文献速递静脉血栓栓塞

下腔静脉滤器相关医疗过失诉讼的结果及相关因素分析

Outcomes and associated factors in malpractice litigation involving inferior vena cava filters.
PubMed 文献 · J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord · 2018-01-01

该研究检索1967至2016年美国法律数据库,回顾分析29例下腔静脉滤器相关医疗过失诉讼案件,发现私人执业医师最常被诉(37.9%),最常见指控为有指征时未置入滤器(48.3%),患者死亡占41.4%,已有判决中92.9%支持被告。

要点

  • 私人执业医师最常被诉(11/29,37.9%),血管外科是最常被列名的专科(8/29)。
  • 最常见指控为有指征时未置入滤器(14/29,48.3%),其次为术中疏忽和未及时取出装置(各5/29,17.2%)。
  • 患者死亡占41.4%(12/29),已有判决中92.9%(13/14)支持被告。

核心结论

  • 下腔静脉滤器相关医疗过失诉讼中,判决总体支持被告,私人执业医师最常被诉,最常见起诉原因为未置入滤器、术中并发症和未取出滤器。
  • 作者认为更深入认识医疗过失诉讼相关问题可为临床实践提供信息并改善患者照护与安全。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性法律案件审查,检索LexisNexis和Westlaw数据库1967至2016年美国所有已发表的下腔静脉滤器置入相关法律案件。
  • 关键词包括「IVC」「inferior vena cava」「filter」「malpractice」,排除社会保障残疾索赔、产品责任诉讼和医院雇佣合同纠纷。
  • 310条搜索结果进入初筛,应用排除标准后29例医疗过失案件纳入最终分析,多数被排除案件为保险纠纷和税收案件。

主要发现

  • 私人执业医师最常被诉(11/29,37.9%),学术医院占24.1%(7/29),监狱占20.7%(6/29),社区医院占17.2%(5/29)。
  • 最常被列名的专科为血管外科(8/29),介入放射科医师仅被列名两次。
  • 滤器置入最常见指征为高凝状态(8/29,29.6%)、复发性肺栓塞(6/29,22.2%)和创伤(5/29,18.5%)。
  • 最常见指控为有指征时未置入滤器(14/29,48.3%)、术中疏忽(5/29,17.2%)和未及时取出装置(5/29,17.2%)。
  • 常见并发症包括未能预防肺栓塞发生(14/29,48.3%)、装置移位(4/29,13.8%)和器官或血管穿孔(3/29,10.3%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 患者死亡占全部案件的41.4%(12/29)。
  • 死亡患者中最常见滤器置入指征为创伤(4/12,33.3%)和深静脉血栓(3/12,25.0%),最常见并发症为未能预防后续肺栓塞(9/12,75.0%)。
  • 已有判决支持被告(13/14,92.9%)。
  • 被告胜诉案件中,最常见滤器置入指征为创伤(4/13,30.8%)和深静脉血栓(3/13,23.1%),最常见并发症为未能预防肺栓塞(9/14,64.3%)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为更深入认识医疗过失诉讼相关问题可为临床实践提供信息并改善患者照护与安全。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Placement of inferior vena cava (IVC) filters is a controversial focus of medical malpractice. Clinicians currently have little information to guide them regarding key issues and outcomes in litigation. In this retrospective legal case review, we analyzed the factors associated with malpractice actions involving IVC filters. METHODS: The legal databases LexisNexis and Westlaw were searched from 1967 to 2016 for all published legal cases in the United States involving placement of IVC filters. Keywords included "IVC," "inferior vena cava," "filter," and "malpractice." Social Security Disability claims, product liability actions, and hospital employment contract disputes were excluded. RESULTS: There were 310 search results eligible for initial review. After application of exclusion criteria, 29 cases involving medical malpractice were included in final analysis. The majority of excluded cases were insurance disputes and tax revenue cases. Overall, private practitioners were most often sued (11/29 [37.9%]), whereas 24.1% of defendants were academic hospitals (7/29), 20.7% were prisons (6/29), and 17.2% were community hospitals (5/29). The most common specialty named was vascular surgery (8/29), whereas interventional radiologists were named only twice. The most common indications for IVC filter placement were hypercoagulable state (8/29 [29.6%]), recurrent pulmonary embolism (PE; 6/29 [22.2%]), and trauma (5/29 [18.5%]). The most common underlying allegations involved failure to insert IVC filter when indicated (14/29 [48.3%]), intraprocedural negligence (5/29 [17.2%]), and failure to timely remove device (5/29 [17.2%]). Common complications included failure to prevent occurrence of PE (14/29 [48.3%]), device migration (4/29 [13.8%]), and perforation of organs or vasculature (3/29 [10.3%]). Death of the patient occurred in 41.4% of total cases (12/29). In cases in which the patient died, the most common indications for filter placement were trauma (4/12 [33.3%]) and deep venous thrombosis (3/12 [25.0%]), and the most common complication in those patients who died was the failure to prevent a subsequent PE (9/12 [75.0%]). Available verdicts favored defendants (13/14 [92.9%]). In cases with defense verdicts, the most common indications for filter placement similarly were trauma (4/13 [30.8%]) and deep venous thrombosis (3/13 [23.1%)], and the most common complication was failure to prevent PE (9/14 [64.3%]). CONCLUSIONS: Analysis of malpractice cases involving IVC filters revealed key factors associated with litigation. Overall, verdicts favored defendants. Private practitioners were most commonly sued, and the most common reasons for bringing suit were failure to insert filter, intraprocedural complications, and failure to remove filter. Deeper awareness of issues related to malpractice litigation can inform clinical practice and improve patient care and safety.

来源:J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Oh K, Hingorani A. Outcomes and associated factors in malpractice litigation involving inferior vena cava filters. J Vasc Surg Venous Lymphat Disord. 2018. PMID: 29909860. doi:10.1016/j.jvsv.2018.01.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。