使用助手外科医生并不能减轻主刀医生手术量对完整腹主动脉瘤开放修复术后结局的影响
该研究纳入2003至2008年间接受完整腹主动脉瘤开放修复的全部医保受益人共28,590例,构建嵌套回归模型评估主刀与助手手术量与围术期死亡率的关系。结果显示无助手时调整后围术期死亡率随主刀手术量单调变化,但使用高或低手术量助手在任何主刀手术量五分位组中均与更低的围术期死亡率无关。结论认为使用助手外科医生不能改善任何主刀手术量五分位组的结局。
要点
- 28,590例开放腹主动脉瘤修复中67.5%由单一主刀完成,32.5%有助手参与。
- 有助手病例中仅12.3%为高手术量助手,低手术量主刀更常使用助手。
- 无助手时调整后围术期死亡率随主刀手术量单调下降(Q1 4.7%至Q5 3.2%)。
核心结论
- 使用助手外科医生不能改善任何主刀手术量五分位组的结局。
- 即使高手术量助手的帮助也可能不能减轻低手术量主刀医生的不利影响。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估2003至2008年间接受完整开放腹主动脉瘤修复的全部医保受益人,共28,590例修复。
- 构建嵌套回归模型评估主刀与助手手术量与围术期死亡率的关系,并调整合并症和医院手术量。
主要发现
- 28,590例修复中19,284例(67.5%)由单一主刀完成,9,306例(32.5%)有助手参与。
- 有助手病例中12.3%为高手术量助手。
- 低手术量主刀更常使用助手(主刀Q1手术量40%;Q2 36%;Q3 34%;Q4 29%;Q5 27%;p < .01)。
- 无助手病例中调整后围术期死亡率随主刀手术量单调变化(Q1 4.7%;Q2 4.4%;Q3 4.1%;Q4 3.3%;Q5 3.2%)。
- 与无主治医师作为助手相比,使用高或低手术量助手在任何主刀手术量五分位组中均与更低的围术期死亡率无关,即使在最低手术量主刀医生实施的手术中也是如此。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE/BACKGROUND: While higher lead surgeon volume has been associated with lower mortality following open abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair, little is known about the impact of using an attending surgeon as assistant surgeon. The aim of this study was to determine whether the presence of an assistant surgeon, particularly a high volume assistant, mitigates the relationship between lead surgeon volume and outcomes. METHODS: All Medicare beneficiaries who underwent intact, open AAA repair between 2003 and 2008 were evaluated and nested regression models were constructed to evaluate the relationship between surgeon and assistant volume and peri-operative mortality, adjusting for comorbid conditions and hospital volume. RESULTS: In total 28,590 repairs were studied, of which 19,284 (67.5%) were performed by a single surgeon and 9306 (32.5%) included an assistant surgeon. Of cases with an assistant, 12.3% included a high volume assistant surgeon. Lower volume surgeons more frequently used an assistant (lead surgeon Q1 volume: 40%; Q2: 36%; Q3: 34%; Q4: 29%; Q5: 27% [p < .01]). In cases with no assistant, adjusted peri-operative mortality varied monotonically with surgeon volume (Q1: 4.7%; Q2: 4.4%; Q3: 4.1%; Q4: 3.3%; Q5: 3.2%). However, the use of a high or a low volume assistant surgeon, compared with no attending surgeon as assistant, was not associated with lower peri-operative mortality in any lead surgeon volume quintile, even among those operations performed by the lowest volume lead surgeons. CONCLUSION: Employing an assistant surgeon does not improve outcomes amongst any quintile of volume of the lead surgeon. As surgeons perform fewer open AAA repairs in the modern era, these data imply that even the help of a high volume assistant surgeon may not mitigate the detrimental effect of a lower volume surgeon.
引用
- Deery SE, O'Donnell TFX, Zettervall SL, et al. Use of an Assistant Surgeon Does not Mitigate the Effect of Lead Surgeon Volume on Outcomes Following Open Repair of Intact Abdominal Aortic Aneurysms. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29609964. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2018.02.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。