电子健康外周动脉疾病社区论坛的范围、主题与医学准确性
该研究对开放获取的外周动脉疾病(PAD)电子健康社区论坛(MedHelp)的帖子进行定性分析,共收集103条帖子(40条原创帖和63条回复)。原创帖最常见主题为PAD诊断(25%)和治疗(23%);回复帖主题包括医疗建议(40.5%)和个人经历(32.8%);所有医疗建议中15.1%与临床治疗指南不一致。
要点
- 原创帖最常见主题为PAD诊断(25%)和治疗(23%)。
- 回复帖中医疗建议占40.5%,其中15.1%与临床治疗指南不一致。
- 与医疗提供者体验相关的帖子中,10/18(55.6%)显示负面态度。
核心结论
- 电子健康社区是了解PAD患者经历、治疗偏好、重要问题和所用术语的丰富信息来源,可用于理解未满足的患者需求、开发教育资源并改善沟通。
研究设计与样本
- 对开放获取、无需参与者表明身份、位于美国的在线PAD医疗支持社区论坛(MedHelp)的帖子进行定性分析。
- 共收集并分析103条帖子,包括40条原创帖和63条回复;原创帖和相关回复均被分析主题内容、常用术语和参与者自报特征。
- 对疾病相关评论和建议与当代PAD治疗指南的一致性进行评估。
主要发现
- 原创帖中45%由自报为PAD患者的参与者撰写,回复帖中19%由自报为PAD患者的参与者撰写。
- 原创帖最常见主题包括PAD诊断(及鉴别诊断)(25%)、治疗(23%)、流行病学和病理生理学(21%)、疾病症状及对日常生活活动的影响(15%)和医疗保健提供者建议(13%)。
- 回复帖主题包括医疗建议(40.5%)、个人PAD经历(32.8%)和社会支持(12.6%)。
- 与医疗保健提供者体验相关的18条帖子中,10条(55.6%)显示负面态度。
- 所有医疗建议中15.1%与临床治疗指南不一致。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The availability of electronic health (eHealth) information and disease-related community forums has grown over the last decade. Although patients and families frequently use these resources, their content has not been characterized in terms users, content, or reliability of information. eHealth communities therefore represent a potentially valuable but uncharted source of information about key patient issues, communication terminology, and unmet needs. We hypothesized that eHealth forums would contain terminology, themes, and advice inconsistent with resources from medical providers and references. To test this hypothesis, we performed a qualitative analysis of posts and responses from an open-access peripheral artery disease (PAD) eHealth community forum to characterize the discussion, participants, and the information being exchanged. METHODS: Posts were collected from an online PAD Medical Support Community forum (MedHelp), which is open access, does not require participants to identify themselves, and is based in the United States. Posts were selected from threads in which the main topic was PAD, including diagnosis, symptoms, and treatment. Original posts and related responses were analyzed for thematic content, common vernacular, and self-reported characteristics of the participants using a qualitative analysis software program. Disease-specific comments and advice were evaluated for congruence with contemporary PAD treatment guidelines. RESULTS: A total of 103 posts were collected and analyzed, including 40 original posts and 63 responses. Forty-five percent of the original posts and 19% of the responses were authored by participants who self-identified as patients with PAD. The remaining posts were authored by people with undeclared relationships to patients with PAD, followed by children, spouses, and other relatives. The most common themes among original posts included PAD diagnosis (and differential) (25%), treatment (23%), epidemiology and pathophysiology (21%), disease symptoms and impacts on activities of daily living (15%), and health-care provider recommendations (13%). Themes of responses included medical advice (40.5%), personal experiences with PAD (32.8%), and social support (12.6%). Negative attitudes were identified in 10 of 18 (55.6%) posts related to experiences with health-care providers. Of all medical advice, 15.1% was inconsistent with clinical treatment guidelines. CONCLUSION: eHealth communities are a rich source of information related to the experiences of patients with PAD, their treatment preferences, questions they consider important, and terminology that they use. This information can be used to understand unmet patient needs, develop educational resources, and improve communication.
引用
- Castaneda P, Sales A, Osborne NH, et al. Scope, Themes, and Medical Accuracy of eHealth Peripheral Artery Disease Community Forums. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 30267913. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2018.09.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。