- 教学学习后进行初始评估,干预结束后进行最终评估;学生在健康志愿者身上操作ABI正确且与血管医学教授ABI测量差值≤0.15时视为熟练。
主要发现
- 初始评估时无学生达到熟练。
- 最终评估时,Wyatt评分合格人数为单纯教学组1/10 vs 教学联合体验学习组15/20。
- 最终评估时,ABI操作合格人数为单纯教学组0/10 vs 教学联合体验学习组16/20。
- 6个月时,通过最终评估的12名学生中4人Wyatt评分和ABI测量均通过。
关键数值与推荐
- 熟练标准为:正确回答Wyatt评分,且教授与学生的ABI测量差值≤0.15。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The resting ankle-brachial index (ABI) is a clinical test to diagnose peripheral artery disease. The Wyatt's score has been proposed to assess the students' performance on ABI measurement on a healthy volunteer (HV). No study has shown that this score is sensitive to different teaching methods. In this randomized controlled trial, we wanted to determine whether didactic learning alone or didactic learning combined with experiential learning improves proficiency in the ABI procedure assessed by the Wyatt's score. METHODS: Medical students (n = 30) received a didactic learning, including (1) a presentation of the ABI guidelines and (2) a video demonstration. Each student was then randomized into 2 groups ("the no experiential learning group" and "the experiential learning group"). An initial evaluation was performed after the didactic learning and then the final evaluation at the end of the intervention. A student was considered to be proficient when he performed a correct ABI procedure on an HV. The correct procedure corresponds to the following: (1) correctly answered Wyatt's score and (2) a difference in the ABI measurement between a professor in vascular medicine and a student was ≤0.15. RESULTS: No student was proficient at the initial evaluation. At the final evaluation, there was a significant difference between the number of proficient students for the Wyatt's score depending on their learning group [didactic alone (1/10) or didactic + experiential training (15/20)] and also for the ABI procedure [didactic alone (0/10) or didactic + experiential training (16/20)]. At 6 months, among the 12 students who passed the final evaluation, 4 students passed both the Wyatt's score and the ABI measurement. CONCLUSIONS: Our study demonstrates that the Wyatt's score was sensitive to an educational intervention and no improvement was found in the case of "no experiential learning." The Wyatt's score could be used to evaluate the student on ABI measurement after an educational intervention. TRIAL REGISTRATION: A randomized controlled trial was conducted in the Vascular Medicine Department of Rennes University Hospital (France). This was approved by the ethics review board of our institution (no. 16.150).
引用
- Omarjee L, Donnou C, Chaudru S, et al. Impact of an Educational Intervention on Ankle-Brachial Index Performance Among Medical Students and Fidelity Assessment at Six Months. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 30278260. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2018.07.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。