膝下逆行与经股动脉入路腔内介入治疗慢性下肢缺血的结局比较
该单中心回顾性研究比较了2012至2016年间膝下逆行腔内介入(47例,85%为 критическая肢体缺血)与常规经股动脉入路(93例,83%为 критическая肢体缺血)治疗慢性下肢缺血的结局。逆行组总体技术成功率为57%,经股动脉组为78%。两组1年和2年一期通畅率无显著差异,但经股动脉组一期辅助通畅率在1年(66% vs 46%;P = .031)和2年(56% vs 29%;P = .031)均显著更优。
要点
- 膝下逆行入路技术成功率为57%,低于经股动脉入路的78%。
- 两组1年和2年一期通畅率无显著差异。
- 经股动脉组一期辅助通畅率在1年和2年均显著优于逆行组。
核心结论
- 膝下逆行入路行腔内介入可获得与顺行介入相似的一期通畅率,且不损害入路部位。
- 在此初期经验中技术失败率较高,主要归因于再通失败。
- 技术失败后可通过重复顺行介入或外科旁路实现保肢。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性单中心研究,纳入2012至2016年因慢性下肢缺血行逆行腔内介入(REI)的患者47例(85%为严重肢体缺血),并对比同期行标准经股动脉入路的患者93例(83%为严重肢体缺血)。
- 逆行组中16例(34%)为股腘动脉介入,14例(30%)为胫动脉介入,17例(36%)为多节段介入;经股动脉组分别为41例(41%)、20例(20%)和39例(39%)。
- 逆行组入路部位包括足背动脉(26%)、小腿中段腓动脉(24%)、胫前动脉(22%)、胫后动脉(26%)和腘动脉(2%)。
- 技术失败定义为因入路失败或再通不成功而无法完成手术。
- 膝下入路和经股动脉入路均在超声或血管造影路线图引导下建立。
主要发现
- 总体技术成功率在逆行组为57%,在经股动脉组为78%。
- 平均随访20个月(范围1-45个月)。
- 两组1年和2年一期通畅率无显著差异。
- 经股动脉组1年(66% vs 46%;P = .031)和2年(56% vs 29%;P = .031)一期辅助通畅率显著优于逆行组。
- 经股动脉组1年(93% vs 83%;P = .079)和2年(91% vs 76%;P = .079)二期通畅率更高,但未达统计学显著。
关键数值与推荐
- 技术失败定义为因入路失败或再通不成功而无法完成手术。
- 一期辅助通畅率在1年时经股动脉组66% vs 逆行组46%(P = .031),2年时经股动脉组56% vs 逆行组29%(P = .031)。
- 二期通畅率在1年时经股动脉组93% vs 逆行组83%(P = .079),2年时经股动脉组91% vs 逆行组76%(P = .079)。
- 再次介入率在逆行组为41%,在经股动脉组为40%。
临床怎么用
- 膝下逆行入路行腔内介入可获得与顺行介入相似的一期通畅率,且不损害入路部位。
- 在此初期经验中技术失败率较高,主要归因于再通失败。
- 技术失败后可通过重复顺行介入或外科旁路实现保肢。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Retrograde infrageniculate access is an alternative treatment strategy for patients who have failed to respond to antegrade endovascular intervention. This study compares the outcomes of infrageniculate retrograde arterial access with the conventional transfemoral access for the endovascular management of chronic lower extremity ischemia. METHODS: This was a retrospective single-center review of retrograde endovascular intervention (REI) from 2012 to 2016. Indications for intervention, comorbidities, complications, procedural success, limb outcomes, and mortality were analyzed. Technical failure was defined as the inability to complete the procedure because of failed access or unsuccessful recanalization. Infrageniculate access and transfemoral access were obtained with ultrasound or angiographic roadmap guidance. Patency rates were calculated for technically successful interventions. RESULTS: There were 47 patients (85% presenting with critical limb ischemia) who underwent sheathless REI after failed antegrade recanalization of TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus class D infrainguinal lesions, whereas 93 patients (83% with critical limb ischemia) underwent standard transfemoral access. There were 16 (34%) femoropopliteal, 14 (30%) tibial, and 17 (36%) multilevel interventions in the retrograde group compared with 41 (41%) femoropopliteal, 20 (20%) tibial, and 39 (39%) multilevel interventions in the transfemoral group. Access sites for the retrograde group included the dorsalis pedis (26%), midcalf peroneal (24%), anterior tibial (22%), posterior tibial (26%), and popliteal (2%) arteries. Overall technical success was achieved in 57% of the retrograde group compared with 78% of the transfemoral group. Mean follow-up was 20 months (range, 1-45 months). There were no significant differences in the primary patency rates between the two groups at 1 year and 2 years. The primary assisted patency rates were significantly better in the transfemoral group at 1 year (66% vs 46%; P = .031) and 2 years (56% vs 29%; P = .031). The secondary patency rates were higher in the transfemoral group at 1 year (93% vs 83%; P = .079) and 2 years (91% vs 76%; P = .079), although this did not reach statistical significance. The rate of reintervention was 41% for the retrograde group vs 40% for the transfemoral group. Most of the reinterventions (70% in the retrograde group and 61% in the transfemoral group) were endovascular interventions for a restenosis or occlusion. CONCLUSIONS: Infrageniculate access for REI can result in primary patency rates similar to those of antegrade interventions and does not compromise the access site. Technical failure is high in this initial experience and is mostly due to failed recanalization. Limb salvage may be achieved after technical failure with either repeated antegrade intervention or surgical bypass.
引用
- Taha AG, Abou Ali AN, Al-Khoury G, et al. Outcomes of infrageniculate retrograde versus transfemoral access for endovascular intervention for chronic lower extremity ischemia. J Vasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29615358. doi:10.1016/j.jvs.2018.01.028
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。