术前向患者展示计算机断层扫描或血管造影图像未能提高血管手术知情同意讨论的患者满意度
一项随机对照研究将51例择期腹主动脉瘤修复或下肢血运重建患者分为标准术前讨论组和讨论加图像回顾组,发现展示CT或血管造影图像未改善患者对知情同意讨论的满意度(平均分24.9±3.02 vs 24.8±2.93,P=0.88),信任、理解和焦虑也无差异,图像回顾组讨论时间有延长趋势(8.18 vs 6.35分钟,P=0.07)。
要点
- 展示术前CT或血管造影图像未提高患者对知情同意讨论的满意度(P=0.88)。
- 图像回顾对患者信任、理解和焦虑水平均无显著影响。
- 图像回顾组术前讨论时间有延长趋势(8.18 vs 6.35分钟,P=0.07)。
核心结论
- 术前讨论时向患者展示CT或血管造影图像未改善患者对知情同意讨论的满意度,对信任、理解或焦虑水平也无影响。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照研究,纳入择期腹主动脉瘤修复或下肢血运重建患者,随机分为标准围手术期讨论组或讨论加图像回顾组,随机化隐藏并按外科医生分层。
- 共51例患者随机分组,干预组25例(讨论加图像),对照组26例;男性占69%,平均年龄70岁。
- 40%患者接受腹主动脉瘤修复,60%接受下肢血运重建。
主要发现
- 患者对讨论的满意度总体较高,图像回顾未带来额外改善(平均分24.9±3.02 vs 24.8±2.93;P=0.88)。
- 图像回顾与标准讨论相比,患者焦虑、信任水平或理解均无差异。
- 图像回顾组术前讨论时间有延长趋势(8.18 vs 6.35分钟;P=0.07)。
局限性
- 结论受限于缺乏标准化的患者理解测量工具。
- 结论受限于未测量术后结局。
- 上述两点应在未来研究中考虑。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Patient-based decision aids and other multimedia tools have been developed to help enrich the preoperative discussion between surgeon and patient. Use of these tools, however, can be time-consuming and logistically challenging. We investigated whether simply showing patients their images from preoperative computed tomography (CT) or angiography would improve patients' satisfaction with the preoperative discussion. We also examined whether this improved the patient's understanding and trust and whether it contributed to increased preoperative anxiety. METHODS: Patients undergoing either elective abdominal aortic aneurysm repair or lower limb revascularization were randomly assigned to either standard perioperative discussion or perioperative discussion and review of images (CT image or angiogram). Randomization was concealed and stratified by surgeon. Primary outcome was patient satisfaction with the preoperative discussion as measured by a validated 7-item scale (score, 0-28), with higher scores indicating improved satisfaction. Secondary outcomes included patient understanding, patient anxiety, patient trust, and length of preoperative discussion. Scores were compared using t-test. RESULTS: Overall, 51 patients were randomized, 25 to the intervention arm (discussion and imaging) and 26 to the control arm. Most patients were male (69%), and the average age was 70 years. Forty percent of patients underwent abdominal aortic aneurysm repair, whereas 60% underwent lower limb revascularization. Patient satisfaction with the discussion was generally high, with no added improvement when preoperative images were reviewed (mean score, 24.9 ± 3.02 vs 24.8 ± 2.93; P = .88). Similarly, there was no difference in the patient's anxiety, level of trust, or understanding when the imaging review was compared with standard discussion. There was a trend toward longer preoperative discussions in the group that underwent imaging review (8.18 vs 6.35 minutes; P = .07). CONCLUSIONS: Showing patients their CT or angiography images during the preoperative discussion does not improve the patient's satisfaction with the consent discussion. Similarly, there was no effect on the patient's trust, understanding, or anxiety level. Our conclusions are limited by the lack of a standardized measure of patient understanding and not measuring outcomes postoperatively, both of which should be considered in future studies.
引用
- LeBlanc D, Power AH, DeRose G, et al. Patient satisfaction with the consent discussion is not improved by showing patients their computed tomography or angiography images before they undergo vascular surgery. J Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29779961. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2018.02.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。