文献速递外周动脉疾病颈动脉与弓上血管主动脉疾病

血管外科医生为何被起诉?医疗过失诉讼索赔与结果分析

Why Do Vascular Surgeons Get Sued? Analysis of Claims and Outcomes in Malpractice Litigation.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Vasc Surg · 2018-06-11

该研究分析美国Westlaw数据库中1999年1月1日至2014年12月31日血管外科医生医疗过失索赔案例,共识别785例,其中135例血管外科医生为被告。65.2%判被告胜诉,23%判原告胜诉,11.1%和解;最常见诉讼操作是外周血运重建、颈动脉干预和主动脉干预,最常见指控是「未能诊断和治疗」。

要点

  • 血管外科医生为被告的135例索赔中,65.2%被告胜诉,23%原告胜诉,11.1%和解。
  • 最常见诉讼操作:开放或血管内外周血运重建14.8%、颈动脉干预11.85%、主动脉干预11.1%。
  • 最常见指控为「未能诊断和治疗」48.9%,其次开放手术并发症31.85%。

核心结论

  • Westlaw数据库闭索赔分析显示,血管外科医疗过失诉讼最常见操作是外周血运重建、颈动脉干预和主动脉干预,而非胸廓出口综合征手术。
  • 最常见指控是「未能诊断和治疗」和「开放手术并发症」,分析这些案例特征可为提高患者安全提供框架。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析Westlaw数据库1999年1月1日至2014年12月31日录入的案例,检索词为「vascular」和「surgeon」。
  • 共识别785例,其中485例(61.8%)血管外科医生为被告或专家证人;135例(27.8%)血管外科医生为被告。

主要发现

  • 135例被告案例中,88例(65.2%)判被告胜诉,31例(23%)判原告胜诉,15例(11.1%)和解。
  • 31例原告胜诉案例中,赔偿中位数为750000美元,均值为1830000美元;从事件到判决平均时间4.8年。
  • 最常见诉讼操作:开放或血管内外周血运重建14.8%、颈动脉干预11.85%、主动脉干预11.1%、血管创伤9.63%、透析通路8.15%、静脉手术5.93%。
  • 最常见指控:「未能诊断和治疗」48.9%、开放手术并发症31.85%、过失操作25.19%。
  • 最常见损伤:死亡31.85%、大截肢23.7%、神经血管损伤14.8%、出血5.9%。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The objective of the study was to analyze causes and outcomes of malpractice claims against vascular surgeons in the United States. METHODS: Cases entered into the Westlaw database from January 1, 1999 to December 31, 2014 were reviewed. Search terms "vascular" and "surgeon" were used. Data were compiled on the allegation, subject matter, and outcome of each case. Additional data including demographics of the defendant were obtained from the U.S. News Health reports on practicing physicians. RESULTS: Of a total of 785 cases identified from the Westlaw database using the search terms "vascular" and "surgeon", 485 (61.8%) were identified where a vascular surgeon was the defendant or expert witness. Of these, 135 (27.8%) had a vascular surgeon identified as a defendant. Among these 135 cases, 88 (65.2%) were found for the defendant with 31 (23%) and 15 (11.1%) being found for the plaintiff or settled, respectively. Of the 31 cases found for the plaintiff, the median award was $750,000 and mean award was $1,830,000. Mean time from incident to verdict was 4.8 years. The most common procedures which led to litigation were open or endovascular peripheral revascularization (PR) (14.8%), carotid interventions (CIs) (11.85%), aortic interventions (AI) (11.1%), vascular trauma (9.63%), dialysis access (8.15%), and venous surgery (5.93%). The most common allegation was "failure to diagnose and treat" (48.9%), followed by complication of open surgery (31.85%) and negligent procedure (25.19%). The most common injuries reported were death (31.85%), major amputation (23.7%), neurovascular injury (14.8%), and bleeding (5.9%). CONCLUSIONS: Analysis of vascular surgery malpractice litigation in the Westlaw database revealed details regarding the subject matter and outcomes of these cases. Through this closed claims analysis, the most common procedures leading to litigation were found to be PR, CI, and AI and not thoracic outlet syndrome procedures as commonly believed. Furthermore, the most common allegations were a "failure to diagnose and treat" and "open surgical complication". Analysis of the salient features and outcomes in these cases can provide a framework for heightened awareness of issues which lead to malpractice claims and can ultimately improve patient care and safety.

来源:Ann Vasc Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Phair J, Trestman EB, Skripochnik E, et al. Why Do Vascular Surgeons Get Sued? Analysis of Claims and Outcomes in Malpractice Litigation. Ann Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29758323. doi:10.1016/j.avsg.2018.02.024

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。