文献速递血液透析通路内脏/肾动脉与血管畸形

评估搏动性新鲜冷冻人体尸体循环模型用于血管腔内训练的建构效度

Evaluating the Construct Validity of a Pulsatile Fresh Frozen Human Cadaver Circulation Model for Endovascular Training.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2018-05-19

本研究评估搏动性新鲜冷冻人体尸体模型(PHCM)的建构效度,纳入23名不同血管腔内经验参与者(12名新手、4名中级、7名专家),要求在10分钟内于PHCM上完成左肾动脉插管。结果显示专家和中级参与者均完成操作,而新手仅1人完成(P < 0.0005);新手在任务特异性清单评分、全局评分和总体操作评分上均显著低于中级和专家,中级与专家间无显著差异。结论认为PHCM具有建构效度,需进一步工作确定其教育影响。

要点

  • 专家和中级参与者全部在10分钟内完成左肾动脉插管,新手仅1/12完成(P < 0.0005)。
  • 新手在任务特异性清单评分、全局评分和总体操作评分上均显著低于中级和专家。
  • 中级与专家之间在任务特异性清单评分、全局评分和总体操作评分上无显著差异。

核心结论

  • PHCM展示出建构效度,需进一步工作确定其在血管腔内训练中的教育影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 招募23名不同血管腔内经验参与者(12名新手、4名中级、7名专家),每人在考试条件下尝试10分钟内于PHCM上完成左肾动脉插管。
  • 操作过程录像,由2名对操作者身份不知情的独立血管腔内专家使用经验证的评分工具评分。
  • 每位参与者获得任务特异性清单评分(TSC)、全局评分(GRS)和总体操作评分(OPS),考官另对是否愿意在手术室监督该参与者评为「不通过」「边缘」或「通过」。

主要发现

  • 所有专家和中级参与者均在规定的10分钟内完成指标操作,而12名新手参与者中仅1人完成(P < 0.0005)。
  • 血管腔内新手在TSC、GRS和OPS上均显著低于中级参与者和血管腔内专家。
  • 中级参与者与血管腔内专家之间在TSC、GRS或OPS上无显著差异。
  • 参与者被评为「不通过」「边缘」或「通过」时,组间差异显著(P = 0.001)。
  • 所有中级和专家参与者均获「通过」;12名新手参与者中2名获「通过」、6名获「边缘」、4名「不通过」。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 需进一步工作确定PHCM在血管腔内训练中的教育影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: We recently described a pulsatile fresh frozen human cadaver model (PHCM) for training endovascular practitioners. This present study aims to assess the construct validity of PHCM; its ability to differentiate between participants of varying expertise. METHODS: Twenty-three participants with varying endovascular experience (12 novice, 4 intermediate, and 7 expert) were recruited. Each attempted catheterization of the left renal artery on PHCM within 10 min under exam conditions. Performances were video recorded and scored using a validated scoring tool by 2 independent endovascular experts, blinded to performer status. Each participant was given a task-specific checklist score (TSC), global rating score (GRS), and overall procedure score (OPS). Finally, examiners were asked whether they would be happy to supervise the participant in theater, with each participant graded as "fail", "borderline," or "pass". RESULTS: All expert and intermediate participants completed the index procedure within the allotted 10 min; however, only one of the 12 novice participants achieved this (P < 0.0005). Endovascular novices had significantly lower TSC, GRS, and OPS than both intermediate participants and endovascular experts. There were no significant differences in TSC, GRS, or OPS between intermediate participants and endovascular experts. When participants were graded as "fail", "borderline," or "pass," there were significant differences between groups (P = 0.001). All of the intermediate and expert participants received a pass. Out of the 12 novice participants, 2 received a pass, 6 received a borderline, and 4 were failed. CONCLUSIONS: The PHCM demonstrates construct validity. Further work is required to determine its educational impact in endovascular training.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nesbitt C, Tingle SJ, Williams R, et al. Evaluating the Construct Validity of a Pulsatile Fresh Frozen Human Cadaver Circulation Model for Endovascular Training. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29787852. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2018.03.041

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。