多普勒超声与相位对比磁共振成像测量血液透析动静脉内瘘血流速率的比较
本研究在49例患者新创建的上肢动静脉内瘘中,于术后1天、6周和6个月用多普勒超声(DUS)和相位对比磁共振成像(MRI)测量近端动脉和引流静脉的血流速率。基于78对近端动脉数据和64对引流静脉数据,两种方法测值无统计学差异,按临床相关血流速率分类后一致性中等。
要点
- 近端动脉DUS测值1155±907 mL/min与MRI测值1170±657 mL/min无统计学差异(P=.812)。
- 引流静脉DUS测值1277±995 mL/min与MRI测值1130±655 mL/min无统计学差异(P=.071)。
- DUS测血流时需注意准确测量管腔直径,并避免在明显弯曲的扫描部位测量。
核心结论
- DUS与MRI在近端动脉和引流静脉测得的血流速率总体可比。
- 使用DUS测血流时需仔细关注管腔直径的准确测量,并应避免在明显弯曲的扫描部位测量。
- 作者认为本研究结果可能提高DUS测量动静脉内瘘血流速率的准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 比较DUS与相位对比MRI测量新创建上肢动静脉内瘘近端动脉和引流静脉血流速率的研究。
- 在术后1天、6周和6个月进行测量和比较。
- 近端动脉分析基于来自49例患者的78对数据,引流静脉分析基于64对数据。
主要发现
- 近端动脉DUS测值1155±907 mL/min(均值±标准差)与MRI测值1170±657 mL/min无统计学差异(P=.812)。
- 引流静脉DUS测值1277±995 mL/min与MRI测值1130±655 mL/min无统计学差异(P=.071)。
- 将血流速率分为四个临床相关类别(<300、300-599、600-1499和≥1500 mL/min)后,两种方法在近端动脉和引流静脉均显示实质性一致(Cohen κ:近端动脉0.66;引流静脉0.67)。
- Bland-Altman分析发现近端动脉和引流静脉分别有6个和4个离群值;7个离群值DUS测值高于MRI,其所有DUS扫描部位均存在大管腔或明显局部弯曲;其余3个离群值DUS测值较低,部分原因是DUS低估了管腔直径。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为使用DUS测血流时需仔细关注管腔直径的准确测量,并应避免在明显弯曲的扫描部位测量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to compare blood flow rates measured by Doppler ultrasound (DUS) and phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in patients having a hemodialysis arteriovenous fistula (AVF) and to identify scenarios in which there was significant discordance between these two approaches. METHODS: Blood flow rates in the proximal artery (PA) and draining vein (DV) of newly created upper extremity AVFs were measured and compared using DUS and phase-contrast MRI at 1 day, 6 weeks, and 6 months postoperatively. RESULTS: Blood flow rates in the PA measured by DUS (1155 ± 907 mL/min, mean ± standard deviation) and by MRI (1170 ± 657 mL/min) were not statistically different (P = .812) based on 78 data pairs from 49 patients. DV DUS flow (1277 ± 995 mL/min) and MRI flow (1130 ± 655 mL/min) were also not statistically different (P = .071) based on 64 data pairs. In both PA and DV, the two methods substantially agreed with each other (Cohen κ: PA, 0.66; DV, 0.67) when flow rates were put into four clinically relevant categories (<300, 300-599, 600-1499, and ≥1500 mL/min). The Bland-Altman analyses of DUS and MRI flow identified six and four outliers for PA and DV, respectively. Seven outliers had higher DUS than MRI flow, with all DUS scan sites having a large lumen or significant local curvature; the other three had lower DUS flow, partly due to an underestimation of lumen diameter by DUS. CONCLUSIONS: DUS and MRI flow rates are generally comparable in both PA and DV. When DUS is used for flow measurements, careful attention to accurate lumen diameter measurements is needed and scan sites with marked curvature should be avoided. Our result may improve the accuracy of DUS-measured AVF blood flow rate.
引用
- He Y, Shiu YT, Pike DB, et al. Comparison of hemodialysis arteriovenous fistula blood flow rates measured by Doppler ultrasound and phase-contrast magnetic resonance imaging. J Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29779960. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2018.02.043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。