补救失败——深入分析死亡率对医院间比较无附加价值,但有助于腹主动脉瘤手术的团队质量评估:荷兰研究
该研究分析2013至2015年荷兰外科动脉瘤审计(DSAA)中9258例腹主动脉瘤手术患者,比较补救失败(FTR)与死亡率用于医院间比较的价值,并探讨医院容量及相关因素。结果显示FTR的医院间变异大于死亡率,但FTR识别出的最佳表现医院与死亡率一致,故对腹主动脉瘤手术质量测量的附加价值有限;FTR可用于内部质量改进。
要点
- FTR的医院间变异大于死亡率,但FTR识别的最佳表现医院与死亡率一致,附加价值有限。
- 医院容量与FTR无关,但在急性腹主动脉瘤患者中与更低调整后主要并发症率和死亡率相关。
- FTR可用于内部质量改进,结合漏斗图及等死亡率线图展示主要并发症。
核心结论
- FTR的医院间变异大于死亡率,但FTR识别出的最佳表现医院与死亡率相同,故对腹主动脉瘤手术质量测量的附加价值有限,可用于内部质量改进。
研究设计与样本
- 分析2013至2015年前瞻性登记于荷兰外科动脉瘤审计(DSAA)的腹主动脉瘤手术患者,共9258例,来自61家医院。
主要发现
- 共9258例患者,其中择期腹主动脉瘤7149例(77.2%),急性腹主动脉瘤2109例(22.8%)。
- 2785例(30.1%)发生并发症(未调整的医院间范围5-65%),其中2161例(77.6%)为主要并发症,624例(28.4%)为次要并发症。
- 总体死亡率为6.6%(调整后医院间范围0-16%),FTR为28.4%(n=613)(调整后医院间范围0-60%)。
- 格拉斯哥昏迷评分、年龄、脉搏、肌酐、心电图和手术时机与FTR独立相关;医院容量与FTR无关。
- 在急性腹主动脉瘤患者中,医院容量与更低的调整后主要并发症率(OR 0.62,95%CI 0.49-0.78)和死亡率(OR 0.64,95%CI 0.48-0.87)显著相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为FTR对腹主动脉瘤手术的医院间质量比较附加价值有限。
- 作者认为FTR可用于内部质量改进,结合漏斗图和等死亡率线图展示主要并发症。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Failure to rescue (FTR) is a composite quality indicator, defined as the proportion of deceased patients following major complications. The aims of this study were to compare FTR with mortality for hospital comparisons in abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) surgery in The Netherlands and investigate hospital volume and associated factors. METHODS: Patients prospectively registered between 2013 and 2015 in the Dutch Surgical Aneurysm Audit (DSAA) were analysed. FTR was analysed for AAA patients and subgroups elective (EAAA) and acute (AAAA; symptomatic or ruptured) aneurysms. Variables and hospital volume were analysed by uni- and multivariable regression analysis. Adjusted hospital comparisons for mortality, major complications, and FTR were presented in funnel plots. Isomortality lines were constructed when presenting FTR and major complication rates. RESULTS: A total of 9258 patients were analysed in 61 hospitals: 7149 EAAA patients (77.2%) and 2109 AAAA patients (22.8%). There were 2785 (30.1%) patients with complications (unadjusted range 5-65% per hospital): 2161 (77.6%) with major and 624 (28.4%) patients with minor complications. Overall mortality was 6.6% (adjusted range 0-16% per hospital) and FTR was 28.4% (n = 613) (adjusted range 0-60% per hospital). Glasgow Coma Scale, age, pulse, creatinine, electrocardiography, and operative setting were independently associated with FTR. Hospital volume was not associated with FTR. In AAAA patients hospital volume was significantly associated with a lower adjusted major complication and mortality rate (OR 0.62, 95% CI 0.49-0.78; and 0.64, 95% CI 0.48-0.87). Four hospitals had a significant lower adjusted FTR with different major complication rates on different isomortality lines. CONCLUSIONS: There was more variation in FTR than in mortality between hospitals. FTR identified the same best performing hospitals as for mortality and therefore was of limited additional value in measuring quality of care for AAA surgery. FTR can be used for internal quality improvement with major complications in funnel plots and diagrams with isomortality lines.
引用
- Lijftogt N, Karthaus EG, Vahl A, et al. Failure to Rescue - a Closer Look at Mortality Rates Has No Added Value for Hospital Comparisons but Is Useful for Team Quality Assessment in Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Surgery in The Netherlands. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 30145163. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2018.06.062
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。