双功能超声与多门质量多普勒轮廓软件在下肢穿通静脉方向评估中的比较
这项观察性前瞻性研究对193例慢性静脉疾病患者的221条肢体行双功能超声检查,共识别774条穿通静脉,并用质量多普勒轮廓多门分析判断净流入与净流出方向。研究发现传统以 outward flow 持续超过500ms定义穿通静脉功能不全与净流出方向之间存在不重叠,传统定义受到挑战,需进一步研究确定金标准评估方法。
要点
- 仅7.7%的穿通静脉显示超过500ms的向外血流。
- 超过500ms向外血流的穿通静脉中,质量多普勒轮廓显示大腿净向外血流仅84%,小腿仅28.6%。
- 传统向外血流超过500ms定义与净向外血流不重叠,需进一步研究确定金标准。
核心结论
- 穿通静脉向外血流持续超过500ms与同一血管的净向外血流之间存在不重叠。
- 传统穿通静脉功能不全定义受到所报告数据的挑战,需进一步研究确定金标准评估方法。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性前瞻性研究,纳入193例慢性静脉疾病(C1-6EpAs,pPr)患者的221条肢体,行双功能超声检查。
- 对所有识别的穿通静脉行质量多普勒轮廓多门分析,以确定净向内和净向外血流方向。
- 比较传统脉冲波多普勒分析与质量多普勒轮廓分析,检测传统穿通静脉功能不全定义与净向外血流之间的潜在差异。
主要发现
- 双功能超声检查识别774条穿通静脉,仅7.7%显示向外血流持续超过500ms。
- 在向外血流超过500ms的穿通静脉中,质量多普勒轮廓评估显示大腿净向外血流仅84%,小腿仅28.6%。
- 在向外血流短于500ms的穿通静脉中,质量多普勒轮廓评估报告大腿净向外血流2.4%,小腿47.3%。
- 向外血流持续超过500ms检测实际净向外血流的敏感性为13.9%(9-20.1%)。
- 向外血流持续短于500ms检测净向内血流的特异性为96.4%(93.2-98.3%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim was to assess more accurately the net flow of the lower limb perforating veins (PVs). MATERIAL AND METHODS: This was an observational prospective study. Two hundred and twenty one limbs with chronic venous disease (C1-6EpAs,pPr) of 193 patients underwent a duplex ultrasound (DUS). All identified PVs were scanned also by means of quality Doppler profile (QDP) multigate analysis in order to determine their net inward and outward flow direction. A comparison between the traditional pulsed wave Doppler analysis and QDP was performed to detect potential discrepancy between the traditional definition of PV incompetence and a net outward flow. RESULTS: The DUS investigation identified 774 PVs. Only 7.7% of the PVs showed an outward flow lasting more than 500 ms. Among the PVs showing a longer than 500 ms outward flow, QDP assessment revealed net outward flow in only 84% of the PVs along the thigh and in 28.6% along the lower leg. Among the PVs showing a shorter than 500 ms outward flow, QDP assessment reported a net outward flow in 2.4% of the PVs along the thigh and in 47.3% of those along the lower leg. The sensitivity of an outward flow lasting more than 500 ms in detecting an actual net outward flow was 13.9% (9-20.1%). The specificity of an outward flow lasting less than 500 ms in detecting a net inward flow was 96.4% (93.2-98.3%). CONCLUSIONS: A lack of overlap exists between the finding of a PV outward flow lasting more than 500 ms and the net outward flow of the same vessel. The traditional definition of PV incompetence is challenged by the reported data and further investigations are required to identify a gold standard assessment.
引用
- Gianesini S, Menegatti E, Sisini F, et al. Comparison Between Duplex Ultrasound and Multigate Quality Doppler Profile Software in the Assessment of Lower Limb Perforating Vein Direction. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2018. PMID: 29503081. doi:10.1016/j.ejvs.2018.01.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。