颈动脉内膜切除术联合近端干预的风险与结局在多机构评估中令人担忧
多机构回顾性分析62例颈动脉内膜切除术联合同侧近端血管内干预患者,围术期同侧卒中4例(6.5%)、死亡3例(4.8%),卒中合并死亡率为11.3%且各中心无差异;平均临床随访6±4年,再狭窄≥50%者20例(34%),再干预8例(14%);作者认为该技术策略应谨慎使用,选择性用于有症状、血流动力学相关串联病变且不适合开放血运重建者。
要点
- 颈动脉内膜切除术联合近端血管内干预的围术期卒中合并死亡率为11.3%。
- 平均临床随访6±4年期间再狭窄≥50%发生率为34%,再干预率为14%。
- 作者认为该技术策略应谨慎使用,选择性用于有症状且不适合开放手术者。
核心结论
- 颈动脉内膜切除术联合同侧近端血管内干预的围术期卒中和死亡发生率较高且各中心一致,与单纯颈动脉内膜切除术或颈动脉内膜切除术联合开放头臂动脉重建明显不同;再狭窄常见,近端支架或分叉处再干预也常见;作者认为该技术策略应谨慎使用,选择性用于有症状、血流动力学相关串联病变且不适合开放血运重建者。
研究设计与样本
- 2002年8月至2016年7月在三家机构通过手术记录识别接受颈动脉内膜切除术联合同侧近端血管内干预的患者,共62例,平均年龄69±9岁,女性34例(55%)。
主要发现
- 围术期同侧卒中4例(6.5%),高灌注事件2例,手术死亡3例(4.8%,其中1例死于卒中、2例死于心血管原因),卒中合并死亡率为11.3%且各中心间无差异。
- 平均临床随访6±4年,平均影像随访3±4年,任一干预部位再狭窄≥50%者20例(34%),因近端失败再干预5例、分叉失败再干预3例,合计再干预8例(14%)。
- 有症状状态、再次手术、颈动脉阻断保护、多枚支架和手术顺序与手术卒中无关;颈动脉阻断保护与较少再狭窄相关(P = .003);再次手术(P = .04)和高脂血症(P = .05)与再干预相关。
- 5年实际生存率为81%,无卒中生存率为94%,无再干预生存率为81%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为该技术策略应谨慎使用,选择性用于有症状、血流动力学相关串联病变且不适合开放血运重建者。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Approaching tandem bifurcation and brachiocephalic disease using carotid endarterectomy (CEA) with ipsilateral proximal endovascular intervention (IPE) has been promulgated as safe and durable. There have been recent concerns about neurologic risk with this technique. The goal of this study was to define stroke and perioperative risk with this uncommon procedure across multiple centers. METHODS: Between August 2002 and July 2016, patients who underwent CEA + IPE were identified by operative records at three institutions. Primary end points were perioperative stroke and death, restenosis, freedom from neurologic event, and need for reintervention. Factors related to these end points were analyzed. RESULTS: There were 62 patients who underwent CEA + IPE. The average age was 69 ± 9 years. Most were female 34 (55%); 56 (90%) were taking a statin and at least one antiplatelet agent. Bilateral internal carotid stenosis (>50%) was present in 32 (52%); 26 (42%) patients were symptomatic and 12 (19%) had undergone prior ipsilateral CEA. Bifurcation operations included longitudinal CEA/patch (38 [61%]), eversion CEA (20 [32%]), bypass graft (3 [5%]), and CEA/primary repair (1 [2%]). CEA was performed first in 53 (85%). All IPEs included stenting, with a single stent used in 58 (94%). Balloon-expandable stents were placed in the majority of patients (51 [82%]). Proximal arteries treated included the innominate (20 [32%]), left common carotid (32 [52%]), right common carotid (8 [13%]) and both innominate and right common carotid (2 [3%]). IPE was protected by carotid cross-clamp in 48 (77%). Shunting occurred in 14 (23%). There were four (6.5%) perioperative ipsilateral strokes and two hyperperfusion events. There were three (4.8%) operative deaths, one from stroke and two cardiovascular. Combined stroke and death rate was 11.3% and was not different between centers. Mean clinical follow-up was 6 ± 4 years. Mean imaging follow-up was 3 ± 4 years. Restenosis ≥50% at either intervention occurred in 20 (34%). Reintervention was performed for five proximal and three bifurcation failures (14%). Symptomatic status, redo operation, carotid clamp protection, multiple stents, and procedural order were not associated with operative stroke. Carotid clamp protection was associated with less restenosis (P = .003). Redo operation (P = .04) and hyperlipidemia (P = .05) were associated with reintervention. The 5-year actuarial survival was 81%, whereas freedom from stroke and reintervention were 94% and 81%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Perioperative stroke and death with CEA + IPE are substantial and consistent across centers. It is strikingly different from isolated CEA or CEA added to open brachiocephalic reconstruction. Restenosis is frequent, and reintervention at either the proximal stent or bifurcation is common. This technical strategy should be used cautiously and selectively reserved for those who are symptomatic with hemodynamically relevant tandem lesions and unfit for open revascularization.
引用
- Clouse WD, Ergul EA, Wanken ZJ, et al. Risk and outcome profile of carotid endarterectomy with proximal intervention is concerning in multi-institutional assessment. J Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29622356. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2017.12.069
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。